Server hassles are virtually solved

T&B Editor's choice Editor's choice: VMware DSX Virtual Server 3

  Virtual servers
  Microsoft
  VMware

 Specifications
 How we tested
 Editor's choice
 About RMIT

We were worried about selecting an Editor's Choice for two reasons. The first is that Microsoft Virtual Server 2005 is only a Release Candidate, not the production version. The final version was due to be released in enough time for us to review it before our deadline, but the release date appears to have slipped slightly. However the code appeared very stable and it is doubtful any significant extra features will find their way into the product by the time the final verision is released. As a result, Microsoft also couldn't give us pricing information in time for the deadline, so unless we use a crystal ball there is no tying down an ROI score.

In summary, both are excellent products. VMware's product is quite idiot-proof with its various wizards while Microsoft's requires more effort during initial VM creation.

Both support a wide range of guest VMs, although Microsoft only provides technical support for Windows guest OSes, while VMware is far more liberal, covering Linux, Netware, and many others.

Microsoft Virtual Server can only exist on a Windows 2003 Server or XP Pro Host while GSX Server is far more cosmopolitan with host software for many flavours of Linux.

In general terms we found GSX Server VMs to have higher performance than Microsoft's Virtual Server VMs, but in some cases Virtual Server has better VM control such as CPU resource allocation; you have to step up to VMware's ESX Server to gain this functionality. But that itself is an important point; if you do require additional functionality above and beyond GSX server, it's available in ESX Server.

Unless Microsoft was literally (not virtually) giving away Virtual Server 2005, we wouldn't reassess our decision to give the Editor's Choice to VMware's GSX Server 3.

This article was first published in Technology & Business magazine.
Click here for subscription information.

Advertisement

Talkback 0 comments

Reviews by category

Latest Videos

Sponsored content

Power Centre - Content from our premier sponsors

Blogs

Tags

Back to top

Featured