Sweet bypass for student finger scanner

Voted by

darrenpauliOctober 27th, 2010

A NSW high school has installed "secure" fingerprint scanners for roll call, which savvy kids may be able to circumvent with sweets from their lunch box.

Gummi bears

(Munich 154 image by Betsy Weber, CC2.0)

The system replaces the school's traditional sign-in system with biometric readers that require senior students to have their fingerprints read to verify attendance.

Henry Kendall High School, on the NSW Central Coast, has pitched the system to parents as a convenient way for students to clock in and out of school during their irregular hours.

Principal Bob Cox told the ABC that the system was preferred over swipe cards, which students can abuse by signing-in for each other.

But a litany of fingerprint scanners have fallen victim to bypass methods, many of which are explained publicly in detail on the internet. The hacks could potentially be used by students to make replicas of their own fingerprints, or lift those of others from imprints left on the reader.

Japanese cryptographer Tsutomu Matsumoto used gelatin, the ingredient in Gummi Bears, to forge a replica finger that fooled 11 fingerprint scanners during tests in 2002. Gelatine has virtually the same capacitance as a finger's skin, meaning it can fool scanners designed to detect electrical charges within the human body.

"Simply form the clear gelatine finger over your own [which] lets you hide it as you press your own finger onto the sensor. After [the reader] lets you in, eat the evidence," BT chief technology officer Bruce Schneier said of the so-called Gummi Bear attack.

Chris Gatford, director of penetration testing firm HackLabs, has foiled biometric fingerprint scanners before.

"Whether it can be hacked depends on how clever the device is. If it is a reasonable quality, it will look for blood flow and heat, but entry-level models do not."

The NSW Department of Education said in a statement that the software does not store digital copies of fingerprints, but creates templates of unique characteristics.

This should prevent stored fingerprint images from being stolen, but would not prevent students bypassing machines.

The department said the decision to adopt the technology is up to the school, and participation in the scheme is optional.

Fingerprints can be lifted from a variety of surfaces, and then scanned, printed and applied to receptacle mediums which are used to trick scanners.

Finnish researcher Ton van der Putte hacked a scanner used for checkout payments in a chain of stores based in the Netherlands in 2008, while another Finnish researcher Mikko Kiviarju lifted prints (PDF) from Microsoft's now defunct Fingerprint Reader.

Talkback

Ton van der Putte appears to be a dutchman instead. And if you put the gelatin around your fingers an expensive scanner will still "see" enough veins and blood flow to accept the fake as the genuine article.

But what nobody in the industry dares say, is that this shows that biometrics are unsuitable for casual identification. To match you to fingerprints left at the scene of a crime, fine. But to identify you so you can access your bank account or anything else of importance to you, no.

The problem with the current state of identification is that in order to identify yourself you must surrender your entire identity, and that is enough information to forge your identity, too. Biometrics don't change that. The property that changes is that now identity can be more easily forged because you leave your fingerprints literally everywhere, unless you're willing to always, every day of the year, wear gloves when outside your own home, and at the same time it becomes nigh-on impossible to assume a different "identity" should your old one get stolen.

So where your bank card or your credit card might get stolen, and then you cancel it as fast as you can, if that happens to your fingerprints you can't just cancel your fingerprints. Not unless you're willing to give up your access to your own bank account forever. Now isn't that a wonderful choice this use of technology forces upon you?

CellarCellar October 28th, 2010
Report offensive content Reply (+13) (0)

A response to this article may be read at:
http://securlinx.blogspot.com/2010/10/old-gummi-bear-trick.html

If you're interested in a contrary point of view, please consider reading.

