Telstra-NBN deal timing called into question

Questions have been raised as to whether the deal between the National Broadband Network Company (NBN Co) and Telstra can be completed by 20 December, at which point the deal would be terminated.

The government, NBN Co and Telstra signed definitive agreements in June, which see Telstra lease its ducts to NBN Co and move its customers onto the network in return for $11 billion. This deal was dependent on a shareholder vote and ACCC approval of a structural separation undertaking (SSU) from Telstra, which lays out how the company will separate its business units so that they don't operate in a vertically integrated fashion.

Reports in the Australian Financial Review and The Australian this morning quoted sources saying that delays with providing a revised structural separation undertaking would put a spoke in the wheels of the deal, as the Australian Competition and Consumer Commission (ACCC) now no longer has enough time to deliberate over any undertaking it receives before the deadline.

However, Telstra released a statement this morning saying that although it had yet to submit a revised structural separation undertaking to the ACCC, it is still in deliberations with the ACCC, and it has an eye on the time that it has remaining.

"Telstra is currently considering the time needed to complete the conditions precedent. Should an extension to the end date be required to provide the ACCC time to conclude its consideration of the SSU, then Telstra will communicate it to shareholders when such an agreement is reached with NBN Co."

Much of the NBN roll-out depends on this deal, as NBN Co executives have said that without Telstra's ducts, it would cost a lot more to build.

Talkback

The accc should have never been allowed to negotiate, the government should hasve brought in a new body to deal with this.

Lets hope wiht accc mucks this upo that what happens the government will dismantle the accc

bob hobbob hob December 2nd, 2011
Report offensive content Reply (+4) (-12)

Telstra and the NBN Co will decide if an extension in time is necessary for the ACCC to make its decision on the Telstra RSS.

Considering the calamitous result of a Telstra/NBN Co not being able to consummate the proposal I would think Senator Conroy will expedite proceedings.

sydneylasydneyla December 2nd, 2011
Report offensive content Reply (+2) (-11)

The ACCC has made some poor decisions on the roll out of the NBN (eg points of interconnect). Is it coming to the end of its life? In any case why should a decision as big as the break up of Telstra in the bigger plan of the NBN rollout over ten years or more, have to be made in just a few more days.

GoldieGoldie December 4th, 2011
Report offensive content Reply (+6) (0)

Goldie the decision on the Telstra/NBN Co agreement must be made with urgency because the future of the Gillard Government depends on it.

It is critical that the NBN roll-out is at an advanced stage at the next election so as to allow the Labor Party to claim a successful delivery to the Australian people.

Without the Telstra agreement, and heavens forbid, with Telstra as a competitor, the proposed NBN would be be greatest disaster for Australia and the Labor Party.

With all due respects to the ACCC, the Government is the master of the ACCC, and through Senator Conroy must advise the ACCC to reach an early decision.

sydneylasydneyla December 4th, 2011
Report offensive content Reply (+1) (-12)

The ACCC is set up as an independent statutory body. It's a slippery slope once the government start dictating terms to it.

mwil19mwil19 December 5th, 2011
Report offensive content Reply (+6) (0)

Not dictating mwil19 just requesting, there is a vast difference.

sydneylasydneyla December 5th, 2011
Report offensive content Reply (0) (-8)
Add your opinion

In order to post a comment, you need to be registered. (Sign In or register below)

Post your comment

Terms of Service - As a ZDNet registrant, and by using this service, you indicate that you agree to our Terms and Conditions and have read and understand our Privacy Policy.

ZDNet Australia Live

Why can't the entire world pull there finger out and use the same spectrum for mobiles in every country?! Think about it...... it would...

0 minute ago by TelstraMonopolist on ACMA probes 1.5GHz for spectrum shortfall

A compelling argument to avoid the @Facebook #IPO http://t.co/4n4cYzQD

Salesforce cruises in Q1; Eyes $3 billion in annual revenue - ZDNet (blog): Salesforce cruises in Q1; Eyes $3 bi... http://t.co/BkDopuOH

Dropbox, Skydrive, google drive - which one? I use Dropbox - http://t.co/AwNkVh4i

Public cloud execs dish out Top 10 tips for enterprises building hybrid clouds: "Enterprise-class" or "cloud cla... http://t.co/gaieq8zt

diablo 3 Diablo 3, the long-sought, the next edition of the highly rated action RPG game series is now available in stores. ...

1 hour ago by TrillaSal on iiNet undercuts Internode with NBN pricing

Shut up and take my Money.....

1 hour ago by Nesr on Portal turret comes alive in robot project

RT @quiip: 38% of kids on Facebook are under the minimum age of 13 http://t.co/tF1zSw4J

Nerds rule the economy #bizmanager #agency - http://t.co/xYbeetey

Interesting: Sprint: Trade in old iPhone, get $100 towards iPhone 4S http://t.co/CgUvf3dc

HANA - we cannot abandon 99 per cent of our customers who sit on IBM's DB2, Oracle, NextDB, Microsoft, etc.
http://t.co/V3lfzU9O

DNS poisoning the 'thin end of a wedge' - http://t.co/Zn5FRKqD - want more info - call #Kamloops PC Doctor

DNS poisoning the 'thin end of a wedge' - ZDNet Australia http://t.co/kcbReNVA #australia #technews

http://t.co/YFNfzPu9
@bryancapri

RT @crispinkerr: Charlie Tomeo from #webroot speaking on panel for #zdnetlive http://t.co/SXa1Es0L http://t.co/8F9YkMl4

@CNET @ZDNet Ah, well .. What to say :P

The implications of schools demanding access to student mobile devices - ZDNet (blog) http://t.co/7yfu5Tya #mobiledevices

cheap louis vuitton http://www.fadlouisvuittonbags.com/
louis vuitton luggage http://www.fadlouisvuittonbags.com/

5 hours ago by outlet on Kodak files for bankruptcy, sues Samsung

A robotics student at Pennsylvania State University.. Portal turret comes alive in robot project http://t.co/9aVkcZx2

propecia treatment Finasteride 1 mg http://buy-finasteride5mg.com/ propecia proscar avodart cheapen prices

6 hours ago by bricleefforie on Intel programming tools reach new 64-bit chips

I began to read Project PM. BB will make a writer out of you. I must commend Mr. Brown enthusiastically on his remarkable intellect. I...

