Who's spying on you? 6 anti-spyware apps tested

F-Secure Internet Security 2005

F-Secure submitted a suite of security-blocking, filtering, and scanning-orientated applications. The spyware component was sourced from the people at Lavasoft, and is identical to Ad-Aware. The rest of the suite includes antivirus, firewall, anti-spam, and parental control components.

Installation takes quite some time and part of the process involves removing other similar applications (eg antivirus and anti-spyware programs). This could potentially be a problem if you are one of those paranoid users who does not trust a sole application to provide the level of security required on the desktop. Once the system has been installed and updated, the user could be forgiven for wondering where the spyware application is located. After a short period of poking and prodding, we discovered that it is in fact a separate standalone application launched from the start menu. One would expect that the programmers at F-Secure could have at least put a shortcut button on their main user interface window to allow operators to launch the anti-spyware application directly from the console.

For the purposes of this review, we are focusing solely on the anti-spyware capabilities of the product and not on the additional applications and features bundled in the suite.

As already mentioned, F-Secure sourced and re-badged the Ad-Aware application from Lavasoft. This being the case what we mention later for Ad-Aware can be considered to be the same for F-Secure's Anti-Spyware application.

F-Secure's suite of applications appears to be geared fairly and squarely at the SOHO or home-user market, particularly with the inclusion of applications such as parental controls. Therefore, from the standpoint of a business magazine review, there is very little that can be said except that F-Secure made a very good decision to bundle Lavasoft's technology and experience with their suite instead of trying to re-invent the wheel. If a home user or SOHO is looking for a complete security suite then consideration should be given to F-Secure's Internet Security 2005 package.

  Spyware
  CA eTrust PestPatrol
  F-Secure
  Lavasoft Ad-Aware
  McAfee AntiSpyware
  Trend Micro OfficeScan
  Websense

 Specifications
 How We Tested
 Sample Scenarios
 Editor's choice
 About RMIT

Product F-Secure Internet Security 2005
Price Euro 79.90
Vendor F-Secure Corporation
Phone +358 9 2520 0700
Web www.f-secure.com
 
Interoperability ½
Bundled with quite a lot of applications but the system is standalone especially in respect to the anti-spyware component being the same as Ad-Aware.
Futureproofing
Great array of features for a standalone application.
ROI
A reasonable price considering the bundled applications, but if one is just after a spyware scanner then perhaps it would be better to consider Ad-Aware on its own.
Service ½
12 months appears to be the standard warranty with all these applications which is very good for software applications in general.
Rating ½

Advertisement

Talkback 7 comments

    Nastyware - a collective descr ...Anonymous -- 16/11/04

    Nastyware - a collective descriptive term...

    You obviously have not seen th ...Anonymous -- 20/12/04

    You obviously have not seen the very recent advice from Pest Patrol, which now is no longer supported, but has been replaced (free of charge to current users) with a new Spyware called "Counterspy". I have had it installed for about a week and although I was happy with Pest patrol, Counterspy does have a number of improved features
    Ken Hillier

    Spyware John Taylor -- 22/12/05 (in reply to #120111444)

    Tosh and nonsense, CA are announcing a new version of PestPatrol to be released soon and have incorporated the product into the new Integrated Threat Manager which has both a/v and Anti-Spyware. I sit on the CA Advisory Council as a UK memeber so I should know!) You are not by chance an old PestPatrol Reseller who now sells Counterspy are you Ken? Very cheap swipe at CA Ken, very cheap indeed!

    eTrust Pest Patrol contains th ...Anonymous -- 26/12/04

    eTrust Pest Patrol contains the virus Win32.Bagle.4.Gen@mm. Everytime the program updates it re-download the same virus. Buyer beware on this application.

    Spyware John Taylor -- 22/12/05 (in reply to #120111608)

    Yes, and what is more the tooth fairy met with Santa yesterday to discuss leaving a tube of Flouride Toothpaste under the pillow of everyone in the World on Saturday Night! Come on, lets not get silly here. You really think the World's 3rd largest Software Company ships a virus in it's products? hmmm

    we use officescan 6.5 in our c ...Anonymous -- 28/02/05

    we use officescan 6.5 in our company and even though i've followed all the steps to make sure that the spyware part of officescan is active, we still get spywares! most notable is those spywares like gator.b, gator.c.

    i'm the network administrator and i'm thinking of dumping officescan for a better one.

    readability blind bob -- 27/12/05

    black ink on a dark blue background. Good job!

    AND it never tells me my comment was submitted!

Add your opinion

Back to top

Featured