SecurLinx BlogSecurLinx Blog October 29th, 2010
Report offensive content Reply (+1) (0)

Went to Disneyland and the rest of the theme parks in Orlando this summer - my brother in law had no trouble at all pretending to be my wife, using her ticket, and placing his finger on the fingerprint security glass. When using them legitimately though they failed often, and staff had to let us in anyway. In case any of the folks are Disney are upset we never had more people than tickets - he was instead of, not as well as my wife !

northernhecklernorthernheckler October 29th, 2010
Report offensive content Reply (+4) (-1)

Seriously, how many kids would a) go to that much effort, and b) rely on it actually working.

xBeaniexBeanie November 2nd, 2010
Report offensive content Reply (0) (0)

Having read that SecurLinx blog post (and why couldn't you have posted it here, hm?) I see two separate issues: First, the use of biometrics, regardless of where. To that my earlier post up above. That alone ought to be enough, but in case it isn't: Second, you raise the social environment and wonder about the cost.

Well, I say, if you have to resort to (alternatively, hide behind) technology to keep track of the kids in your social environment, you're not doing terribly well with providing that social environment. I expect (non-substitute) teachers to know their pupils well enough that once the year is underway they needn't do a long and tedious roll call. If you can't manage that the school is probably too big and needs sizing down. If you have a lot of substitute teachers because, say, the environment is too stressful so you have too many teachers calling in sick, you're again not usefully running your school.

Not because of roll call efficiency, but because teaching effectively requires that the teacher knows his pupils, knows how to get through to them and make the lessons stick. Everybody is different and everybody learns differently. You can't fix that with a fingerprint reader. Thus any ROI and TCO questions of that fingerprint reading system, which you vaguely raised but didn't address, are pretty much irrelevant.

Yes, it's oh-so-convenient and oh-so-cheap technology. But it's not very good tech and even if it was it's not very appropriate if you care about running a school. It's all the rage nowadays, but that doesn't automatically make it a good idea. And in fact I say it's not a good idea.

Experience has shown us already that money is quite irrelevant, as throwing a couple billion at a (US) state's teaching apparatus mainly caused swimming pools and admin buildings and saw the kids' scores _drop_, whereas the lone contrary guy managed with lots of creative spit and baling wire to pay his teachers more on a smaller-than-usual budget and have the kids get better results. That is what better motivated teachers and kids will make happen.

It would be a much better idea to keep classes small and ensure kids of roughly the same level and same learning capability are in the same classes, focus on teaching each kid as much as he or she can stand and maybe a little more, fast-track the smartest, remedy the slow'uns, that sort of thing, than to try and find cost savings in high technology that, should it manage to work properly, conveniently makes trackable entities out of the kids. We ought to be trying to teach them to be valuable members of society, not nicely trained compliant sheep.

CellarCellar November 4th, 2010
Report offensive content Reply (+2) (0)

Hi SecurLinx Blog, I read your article and thought you raised some important points. Robust debate is always welcome, so I appreciate your time. I placed quotations around "secure" to indicate the flaws of the term, especially when applied to biometrics.
I also referred to those kids who could bypass the system as "savvy" because they would need to be skilled to do so, irrespective of whether doing so is right or wrong.
Thanks again for the comments!
Darren

darrenpaulidarrenpauli November 4th, 2010
Report offensive content Reply (0) (0)

@darrenpauli,

I have spoken to a number of people in the Australian who perform penetration testing and they all confirmed that they have never undertaken physical attacks simply because IRL this would be noticed quickly but people entering and exiting the entry point.

Furthermore, if Chris Gatford had foiled biometric fingerprint device(s) in past then he would publish the make and model like the researchers quoted in your article.

cmlhcmlh November 8th, 2010
Report offensive content Reply (+6) (-1)
Add your opinion

In order to post a comment, you need to be registered. (Sign In or register below)

Post your comment

Terms of Service - As a ZDNet registrant, and by using this service, you indicate that you agree to our Terms and Conditions and have read and understand our Privacy Policy.

Tech Blueprint

ZDNet Australia Live

Before accusing me of fudging the figures, that was the percentage in April, the latest available. It seems that as the advantage of the ...

