Xenophon remains against filter

As new Liberal shadow communications spokesperson Tony Smith ponders a clear stance on ISP filtering, while independent Nick Xenophon remains firmly against the plan.

A spokesperson for Xenophon told ZDNet.com.au that the South Australian-based senator's stance on the proposed system had not been changed by the ISP filter trial report's release this week.

Xenophon has previously said the mandatory ISP filter plan was unworkable because it would slow down internet speeds and block content inaccurately. Today, he remains the only senator clearly opposed to the proposal. Greens senator Scott Ludlam said yesterday it was a "misguided" policy, and his party would seek to make "significant amendments" to the proposal.

It's not yet clear how important the independents' votes will be come 2010, given that currently the Liberal party remains in limbo over the proposed system. Fellow independent Steve Fielding has commended the plan, leaving Xenophon, in his outright rejection of the proposal, the only senator to clearly oppose the proposed amendment to the Broadcasting Act which would see all ISPs implement filtering systems by mid-2011.

Smith, Conroy's new shadow, has cautiously promised to review the filter trial report commissioned by the Department of Broadband, Communications and the Digital Economy, while opposition leader Tony Abbott yesterday did not come down on either side of the policy.

Talkback

Add your opinion

In order to post a comment, you need to be registered. (Sign In or register below)

Post your comment

Terms of Service - As a ZDNet registrant, and by using this service, you indicate that you agree to our Terms and Conditions and have read and understand our Privacy Policy.

ZDNet Australia Live

Yes thank you rossyduck, more oh me oh my, the sky is falling, YAWN...!

1 minute ago by Beta on 191K premises added to yearly NBN plan

Google challenged on Wallet PIN flaw http://t.co/h4OvjrZh via @zdnetaustralia

DesignCrowd and 99designs: UK battle - Aussie crowd-sourcing start-ups DesignCrowd and 99designs have gone head to h... http://t.co/Kw7WAfQt

by http://t.co/vmlQ0Ecb: Jury still out on govt document standards: The Australian Government Information Managem... http://t.co/SVXA3Tfr

Jury still out on govt document standards: The Australian Government Information Management Office (AGIMO) is st... http://t.co/fQzcETSY

DesignCrowd and 99designs: UK battle: Aussie crowdsourcing start-ups DesignCrowd and 99designs have gone head to... http://t.co/yHcz1cOL

DesignCrowd and 99designs: UK battle: Aussie crowdsourcing start-ups DesignCrowd and 99designs have gone head to... http://t.co/bupYryjL

Groupon CEO: 'We've cracked the code' http://t.co/pU2ae8X5 via @zdnetaustralia

DesignCrowd and 99designs: UK battle - Awesome ZDNet Stuff!

Another good write-up on #google #wallet "Google challenged on Wallet PIN flaw" http://t.co/Ge2ERdaF

Are we talking real homes connected, or as I understand it at the moment the 18200 homes is tallied if there is even a fiber in the area....

50 minutes ago by Rossyduck on 191K premises added to yearly NBN plan

DesignCrowd and 99designs' UK battle: Aussie crowd-sourcing start-ups DesignCrowd and 99designs have gone head t... http://t.co/bupYryjL

Google challenged on Wallet PIN flaw: If you lose your phone or suspect an unauthorised transaction, please cont... http://t.co/2eIfUgQH

AFL coverage rolls on http://t.co/6JEf2MyS - and now iinet say they are considering applying http://t.co/QxXIclXP #newgtlds

GPs tick real-time drug database: The Royal Australian College of General Practitioners (RACGP) has patted Healt... http://t.co/NXDLyf7k

GPs approve of real-time drug database: http://t.co/WmGXhjNO

RT @zdnetaustralia: GPs approve of real-time drug database: http://t.co/WmGXhjNO

@zdnetaustralia love songs http://t.co/5Hb6UHlx

QNAP TS-879 Pro review: http://t.co/6DVGv2Y3

Atlassian to abandon Mac App Store - Atlassian is set to turn its back on the Mac App Store come March after Apple-i... http://t.co/rOuW4BFn

QNAP TS-879 Pro: The good
Good expandabilityDeep featuresThe bad
Very priceyQNAP, along with Synology, has carve... http://t.co/o9hDtpRm

QNAP TS-879 Pro: The good
Good expandabilityDeep featuresThe bad
Very priceyQNAP, along with Synology, has carve... http://t.co/RvBjGqEG

Mobile about to hit the wall in Australia, says Einstein http://t.co/QmdHJQGL

http://t.co/suhyLMyr Google may have solved its issue with prepaid cards on Wallet, but an ... http://t.co/H5ZlzWzh http://t.co/IzWS4EFu

BrandBucket AFL to push for .brand domain: The existence of new .brand TLDs means that companies can now registe... http://t.co/Pv3vLYKK

Google challenged on Wallet PIN flaw: Google may have solved its issue with prepaid cards on Wallet, but an earl... http://t.co/OE8yKa2a

by http://t.co/vmlQ0Ecb: Atlassian to abandon Mac App Store: Atlassian is set to turn its back on the Mac App Sto... http://t.co/AdpoyMXJ

Atlassian to abandon Mac App Store: Atlassian is set to turn its back on the Mac App Store come March after Appl... http://t.co/r9zrkTzg

YouTube has the facility to identify copyright music on videos, so why cannot others do so.

