Tech Guide: Buying a CD/DVD burner

Understand CD/DVD burners | Specs that matter | Select the right format | Which discs to buy | What you can do with your burner | The software you need
The software you need
If you've recently purchased a new disc-burning drive or a new computer with a drive installed, you may find yourself with more burning questions than answers. Don't sweat it. We've selected eight of the most commonly bundled programs -- meaning that they come for free with the purchase of a drive.

Bundled software, however, is often a "lite" version of a larger application, meaning that it doesn't have all the features of the full release. Still, even the lite versions include all of the tools that most users will need for burning all kinds of discs; for capturing, importing, and exporting video; and even for some basic audio and video editing. If you're looking for more robust audio, video, and photo-editing capabilities or superior backup options, you should consider upgrading to one of these full suites.

Software options: Ahead Nero | BHA B's Recorder | Iomega HotBurn | NTI CD & DVD Maker | Pinnacle Instant CD/DVD | Roxio Easy Media Creator | Roxio Toast | Sonic MyDVD

Ahead Nero

Ahead Nero
Ahead Nero
Nero 6.0 Ultra is packed with powerful features for creating and backing up discs, as well as editing movies, burning DVDs, and much more. Beginners should look to the included Nero Express component, which features helpful wizards to walk you through the basics of disc creation. Once you're more experienced, try Nero Burning ROM, which provides a fuller range of options.

Nero's bundled, OEM versions lack the fullness of the Ultra suite and can't create as many types of discs or handle as many formats. They're also likely to be missing key applications, such as Burning ROM and BackItUp (depending on which version you have). To upgrade from the OEM, you'll need to visit Nero online and purchase an upgrade serial number for US$49.99 (~AU$70).

BHA B's Recorder Gold 7.0 Basic

While not the most eye-catching or full-featured disc-creation tool around, B's Recorder is a good basic program that will guide users through all of the standard tasks, including creating audio, data, or video CDs and copying discs. Unlike most of the other programs in this guide, B's Recorder has no reduced-feature OEM version, so there's nothing to upgrade.
Iomega HotBurn Pro

If you've purchased an Iomega burner, you have HotBurn Pro, Iomega's own disc-creation software. It's a beautifully simple program, letting newbies make music and data discs or copy CDs, although you won't find video-editing or backup tools -- Iomega often bundles other software for that. There's no lite version of HotBurn Pro, but if you have an older version, you can upgrade for US$39.95 (~AU$56) by using the software's Update button.
NTI CD & DVD Maker 6.7 Platinum

NTI CD & DVD Maker 6.7 Platinum
NTI CD & DVD Maker 6.7 Platinum

At first glance, NTI CD & DVD Maker seems like only a basic burning app, covering the standard disc-creation functions. But dig a little deeper, and you'll find that it offers some other tasks, such as creating CD Extra discs and recording live audio. Power users will want to look to Nero or Easy Media Creator, but CD & DVD Maker is a good choice for beginners who want to start simple. The OEM version of CD & DVD Maker includes only a trial version of the MP3 encoder, and it's missing live audio recording. You can upgrade to the full version for US$29.99 (~AU$42) from the NTI Web site.

Pinnacle Instant CD/DVD 8.0

Pinnacle Instant CD/DVD 8.0
Pinnacle Instant CD/DVD 8.0

In its latest version, Pinnacle has added a new, colourful front end to the suite -- making project selection easier for new users -- as well as excellent tools for movie authoring and audio and video playback. In our full review, though, we noted that the interface can be more confusing than that of other apps and that we had problems with audio playback.

There are two OEM versions of Instant CD/DVD: one has everything but the unlimited MP3 encoder, while the second lacks both that and the ability to play commercial DVDs. You can upgrade the lite version for US$19 (~AU$27) on Pinnacle's Web site.

Roxio Easy Media Creator 7.0
Roxio Easy Media Creator 7.0
Roxio Easy Media Creator 7.0

Along with Nero, Roxio Easy Media is one of the giants of disc creation. Once known as Easy CD & DVD Creator, the suite changed its name as its focus broadened to include media editing and authoring. With it, you can create the standard disc types, as well as edit photos, capture and edit video, edit audio, and much more. Easy Media Creator's superfriendly interface, which clearly lays out the suite's many tools, is superior to Nero's, although it has a buggy history. For more, read our full review.

OEM versions of Easy Media Creator will vary, but version 6.0's OEM lacks tools for label creation, sound editing, and DVD playback, and it has limited DVD authoring, while the 7.0 version, which hadn't been released as of this writing, lacks MP3 encoding, the sound editor, several video-editing tools, and the ability to make scheduled backups, among other things. The price varies depending on which OEM you have, but it's typically around US$69.95 (~AU$99).
Roxio Toast 6.0 Titanium

Roxio Toast 6.0 Titanium

Roxio Toast 6.0 Titanium 7.0

Most Mac users will find their disc-creation needs satisfied by Apple's own iLife suite, but those who want a broader range invariably reach for Roxio Toast. It combines an intuitive interface with a wide range of burning tools; we like it so much that our full review criticised only its documentation and support. With a clear, tabbed interface, Toast lets you select from the basic disc-creation tasks.

