Patch management: 4 packages tested

By
11 June 2004 03:52 PM
Tags: security, radia, novadigm, boundary, languard, shavlik, prism, gfi
Novadigm Radia Patch Manager

Novadigm Radia Patch Manager Radia Patch Manager came in as a late submission. It arrived already pre-installed on a Windows 2000 notebook running SQL Server. The Patch Manager was made up of three components, the Patch Manager, Application Analyzer, and System Explorer.

It's a relatively large package and possibly the most complex we looked at. We were informed that this product is suited to environments with over 1000 machines and can be installed on Windows NT/2000 Server and Windows Server 2003 and clients running Windows 95, 98, NT, 2000, and XP. As for UNIX and Linux support, Novadigm has advised us it is currently working on this one. At the moment it only supports Microsoft operating systems and applications. However you can push out third-party software as executables that can run on client machines.

We were surprised that the Patch Manager has to install an agent prior to running any vulnerability assessments so the main software can better manage the client machines. The installation of agents was quite messy and can be time consuming.

The user interface was also a little primitive. The design would have been greatly improved if all the features could be accessed from one window. We had constantly switch windows to run the other components. Navigating within the applications was simple enough, but the information could have been displayed better. We had to scroll down long pages, which can make you forget what options are available at the start of the page. We are advised Novadigm is currently working on this.

On a better note, the product does an excellent job managing the full life cycle of patches from acquiring, testing, assessing, deploying, applying, reporting, and maintaining patches. In particular, the way the product does patch testing is quite useful. You can use the Application Analyzer to test to see whether there will be any conflicts between two or more applications or machine resources. Also, this product can open up a patch executable from Microsoft and reveal to you files that are of concern. Most other packages don't give you that level of detail.

To some extent this product also does asset management. It can give you a list of machines found on your network as well as what hardware components they are running.

This package doesn't do port scanning or virus scanning like some of the products we looked at, however out of all the dedicated patch management packages, this one seemed to be the most complete in terms of controlling and deploying patches. We wish Novadigm had made the interface more usable and made it an agentless solution. This product is quite often compared with Altiris Client Management software as both packages do more than just patch, however Altitis wasn't able to supply a product for us to review as the new version wasn't ready yet.

This package was well priced considering it does end-to-end patch management. Telephone and e-mail support doesn't come free, however, it will cost you 18 percent of the list price.

Product Novadigm Radia Patch Manager
Price Appox. US$100 per server; US$35 per desktop
Vendor Extended Enterprise Solutions
Phone 02 9956 8555
Web www.ees.net.au
 
Interoperability
Runs on Windows machines.
Futureproofing
Offers end-to-end patch management.
ROI
Affordably priced and does more than any of the others.
Service
24x7 support for 18 percent of list price per year. Onsite support and training available.
Rating
  Patch management

  GFI LanGuard
  New Boundary Prism
  Novadigm Radia
  Shavlik HFNetChkPro

 How We Tested
 Network VirusWall
 Microsoft SMS
 Sample Scenario
 Editor's Choice
 About RMIT

Advertisement

Talkback 0 comments

Back to top

Featured