2 hours ago by Patanjali on Social networks can't be forced to spy

http://t.co/1chaoDYC http://t.co/ow8uuaLq

Google challenged on Wallet PIN flaw http://t.co/NM3BOMWR http://t.co/4Y45q0qC

Google challenged on Wallet PIN flaw http://t.co/d8vXO6fc

Google challenged on Wallet PIN flaw http://t.co/JT0h4NBA

Google challenged on Wallet PIN flaw - ZDNet Australia http://t.co/KjbXsFtg

End to end integration - EMC ties together datacenter and business IT management http://t.co/yjJbIjfB

Google challenged on Wallet PIN flaw: Google may have solved its issue with prepaid cards on Wallet, but an earl... http://t.co/Z4H1BzJ9

@Google challenged on Wallet PIN flaw - @ZDNet Australia : http://t.co/Fa9MS5Nw

LOL, -1 for saying if Conroy wants a filter it should apply to him too... You anti-NBN children should read the comments, not just the n...

2 hours ago by Beta on Let the internets run free, bosses

Orange bringing Facebook to all phones in Africa http://t.co/Efw289lV

umm, also,just want to put this out there, why, if we are currently doing fairly well (the aussie dolar), are we following America down t...

3 hours ago by Gabriel_Clerens on Australia to sign ACTA tomorrow

Whoa never heard about this - wth? hasn't there been MASSIVE controversy about ACTA and PIPA and all that crap???

3 hours ago by Gabriel_Clerens on Australia to sign ACTA tomorrow

Agree btone, live by the sword!

3 hours ago by Beta on Let the internets run free, bosses

"Every time NBN opens up a new market, it's a brand new market for us. A brand new market we've never sold into," he said. So where are...

3 hours ago by Beta on Primus CEO ready to take on Telstra

This story has been voted 10 times in the last 24 hours!

3 hours ago, Telstra, NBN showdown over Tassie devices

This story has been voted 15 times in the last 24 hours!

4 hours ago, AGIMO reveals cautious cloud guides

This story has been voted 5 times in the last 24 hours!

4 hours ago, Primus CEO ready to take on Telstra

The delightful irony of Senator Conroy being unable to access the ACL website due to a parliamentary filter is a dream that may yet event...

4 hours ago by btone on Let the internets run free, bosses

This story has been voted 5 times in the last 24 hours!

4 hours ago, Vocus expands Sydney datacentre

Well I guess Ballmer dances are sexy to some, but after Redmond broke IE8 for Brazilian and local XP users with yet another critical upda...

4 hours ago by btone on Making security sexy

This story has been voted 10 times in the last 24 hours!

4 hours ago, AGIMO reveals cautious cloud guides

This story has been voted 20 times in the last 24 hours!

4 hours ago, Synology DS2411+

This story has been voted 5 times in the last 24 hours!

5 hours ago, Telstra, NBN showdown over Tassie devices

This story has been voted 5 times in the last 24 hours!

5 hours ago, ACCC shoe thrown, Telstra puts it on other foot

This story has been voted 10 times in the last 24 hours!

5 hours ago, Synology DS2411+

This story has been voted 5 times in the last 24 hours!

5 hours ago, Making security sexy

How ironic that even Telstra disagrees with you etsmith. http://www.asialink.unimelb.edu.au/video/business/telstra_ceo_asia_is_where_we_...

5 hours ago by Beta on ACCC shoe thrown, Telstra puts it on other foot

Telstra shareholders are partly in Australia and partly overseas, so what is the point of your 'little reminder'? If you were trying to ...

5 hours ago by socrates on ACCC shoe thrown, Telstra puts it on other foot

if NEHTA's supposedly rigorous quality and testing regime overlooked something a simple as the versioning on a document, it doesn't reall...

5 hours ago by Coenbros on E-health specifications back in testing

Telstra is an Australian owned (by the people) company, little reminder!

5 hours ago by etsmith on ACCC shoe thrown, Telstra puts it on other foot

I would have thought that an editor would know that "lead" (pronounced 'lehd') is a very heavy and soft metal and "led" is the past tense...

5 hours ago by mahlon on E-health specifications back in testing

I also think all this "suing" is very bad however I understand that if you do not aggressively defend your copyright/patents then you wil...

5 hours ago by harryinthesoup on Apple again looks to block Samsung

In addition to business cards, how do you advertise your online business(s)? I sell on ebay, etsy u0026 my web site. Every ...

17 hours ago by Offeftbib on Broadband Speedtest

Highlights the problem that such lockin only seem to be considered when reaching a 'monopoly situation, which of course any business migh...

19 hours ago by Patanjali on Cisco asks EU to rethink Microsoft-Skype

Oh, and many have found that the 64GB microSD cards work in the Note, as they seem to do in most late model phones, except you-know-whose.

20 hours ago by Patanjali on Samsung Galaxy Note

I have a EU Note, and am using it on Telstra without problem on HSDPA+ (speed same as their Elite wireless modem). I bought it for the u...

20 hours ago by Patanjali on Samsung Galaxy Note

Facebook Activity

Keep up with ZDNet Australia

ZDNet Events Calendar

ZDNet Events Calendar