6 hours ago by Appomattox on Anonymous 'crippled': where to for hacktivism?

i own a Toshiba satellite M 300 and was wondering if i was able to upgrade the hard drive, the ram and processor from the factory specifi...

6 hours ago by Cheech Bang on Toshiba Satellite Pro M300

i own a Toshiba M 300

6 hours ago by Cheech Bang on Toshiba Satellite Pro M300

DNS poisoning the 'thin end of a wedge' http://t.co/7NNVmeIc

NVIDIA pushes GPU technologies to the cloud http://t.co/qJJ0vlyZ

Unfortunately it is hard to get the word out to mainstream Aussies, when mainstream media is against the NBN, as they see it a threat to ...

7 hours ago by Beta on Five pros and cons of the NBN

Portal turret comes alive in robot project http://t.co/fXS4Fdxd via @zdnetaustralia

@BarretBrownLOL discusses the state of #anonymous pretty much spot on the situation but he still has that ego http://t.co/W82JLUa6

hoodwinked, welcome to the NBN critics nirvana... You pay more, I pay more and the NBN critics pay more, but that's ok, because the NBN ...

8 hours ago by Beta on Five pros and cons of the NBN

Finding PCI-compliant cloud providers http://t.co/XsgoGbE6 via @taibot

iph4s, n8, lumia900. n9, onex camera camparison and vote on best pics http://t.co/JhKJaSWz

Windows 8: Does Metro actually work? http://t.co/OWPokDN0

Dude, your on the South Brisbane exchange which Telstra have given consumers a lovely taste of what "their" fibre offering would be. No o...

8 hours ago by rtfmoz on Five pros and cons of the NBN

The Pro/Cons are for the NBN. You are not on the NBN, you are on Telstra fibre. You have just added another Pro. 6. The NBN provides fi...

8 hours ago by Pilfer on Five pros and cons of the NBN

The broader view on cloud security http://t.co/VX0V8bZx

DNS poisoning the 'thin end of a wedge' - http://t.co/is0pwJKw

I'd like to make a comment on Pro/Cons 2 & 4 and say that my experience is that those assertions are false. My suburb and the residents o...

9 hours ago by hoodwinked on Five pros and cons of the NBN

How government does BYOD: Allowing users to bring their own devices (BYOD) needn't be difficult, even for the go... http://t.co/tp4mtW9K

RT @maverickwoman: Yammer gets into gamification with Badgeville: http://t.co/faPDDVYr #gamification RT @mobilelearning #yam

The Zionist tool Facebook going to trade on the stock market soon http://t.co/RTbiN2Rd

AusCERT 2012: tanks and toilets: Day one of the AusCERT conference was full of funny quotes and big military bli... http://t.co/eE6KXOwo

RT @KateKendall: 'Is it time for a C-level social media executive?' --> http://t.co/pj5RHesJ

What do you think @FirebrandTalent ?? “@KateKendall: 'Is it time for a C-level social media executive?' --> http://t.co/D7f0QevU

RT @KateKendall: 'Is it time for a C-level social media executive?' --> http://t.co/pj5RHesJ

iOS still tops Android in Australia: Google http://t.co/7D1OP2cQ

ISP brands UK internet spying plans 'pointless' http://t.co/F7wqlvqh

How to build a vibrant cloud community - ZDNet http://t.co/27IJmGl1

Fibretech make a very strong point. It is a pity the Gillard government cannot get this message across. The benefits of decentralisation ...

10 hours ago by Magnus on Five pros and cons of the NBN

did this go to 'net at 4pm Eastern Australian time?

13 hours ago by sierratango on AusCERT Tough Talk live panel

Will an audio pod be available for the "Tough Talk: BYO Disaster?"
st956703@iinet.com.au

13 hours ago by sierratango on AusCERT Tough Talk live panel

Hubert you were right, he doesn't live here... He lives in Detroit, he's in his 20's, has short blonde hair and a tattoo on his left sho...

13 hours ago by Beta on Malaysia held up as NBN king

"If you need indesputable proof of this reality you have only to look at the abject failure of the TRANSACT fibre optic network in the Au...

14 hours ago by pbrooks1 on NBN FUD: will Abbott ever learn?

great webinar on BYOD

14 hours ago by jonuzij1 on AusCERT Tough Talk live panel

See paranoid we shouldn't have wasted money on asphalting all those roads after all... lol!

14 hours ago by Beta on Malaysia held up as NBN king

This story has been voted 15 times in the last 24 hours!

1 day ago, AusCERT 2012 kicks off: photos

This story has been voted 5 times in the last 24 hours!

1 day ago, Up in cyber arms: AusCERT 2012

This story has been voted 5 times in the last 24 hours!

2 days ago, NBN FUD: will Abbott ever learn?

This story has been voted 10 times in the last 24 hours!

3 days ago, Apple drops 4G iPad label in Australia

This story has been voted 5 times in the last 24 hours!

3 days ago, Apple drops 4G iPad label in Australia

Facebook Activity

Keep up with ZDNet Australia

ZDNet Events Calendar

ZDNet Events Calendar