Breaking News: Internode: leave us, but it's not our fault

ZDNet / SAP / Story

SAP user group not independent enough?

By Renai LeMay, Delimiter.com.au on March 9th, 2010

commentary While SAUG's CIO Council is a laudable initiative on the surface, it has a strong smell of vendor floating around that it just can't shake.

For starters, the announcement was issued by SAP's own public relations agency, Burson-Marsteller (BM).

I have nothing against BM — there are some great people that work there, and they do a good job for SAP. But its involvement in SAUG's release appears to show that at some level, SAP was involved in the announcement. This idea is further backed up by the lone sentence in the statement that "SAP is actively supporting the CIO Council and will be actively involved at an executive level".

That statement, no doubt, would have had to be approved by SAP Australia executives — maybe even the local managing director, Tim Ebbeck — as most of the vendor's public statements undoubtedly are. And it doesn't make clear exactly what SAP's involvement will be.

The question needs to be asked — would SAUG go through BM to issue a statement, say, critical of SAP prices rises — a stance which the UK SAP user group has taken from time to time? If so, this would be a clear conflict of interest.

The agenda for the first meeting of the CIO Council in March also rang sour for me. Sure, SunLife Financial Group CIO Mark Edward Ross will be presenting and will likely give insights into how the company's implementations are going. This is the sort of thing other CIOs love to hear about. However, after Ross has presented, it looks like Mike Foster of Fujitsu (a key SAP partner) and SAP's own Mark Hettler will be presenting.

I don't know whether the pair will be allowed to sit in on all the meetings of the CIO Council, but if I know anything about CIOs, I know that they will not talk frankly and openly about their IT projects while vendors (or even journalists like myself) are in the room.

I have nothing against either — Foster in particular is a lovely bloke who I've spoken to at various points over the years. But their attendance at the meeting seems to me to be not in the best interests of the CIOs, who of course can call either at any time for an update.

I've attended a number of conferences over the years that have had certain sections closed to both the press and vendors for exactly this reason. There are some secrets of customer-vendor relationships that are best kept behind closed doors — at least if the CIO concerned wants to keep his job.

Talkback

Independent

Should be called the SAP Promotion group.

SAP is a dead-weight - inflexible, costly, etc - people buy it because everyone else does and they also think it is state of the art.

It is amusing when CFO's make the decision to put SAP in as it tends stuff up the rest of an organisation because they believe the sales mumbo that SAP does everything....it does not.

AnonymousAnonymous March 10th, 2010
Report offensive content Reply (0) (0)
Add your opinion

In order to post a comment, you need to be registered. (Sign In or register below)

Post your comment

Resource Centre Useful content from our premier sponsors

ZDNet Australia Live

@icanseeit 7 per cent wireless and satellite...

A user from Adelaide measured 4581kbps @ Broadband Speedtest.

7 minutes ago, Click here to find out how fast your internet speed is.

RT @icanseeit: And I though the NBN was all fibre and therefore better than coalition plan! “@zdnetaustralia: now we hear bout NBN Co's wireless component

Salesforce takes Chatter to smartphones: Salesforce has released its collaborative networking platform, Chatter, i... http://bit.ly/aeJhWa

Let My Smartphone Go!: The majority of popular mobile phones run on one of five operating systems: Symbian, Blackb... http://bit.ly/cfx5ex

And I though the NBN was all fibre and therefore better than coalition plan! “@zdnetaustralia: now we hear bout NBN Co's wireless component

HulloMail 1.2 for BlackBerry, ZDNet latest review http://bit.ly/d8jeMZ

RT @zdnetaustralia: Telstra completes the majority of a $280m fibre-optic broadband roll-out for NSW DET http://bit.ly/aBmMVm

Let My Smartphone Go! http://bit.ly/9gADuO

RT @zdnetaustralia: With regional Aus getting NBN priority, the cost will not increase http://bit.ly/aAiLXD

Google Instant: search as you type http://dlvr.it/4xtrs (ZDNet)

RT @agusnadhi: Quo Computers' liquid-cooled Core i7 maxQ2 runs OS X, Linux, Windows 7 ...: Still, Quo will tell you the biggest s... http://bit.ly/bdJXfw

RT @phonedevs: Qualcomm looking to Android for initial future developments - ZDNet UK (blog) http://bit.ly/ceYFYk

T-Mobile reveals more details of the upcoming G2 Android device: By Matthew Miller | September 8, 2010, 9:54pm PDT... http://bit.ly/dz8n5g

Freedom of expression online: How far should it go?: Amongst many things, he is a good-for-nothing, pink sock wear... http://bit.ly/bFq3ap

NBN roll-out ramps up post election and rejig adds no cost: Conroy http://bit.ly/cnNdET

Well id rather see the 40 billion put into making my trip to work 20 minutes faster and reducing the price of houses so that i can actual...

32 minutes ago by rbosward on NBN roll-out rejig adds no cost: Conroy

Internode's Simon Hackett says his company will lose customers to BigPond because of wholesale port costs. http://bit.ly/cDosCu

Oh you're back again old faithful, LOL! So you're no longer claiming "binding agreement" and now asking about a "for...

