Tech Guide: Buying a CD/DVD burner

Understand CD/DVD burners | Specs that matter | Select the right format | Which discs to buy | What you can do with your burner | The software you need
Specs that matter

Key specs:  X ratings | Format wars

X ratings
Shorthand terms are used to describe how fast a burner performs. A CD-RW drive rated 52X/32X/52X can write a CD-R at 52X, write a CD-RW at 32X, and read a CD at 52X. The X stands for times the original transfer rate of a disc. For a CD, the original transfer rate is 150 kilobytes (KB) per second; so 52X would equal 7.8 megabytes (MB) per second, and 32X would come to 4.8MB per second (1MB equals 100KB). Note that those are only the maximum ratings, however -- you'll need a 52X-rated CD to capitalise on the drive's speed potential; depending on the task, the disc, and the drive, the transfer rate still may not reach 52X. Another thing to know about the max rating: at 16X and above, CD-RW drives write in speed zones. In other words, they start off slow and incrementally increase their speed until they're writing at full velocity.

Generally, a drive's X ratings tell how fast it records, rewrites, and reads -- in that order.

Newer DVD burners have more and more formats and speeds to list.

DVD drives are rated the same way. A DVD burner rated 4X/2X/12X can write DVDs at 4X, rewrite at 2X, and read at 12X. However, newer DVD drives are increasingly referred to by their plus and dash recording speeds only. For example, the latest batch of burners is often called 8X8 drives -- meaning that they can write both DVD+R and DVD-R at 8X. This is to distinguish them from the first batch of 8X drives which burned DVD+R at 8X but DVD-R at only 4X.

DVDs' original 1X transfer rate is 1.385MB per second -- much faster than CDs' -- and an 8X DVD drive can transfer data at a whopping 11.08MB per second. Like CD-RW drives, DVD writing at 8X and above occurs in speed zones.

There are currently only two DVD speed zones, and the upshift occurs early in the process, so the difference between the rating and the actual time to write a disc is pretty close. Take note that DVD-RAM's 1X transfer rate is about 700KB per second, making it much slower to burn than other DVD media.

The table below translates CD and DVD speeds into their approximate burning times. (Notice that performance gains diminish despite higher ratings, due to the aforementioned speed zones.)

 HOW TIME FLIES: APPROXIMATE CD AND DVD BURNING TIMES
X rating Time to burn a 650MB CD Time to burn a 4.7GB DVD
1X 80 minutes 58 minutes
2X 40 minutes 29 minutes
2.4X (DVD+RW only) --- 24 minutes
4X 20 minutes 14.5 minutes
8X 10 minutes 8.5 minutes
12X 6 minutes N/A
16X maximum 5 minutes N/A
24X maximum 3.3 minutes N/A
32X maximum 3 minutes N/A
40X maximum 3 minutes, 20 seconds N/A
48X maximum 2 minutes, 40 seconds N/A
52X maximum 2 minutes, 20 seconds N/A

It's widely held that CD burners, at 52X, have already reached their maximum speed, but DVD burners are expected to continue to climb to 16X. Unless scientists develop new technology (which they might), 52X and 16X seem to be as fast as the respective media can spin without breaking up.

Format wars
Trying to make sense out of the alphabet soup of DVD formats -- the mysterious jumble of pluses and minuses, Rs and Ws, and RAMs and ROMS -- may trigger a high-school algebra flashback. We won't spend too much time on why these various formats exist -- suffice it to say that competing vendors have differing philosophies and market agendas. Panasonic and the DVD Forum are primarily responsible for the original DVD-RAM and DVD-R/RW formats, while Philips and a splinter group, the DVD Alliance, have pioneered the DVD+R/RW alternative.

DVD Forum DVD Alliance
We have the DVD Forum and its rival, the DVD Alliance, to thank for the confusion that surrounds DVD formats.

CD formats are fairly simple and come in two flavours: CD-R recordable and CD-RW rewritable (note that the dash isn't spoken; it's pronounced CDR and CDRW). DVD's mish-mash of standards features no less than five major formats, however: DVD-R (pronounced DVD-dash-R), DVD-RW (DVD-dash-RW), DVD+R (DVD-plus-R), DVD+RW (DVD-plus-RW), and pronounced-as-spelled (no dash) DVD-RAM.

All five DVD formats offer roughly 4.7GB of storage, but they differ in some subtle and not-so-subtle ways. DVD-R and DVD+R may be written to only once, but they offer high compatibility with drives and set-top DVD players. DVD+RW and DVD-RW can be written and erased approximately 1,000 times, but they are a little less compatible with some DVD players.

