DAS the stuff: 5 RAID units tested

By Steven Turvey, RMIT IT Test Labs
04 February 2005 04:25 PM
Tags: nexsan, promise, scsi, channel, das, fibre, t&b, hp

DAS the stuff
Introduction
Adaptec SANbloc
HP Modular Smart Array
Nexsan ATABeast
Promise VTrack 15100
EMC iClariion AX100
Specifications
How we tested
What is fibre channel?
RAID Definitions
Nexsan on cooling
Editor's choice
About RMIT

Adaptec SANbloc 2Gb RAID

Price:
AU$27,990 (14GB drive, 1.022TB, dual-controller configuration)
AU$17,349 (7-drive, 1.022TB, single-controller configuration).

Test Configuration:
14 x Seagate Cheetah ST336605FC Fibre Channel drives (0.514TB raw) in a RAID 5 configuration.

Drive specs:
  • Capacity: 36.7GB

  • Rotational speed: 10000 RPM

  • Average seek: 5.1ms

  • Buffer: 4MB

  • MTBF: 1,200,000 hours
The SANbloc is a 3RU unit that can accommodate a maximum of 14 Fibre Channel SCSI drives. The case itself is very impressive in terms of its construction as it is solid cast aluminium, the other vendors cases are pressed steel.

The test unit had a swag of redundant and hot-swappable components including two RAID controllers with battery-backed cache, dual power supplies, and two fan cooling modules, each with a small battery pack to ensure the enclosure is cooled even if all external power sources fail. This ensures your drives and components do not sit and stew in their own accumulated heat during a catastrophic power failure. The cooling module fans are surprisingly powerful and ensure that large volumes of air circulate around the drives.

Connection to the host is via two Fibre Channel loops providing 2Gb connectivity.

While each drive cradle has LEDs to indicate the drive's health and status including online, offline, fail, rebuild, drive identify, and prepare for removal, the SANbloc itself has status indicators for power, shelf faults, LS fault, FC loop open/closed, and FC loop speed.

The drive cradles and other redundant items such as power supply or cooling units are all quite easy to replace, and all items are hot swappable.

Management of the SANbloc is handled via Spheras Storage Director which uses Java RMI for connectivity over the Internet. Spheras is a very powerful utility that allows the user to configure, monitor, and maintain the SANbloc.

Adaptec was unable to provide the Lab with a 1TB implementation of the SANbloc and as a consequence the unit was tested with 14 drives (that amounted to just half a terabyte). For cost-per-GB calculations Adaptec supplied the Lab with pricing on a 14-drive 1.022TB solution rather than the cost as tested. Even so, the SANbloc is quite expensive at AU$27.39 per gigabyte -- but bear in mind that this price included the dual-controller option and 14 smallish drives. We also requested Adaptec supply us with a "best value" 1.022TB system with just a single controller and seven drives and the cost per GB drops dramatically to just AU$16.98 per GB.

Performance on the other hand was strong with the SANbloc the fastest during writes and quite quick at reads as well.

Product Adaptek SANbloc 2Gb RAID
Price AU$27,990 as 1TB Dual controller unit (using 14 x 73Gb 10K drives)
Vendor Adaptec Australia
Phone 02 8875 7874
Web www.adaptec.com.au
 
Interoperability
Server platform independent as long as Fibre Channel connectivity is available. Management via Spheras Storage Director which is available for Windows, Sun Solaris Sparc, and Linux Red Hat (Kernel 2.4).
Futureproofing
Up to eight units each with 14 drives that can be daisy chained for a capacity of 16.4TB.
ROI ½
At AU$27.95 per GB the SANbloc is relatively expensive, but remove one of the controllers and reduce the drive count to seven and the cost-per-GB drops to a reasonable AU$16.98. Performance was quite good.
Service ½
Three years return to base (five years on disks). Three-year on-site warranty available.
Rating ½
Adaptec SANbloc 2Gb RAID

Advertisement

Talkback 0 comments

Back to top

Featured