41 minutes ago by RS on Telstra walks while telco D-team squawks

Even all the spectrum in the world added together is hundreds of times slower than a single hairline strand of Fiber. 100,000,000,000Mbp...

51 minutes ago by Duideka on Much cheaper NBN wins it by a whisker

The nature of wireless is that any frequency band is inherently "capped" - there is a maximum ability to carry data regardless of...

1 hour ago by Marshall2 on Much cheaper NBN wins it by a whisker

I too am a Telstra customer. I even bought a few TLS shares when they went ex-div a few weeks back (after doing likewise previously and s...

1 hour ago by RS on Telstra 'price squeeze' claims go to ACCC

NBN roll-out rejig adds no cost: Conroy http://bit.ly/d4LIDI via @zdnetaustralia #NBN #openinternet

brando1... If WiMAX2 does actually do as they claim in 2012, great. I'm sure all the NBN supporters (like me) who welcome technology ...

1 hour ago by RS on Exetel chief: 'God help us all' on NBN

Australia has the strictest laws in the world on Telstra controlling it. If you want to see what happens without control go to America. O...

1 hour ago by Brumby on Telstra 'price squeeze' claims go to ACCC

There is some evidence the US Tea Party are bankrolled by The Koch Brothers, as reported in the New Yorker http://www.newyorker.com/repor...

1 hour ago by Blackbobs on Govt, use tech or have tech use you

It's easy to throw comments like that out there. It seems sort of reasonable on the face of it doesn't it? Things are always impr...

1 hour ago by neil_mc on Much cheaper NBN wins it by a whisker

Speaking of political leanings... It was said to be $26B!

1 hour ago by RS on Much cheaper NBN wins it by a whisker

Oh look, I've gained a new troll, LOL... I have NBN leanings big difference what yourr excuse? Don't see you bagging Scott, hmmm...

1 hour ago by RS on Abbott pledges vigilance on NBN stuff-ups

And am I wrong? Is Australia listed on the ASX? Well... Anyway... it has been projected by McKinsey/KPMG that the NBN will be $26B... A...

1 hour ago by RS on Abbott pledges vigilance on NBN stuff-ups

Thanks TimC3, broken promises aside it seems that you either agree or re-iterate everything I have said in this article and previous arti...

1 hour ago by Peter Carr on Open letter against taking Gershon funds

Does that mean that Telstra have been denied access to exchanges by, ah Telstra and Telstra were part of the case against Telstra, where ...

1 hour ago by RS on Telstra 'price squeeze' claims go to ACCC

And you hang other people for their obvious political leanings :)

1 hour ago by mwil19 on Abbott pledges vigilance on NBN stuff-ups

photos of the NBN rollout - http://bit.ly/dy7vrC

Telecoms giant BT is hiring 300 staff across the Asia Pacific region http://bit.ly/bKRHRD http://fb.me/GHfzPjUU

Check out Google Instant search. They say it's going to make searching easier, but is it distracting? Let us know... http://fb.me/DIPEBhCz

RT @fugazied: Fibre in Tasmania #NBN http://www.zdnet.com.au/houses-linked-up-in-tassie-nbn-photos-339304569.htm?omnRef=NULL

This story has been liked 5 times in the last 24 hours!

TechLines 6: email is a jack of all trades http://zdnet.com.au/339305877/ - so I have too much email because I have no process???

RT @zdnetaustralia: Telstra completes the majority of a $280m fibre-optic broadband roll-out for NSW DET http://bit.ly/aBmMVm

Realestate.com.au adopts cloud email http://zdnet.com.au/339305876/

Internode: leave us, but it's not our fault http://zdnet.com.au/339305865/

Internode: leave us, but it's not our fault http://zdnet.com.au/339305865/

really? i'll believe it when i see it ... "ACTA warms to ISPs?" http://j.mp/bcu7uh

Information security systems failed to prevent a Police analyst from leaking information on raids to bikie gang? http://ow.ly/2AYYA

Qld Uni start-up scores MRI grant: Magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) research is about to get another boost in Quee... http://bit.ly/bFw6fk

ISP: TPG announce unlimited Internet plans: http://bit.ly/damLGa

ACCC takes Optus to court (again) for misleading promos http://bit.ly/awhbMJ

Online hospitality tool nets venture capital: One of Australia's most prominent Web 2.0 investment groups, Future ... http://bit.ly/dt1hm0

Aussie software scores at Soccer World Cup: While Australia may not have finished well at the 2010 FIFA World Cup,... http://bit.ly/ctlKeu

@BigPondTeam - ok it's on http://bit.ly/b6Sl8G - they always tell employees last!

Looks like Windsor & Co will be keeping an eye on the roll out of the NBN http://bit.ly/c2kjKU

Keep up with ZDNet Australia

LinkedinLinkedin Join our network

RSS FeedsRSS Feeds Subscribe now

NewslettersNewsletters Subscribe today

TwitterTwitter Follow us

Sponsored resources