Toast Lite can handle a narrower range of formats and disc types, and it can't burn VideoCDs or SVCDs. It also lacks the Toast It app, which lets you burn directly from the desktop, as well as apps for importing LPs and cassettes or for scheduling backups. Upgrades to the full version are usually US$69.95 (~AU$99).

Sonic MyDVD Studio Deluxe

Sonic MyDVD Studio Deluxe

Sonic MyDVD Studio Deluxe

Sonic's clear, friendly interface makes it ideal for beginners, and the suite rated highly in our full review. The two main applications are MyDVD, which has limited video-editing functions but is wonderful for authoring DVDs, and RecordNow, an all-purpose disc-burning tool. Neither has the extensive range of Nero or Easy Media Creator, but Sonic MyDVD Studio Deluxe will certainly satisfy most users.

OEM versions of MyDVD vary in what they offer. All of them lack the movie player, which would have required an extra licensing fee, and some have limited video-editing, burning, and backup capabilities. The fee to upgrade to the full version varies depending on which OEM you have, but it is generally 20 to 30 percent less than the full price.

Advertisement

Talkback 13 comments

    Very useful article. Thanks. ...Anonymous -- 21/06/04

    Very useful article. Thanks.

    Any chance you could do an article reviewing some budget external cd burners - I need one but I have no idea which to buy. Help! Thanks.

    Excellent explanation of the g ...Anonymous -- 30/06/04

    Excellent explanation of the gobbledy **** abbreviations used with DVD's and the various format limitations; e.g. I had no idea DVD-RAM was physically fragile.

    Great article, now I won't emb ...Anonymous -- 02/12/04

    Great article, now I won't embarrass myself by referring to DVD-R as "minus R" thanks so much!

    Clear and informative presenta ...Anonymous -- 10/12/04

    Clear and informative presentation.

    You need to update this. 16x a ...Anonymous -- 14/12/04

    You need to update this. 16x are the norm now and on the table relating to speed vs time is N/A

    In this article you have incor ...Anonymous -- 05/01/05

    In this article you have incorrectly defined 1MB as equalling 100KB, it should be 1MB = 1000KB.

    "Shorthand terms are used to describe how fast a burner performs. A CD-RW drive rated 52X/32X/52X can write a CD-R at 52X, write a CD-RW at 32X, and read a CD at 52X. The X stands for times the original transfer rate of a disc. For a CD, the original transfer rate is 150 kilobytes (KB) per second; so 52X would equal 7.8 megabytes (MB) per second, and 32X would come to 4.8MB per second (1MB equals 100KB)."

    Well written and informative.E ...Anonymous -- 10/01/05

    Well written and informative.Easy to understand for a novice. I'm looking to buy a dvd burner soon and this answered many question I had.

    THANK YOU. I CAN NOW ANSWER SO ...Anonymous -- 04/07/05

    THANK YOU.
    I CAN NOW ANSWER SOME OF MY WIFES QUESTIONS ABOUT WHY WE NEED A NEW DVD DRIVE.

    Avoid "Heartburn Pro" Unhappy user -- 07/08/05

    Just wanted to share my experience with Iomega and HotBurn pro. I bought a Iomega USB CD-RW drive and HotBurn Pro came with it.

    HotBurn pro copies music CD's OK (no violation, this is a CD a friend made and gave me permission to copy), but I couldn't make a readable data CD, even when I slowed down write and added a simulated burn step.

    I tried to update the product using the "update" button, but the download didn't work, I got a message that "your current installation is not valid".

    Worse, I had to put up with registering at iomega.com just to GET the download. I think companies should make it as easy as possible to download bug fixes, and registrations are a mistake (especially if the sofware doesn't work after all the rigamarole).

    So, I'm deinstalling Hotburn pro, and given how nosy Iomega was, will be looking for companies that just want my money, rather than my money and my email...

    website John Stephens -- 01/12/05

    One of the most difficult websites to read. Blue writing on blue background: bad design

    DVD Burners / player compatability Victor Johnson -- 31/12/05

    Very informitive, however-Can I transfer digital camara pics w/a dvd burner to dvd disk format that can be played/viewd with the common home/tv type DVD-Player. Do I need a special software and/or dvd burner? Anyone, please. Thankx

    Advice on dvd burners Desmond Auer -- 14/05/07

    The article is well thought out and presented. Just one query, what are the hardware requirements for using a dvd-burner?
    I have a Pentium 1.1 GHz processor with 256 MB RAM running Windows XP and I was told that my machine would not be able to run a dvd burner. Is this correct?
    If so, what ARE the requirements for a computer to run a dvd burner?

    iSkysoft DVD Creator for Mac sese -- 10/05/09 (in reply to #320079329)

    iSkysoft DVD Creator for Mac is the best dvd burner for mac users,This mac dvd burner can convert all formats such as MP4, M4V( without DRM protection), MPA, MPG, MPEG, MOV,3GP, 3GP2, FLV, MOV,VOB, DAT, TS, TP, TRP, M2TS, AVI, MKV to DVD on Mac OS X.
    http://youtubetodvd.blogspot.com/

Add your opinion