2 hours ago by GregoryB1 on NBN FUD: will Abbott ever learn?

Currently about 50% of connections are at the 100Mb/s rate.
As a consequence, ARPU is significantly higher than the projected figures.

2 hours ago by GregoryB1 on NBN FUD: will Abbott ever learn?

Currently about 50% of connections are at the 100Mb/s rate.
As a consequence, ARPU is significantly higher than the projected figures.

2 hours ago by GregoryB1 on NBN FUD: will Abbott ever learn?

Wireless currently carries less than 2% of total internet data traffic. Simply to carry the existing traffic, we would need 50 times the ...

2 hours ago by GregoryB1 on Blowing the digital dividend on wireless NBN

The stupidest part about a wireless solution for the burbs is that it will actually cost more to put an antenna on the roof to get the si...

2 hours ago by GregoryB1 on Blowing the digital dividend on wireless NBN

The problem is not range of the cell in the urban areas where Turnbull wants LTE instead of fibre, it is the number of users. In urban ar...

2 hours ago by GregoryB1 on Blowing the digital dividend on wireless NBN

After the Second World War, the pursuit of pleasure domains the entire world atmosphere, Lancel (Lancel) to adapt rapidly into the demand...

3 hours ago by PokArrackpask on Spam sees Westnet blocked by BigPond

RT @DellEnterprise: Dell Secureworks talks with ZDNet about Android's biggest #security flaws - http://t.co/LSFLQVFq #infosec

NBN users opt for 100Mbps: Customers are picking the top fibre plan that is available on the National Broadband ... http://t.co/sjtFSU3g

"Customers are picking the top fibre plan that is available on the National Broadband Network (NBN), more than a... http://t.co/M3P24Htn

Another thing I found so misleading here is the step on how you assume to make the USB bootable . (The NTLDR needs to be renamed to USBNT...

5 hours ago by WindowsAnalyzer on Boot Windows XP from a USB flash drive

You can also use the help of these links, just incase your stuff failed, I probably got Windows build by using the Pebuilder as per the i...

5 hours ago by WindowsAnalyzer on Boot Windows XP from a USB flash drive

RT @CorrieB: An iPad for every child: Inevitable or impossible? http://t.co/I7uS8l9s Thx to @timbuckteeth for this; http://t.co/jxkqIRIp

RT @MADinMelbourne: roxon "will enable more families to access credit" @MLolderandwiser: Privacy Act amendments http://t.co/Mv4c7PC2 via @zdnetaustralia

NBN users opt for 100Mbps - ZDNet Australia http://t.co/fLfHMzPn #australia #technews

RT @konradski: Whaddayaknow - turns out Wi-Fi CAN interfere with a plane's navigation systems http://t.co/ospQCU2S

This story has been voted 5 times in the last 24 hours!

9 hours ago, NBN's Tassie upgrade to cost $1.3 million

Sorry no deal Cinders, I'd rather send my money to someone and watch them desperately try to stop the NBN as this has much better enterta...

9 hours ago by Hubert Cumberdale on NBN users opt for 100Mbps

What else can you expect from a Dodo customer?

9 hours ago by Hubert Cumberdale on NBN users opt for 100Mbps

NBN users opt for 100Mbps - Communications - News - ZDNet Australia: NBN users opt for 100Mbps - Communications ... http://t.co/btB9gKWg

NBN users opt for 100Mbps http://t.co/xKqEb4bE via @zdnetaustralia

Biometric bugs too dangerous for public? http://t.co/8JLz5tdF via @zdnetaustralia

Oh please dont be unkind, I gotta have some fan's. btw I agree I dont set the standard, but who does I wonder?

11 hours ago by Doubt on NBN users opt for 100Mbps

You agree but give him thumbs down... I think you'd better take the medication before one of your alter ego's Fred/Frank/Frergers appear...

