Burnt Offerings: High speed DVD Burners tested

By Steven Turvey, RMIT Labs
05 December 2003 11:10 AM
Tags: dvd, burner

Iomega Super DVD Model DVDRW4224E2Q

Iomega Super DVD

Of the PC based DVD burners the Iomega is the only external unit in this test and its charcoal and silver grey case is quite attractive. If you're not after an external drive the same unit is available as an internal unit. The power supply is an external mini "brick" and connection to the PC is via USB 2.0 so we weren't anticipating any problems with transfer speeds. The only other connectors on the rear of the unit are a pair of RCA audio outputs and for added security there is a Kensington lock connector on the rear.

The software bundle is quite good and the CD/DVD creation software called HotBurn Pro is a little different to most. HotBurn can be used in two ways; either through the extremely simplified Wizard or through HotBurn's relatively basic interface. Bells and whistles are a little lacking when compared to some of the other bundled software packages, but the software does make basic music and data disc creation a doddle. HotBurn also includes basic CD label and jewel case creation utilities. Iomega also supply an applet to implement automatic backups from your PC to the burner, as well as MusicMatch Jukebox and Cineplayer for musical and DVD movie playback respectively. If you are into creating your own VCD or DVD movies then Sonic MyDVD4, although quite basic, does allow you to capture video and burn to DVD.

The Iomega Super DVD is capable of writing to every current DVD media format including DVD-RAM. We did experience some problems during the performance testing; we found that the Iomega was unable to connect to the USB 2 PCI card in our test PC at any speed higher than USB 1.1. As a consequence we carried out the performance testing on a PC configured with an Intel D875PBZ motherboard that includes integrated USB 2.

 DVD Burners

 DVD burner reviews:

 Iomega Super DVD
 LG GSA-4040B
 Panasonic SW-9572-C
 Pioneer DVR-A06
 Sony DRU-510AK

 DVD Recorders: Sony Vs Panasonic
 DVD Burner Test Results
 DVD Burner Specifications
 Editor's Choice
 About RMIT

We then found that the Iomega, with firmware version A105, was unable to correctly detect our Princo DVD-R 4x media and instead appeared to write the DVD at 2x speed instead. We were unable to upgrade the Firmware to version A106 as the firmware upgrade utility was unable to detect the drive when fitted to the Intel motherboard even though Windows XP happily listed the device in Device Manager. After our testing period had expired we were finally able to upgrade the firmware whilst the Iomega was connected to another PC.

Performance was, in general, quite good although as noted we expect the write times for DVD-R media to be around 7 minutes rather than 13 minutes with the firmware upgraded to A106.
We did experience some problems with DVD-RAM however with the HotBurn software claiming that blank JVC and TDK DVD-RAM 4.7GB media was too small to write our 1.8GB test files. This was prior to the firmware upgrade, and we had to resort to a drag and drop copy from Windows that took a mind numbing 49 minutes to complete. For contrast the LG's software managed the same task in 17 minutes.

Iomega Super DVD Model DVDRW4224E2Q
Company: Iomega Australia
Price: AU$699 (External USB 2.0); AU$499 (Internal IDE)
Phone: (02) 8875 7851

Talkback 12 comments

    I have tried to access the rep ...Anonymous -- 25/01/04

    I have tried to access the reports on comparing dvd players but it keeps going back to the same screen when I click on any of the links. Can you help?

    I would like to commend you on ...Anonymous -- 27/01/04

    I would like to commend you on your revamped revies section! I think it long overdue and I can't believe that it's just as one thgought it should! ... like minfs and all that.

    It's a real joy to see the lastest DVDs and other important hardware and software packages reviewed without being too complimentry on the product under review.

    Thank you

    Individual links do not work, ...Anonymous -- 29/01/04

    Individual links do not work, but the review has helped me in my choice for a new product. Thanks.

    around and around we go deja v ...Anonymous -- 07/02/04

    around and around we go
    deja vu perhaps

    Rang Panasonic on the number y ...Anonymous -- 17/02/04

    Rang Panasonic on the number you gave above - took forever to find out the
    SW-9572-C isnt available in Australia yet or if it is only in a new PC (OEM).

    If anyone knows when and where we can get one please let me know.

    I've had nothing but trouble f ...Anonymous -- 20/02/04

    I've had nothing but trouble from my LG 4040b even after two firmware updates it is still very fussy about media. It often refuses to write princo (high grade) discs at 4X, and has similar troubles with other cheaper media (laser) that work well in friends' Pioneer and NEC. No problems with TDK -R disks but they cost nearly $5 each.

    On the Pioneer A06 DVD-CD-RW d ...Anonymous -- 28/04/04

    On the Pioneer A06 DVD-CD-RW drive, I had no problems for 3 months and then the drive just quit reading any DVDs I burned. Both formats of -DVD and +DVD. DVD movies still play I have bought or rented. Just all I burn do not. And it does burn. Haven't found a cure yet. (Updated firmware to v.108)

    These Dvd Recorders are all we ...Anonymous -- 05/05/04

    These Dvd Recorders are all well and good, BUT what they don't do is record Digital Signals as they don't have a Digital tuner, sure you can record now but what abput when Analog is no longer around, are they still going to work? I think not as you will not be able to record SBS as it's on channel 28 analog and on 3, 30, or 31 Digital. If they won't record digital signals what good are they??

    LG 4040B is the best thing ava ...Anonymous -- 18/07/04

    LG 4040B is the best thing available. We had to get a number of different burners as we know there are lemons (diversification!!!) and LG is by far the best. It can burn all formats including the ROM's, and the number of errors compared to other ones (Sony was a real shocker) non existence. Both thumbs up!

    Unfortunately, RecordNow, like ...Anonymous -- 27/11/04

    Unfortunately, RecordNow, like so much software these days presumes that you will only want to use their software. Thus they seem to have hijacked the burner and you can no longer use other software to burn CDs.

    I have a new Phillips DVD reco ...Anonymous -- 19/03/05

    I have a new Phillips DVD recorder DVDR 615(brand new with iLink), but am finding that a lot of the movies I am recording won't work...all have been from Fox Cl****ics or TCM channels. Would these old movies be copyrighted? Is that the reason I end up with "corrupted discs", useless for nothing except throwing in the bin? (both DVD+R and DVD+RW TDK and HP brands) I don't know if the DVD burner is no good, or I just can't burn most of these movies........I somtimes wonder why we bother with this technology when I can record it on video without a problem.

    adding a hard drive later on t ...Anonymous -- 25/04/05

    adding a hard drive later on to models that dont come standard...can this be done??which models are capable...?

Add your opinion

Reviews by category

Sponsored content

Power Centre - Content from our premier sponsors

Blogs

Tags

Back to top

Featured