Sturdy DVD-RAM can be written and erased up to 100,000 times, although it's a slower media, and few drives or set-top players can read it. Furthermore, DVD-RAM often comes in protective cartridges that you must remove before inserting the discs into most drives. In removing a DVD-RAM from its cartridge, unfortunately, you significantly cut its 100,000-rewrite rating, due to the likelihood of damage from handling and elements.

Advertisement

Talkback 13 comments

    Very useful article. Thanks. ...Anonymous -- 21/06/04

    Very useful article. Thanks.

    Any chance you could do an article reviewing some budget external cd burners - I need one but I have no idea which to buy. Help! Thanks.

    Excellent explanation of the g ...Anonymous -- 30/06/04

    Excellent explanation of the gobbledy **** abbreviations used with DVD's and the various format limitations; e.g. I had no idea DVD-RAM was physically fragile.

    Great article, now I won't emb ...Anonymous -- 02/12/04

    Great article, now I won't embarrass myself by referring to DVD-R as "minus R" thanks so much!

    Clear and informative presenta ...Anonymous -- 10/12/04

    Clear and informative presentation.

    You need to update this. 16x a ...Anonymous -- 14/12/04

    You need to update this. 16x are the norm now and on the table relating to speed vs time is N/A

    In this article you have incor ...Anonymous -- 05/01/05

    In this article you have incorrectly defined 1MB as equalling 100KB, it should be 1MB = 1000KB.

    "Shorthand terms are used to describe how fast a burner performs. A CD-RW drive rated 52X/32X/52X can write a CD-R at 52X, write a CD-RW at 32X, and read a CD at 52X. The X stands for times the original transfer rate of a disc. For a CD, the original transfer rate is 150 kilobytes (KB) per second; so 52X would equal 7.8 megabytes (MB) per second, and 32X would come to 4.8MB per second (1MB equals 100KB)."

    Well written and informative.E ...Anonymous -- 10/01/05

    Well written and informative.Easy to understand for a novice. I'm looking to buy a dvd burner soon and this answered many question I had.

    THANK YOU. I CAN NOW ANSWER SO ...Anonymous -- 04/07/05

    THANK YOU.
    I CAN NOW ANSWER SOME OF MY WIFES QUESTIONS ABOUT WHY WE NEED A NEW DVD DRIVE.

    Avoid "Heartburn Pro" Unhappy user -- 07/08/05

    Just wanted to share my experience with Iomega and HotBurn pro. I bought a Iomega USB CD-RW drive and HotBurn Pro came with it.

    HotBurn pro copies music CD's OK (no violation, this is a CD a friend made and gave me permission to copy), but I couldn't make a readable data CD, even when I slowed down write and added a simulated burn step.

    I tried to update the product using the "update" button, but the download didn't work, I got a message that "your current installation is not valid".

    Worse, I had to put up with registering at iomega.com just to GET the download. I think companies should make it as easy as possible to download bug fixes, and registrations are a mistake (especially if the sofware doesn't work after all the rigamarole).

    So, I'm deinstalling Hotburn pro, and given how nosy Iomega was, will be looking for companies that just want my money, rather than my money and my email...

    website John Stephens -- 01/12/05

    One of the most difficult websites to read. Blue writing on blue background: bad design

    DVD Burners / player compatability Victor Johnson -- 31/12/05

    Very informitive, however-Can I transfer digital camara pics w/a dvd burner to dvd disk format that can be played/viewd with the common home/tv type DVD-Player. Do I need a special software and/or dvd burner? Anyone, please. Thankx

    Advice on dvd burners Desmond Auer -- 14/05/07

    The article is well thought out and presented. Just one query, what are the hardware requirements for using a dvd-burner?
    I have a Pentium 1.1 GHz processor with 256 MB RAM running Windows XP and I was told that my machine would not be able to run a dvd burner. Is this correct?
    If so, what ARE the requirements for a computer to run a dvd burner?

    iSkysoft DVD Creator for Mac sese -- 10/05/09 (in reply to #320079329)

    iSkysoft DVD Creator for Mac is the best dvd burner for mac users,This mac dvd burner can convert all formats such as MP4, M4V( without DRM protection), MPA, MPG, MPEG, MOV,3GP, 3GP2, FLV, MOV,VOB, DAT, TS, TP, TRP, M2TS, AVI, MKV to DVD on Mac OS X.
    http://youtubetodvd.blogspot.com/

Add your opinion