11 hours ago by Beta on NBN users opt for 100Mbps

Exploring: http://t.co/rT7RPZLA

+1

11 hours ago by Beta on NBN users opt for 100Mbps

War talk dominates #AusCERT 2012 - http://t.co/SlBpMj0c - #security #cyber

So we agree it was a stupid idea and even stupider comment then ;-)

11 hours ago by Beta on NBN users opt for 100Mbps

Not you obviously ;-)

And stop giving yourself thumbs up FFS.

11 hours ago by Beta on NBN users opt for 100Mbps

Ok Beta, understand now, just one point who sets the standard?

11 hours ago by Doubt on NBN users opt for 100Mbps

Oh no Beta you misunderstand me. I like my waterfront home and deep water jetty, it's those "other" people who can move to Willunga.

11 hours ago by Doubt on NBN users opt for 100Mbps

I agree with you Magnus, but really most people like living on the coastal fringe.

11 hours ago by Doubt on NBN users opt for 100Mbps

Travel Tech Q&A: Skyscanner's Ewan Gray http://t.co/vYexrDwu #ipad

Exploring: http://t.co/YNVjdrct

Exploring: Travel Tech Q and A: Skyscanner's Ewan Gray: Ewan Gray, Skyscanner's director for Asia ... http://t.co/bNLCyobv #ICTChallenge

Exploring: Travel Tech Q and A: Skyscanner's Ewan Gray: Ewan Gray, Skyscanner's director for Asia ... http://t.co/HEPuJgyt #ICTChallenge

#NewSouthWales ditches registration stickers 4 light #vehicles in favour of #technology http://t.co/xX5N0Rp9

Another use is city based top surgeons using 8K resolution monitors to provide real-time assistance to country surgeons and doctors to op...

12 hours ago by Magnus on NBN users opt for 100Mbps

Anonymous hacks Reliance's Internet filtering server - ZDNet (blog) http://t.co/uObU1HBP http://t.co/0UBXxwX4

Which Windows will make for a better tablet? http://t.co/4mAHg850

Listening to @stilgherrian cover AusCERT and cyberwar, http://t.co/6lGUEz8H

Travel Tech Q and A: Skyscanner's Ewan Gray http://t.co/VN5tGJzC

#Westpac Board goes paperless with #Ipads with #Tabula #App http://t.co/duxuj2fd #Cybersecurity #Bank

Microsoft is serious about open source??? http://t.co/mqQGgta7

@joedamato just try varying caps randomly. Maybe they do this http://t.co/1FN5FwYv

NSW outlines datacentre migration plans - Hardware - News - ZDNet Australia http://t.co/OQfUl0D1

"on the new fast Internets everyone wants the fast plan" #orly #nareally #yarly http://t.co/kvfCa84A

Chrome overtakes IE: does it matter? http://t.co/e4SILk8a

A ZDNet study showed that British Facebook users are drunk in 76 percent of their photos.

The HDMI cable ripoff and why retail is really dying http://t.co/eFT7zEW7

Travel Tech Q and A: Skyscanner's Ewan Gray http://t.co/IUysbyKf

Travel Tech Q and A: Skyscanner's Ewan Gray http://t.co/V7vL5QB9

ZDNet reports Microsoft launches its own social service http://t.co/VJS5BkwF

by http://t.co/vmlLt4bh: Travel Tech Q and A: Skyscanner's Ewan Gray: Ewan Gray, Skyscanner's director for Asia P... http://t.co/4bfDRXo4

Travel Tech Q and A: Skyscanner's Ewan Gray http://t.co/CtNlVWN7

Travel Tech Q and A: Skyscanner's Ewan Gray: Ewan Gray, Skyscanner's director for Asia Pacific, shares some of h... http://t.co/ZxjpmqiM

This story has been voted 12000 times in the last 24 hours!

2 days ago, Is Bill Gates a great leader?

Facebook Activity

Keep up with ZDNet Australia

ZDNet Events Calendar

ZDNet Events Calendar