Bang for your buck: 4 Budget printers tested

By Alex Kidman
26 March 2004 09:35 AM
Tags: printer, printing, page, 3550, epson, canon, unit, colour
Canon i250 Bubble Jet Printer Canon i250

While for less than AU$100, you can't expect too much, we've got to say that of all the models we've looked at, the i250 is without a doubt the ugliest of the bunch. That might not matter too much to you  when making a printer purchasing decision, and certainly the i250 proves the maxim that beauty is indeed only skin deep, as it turned out the best photo prints in our test group and kept neck and neck with the HP DeskJet in speed terms.

 Budget printers


 Introduction

 Canon i250
 Epson Stylus C43UX
 HP Deskjet 3550
 Lexmark z605
 How we tested
 Editor's Choice
 Specifications

Aside from the lack of physical beauty, the i250 is also severely lacking in one other important area, and it's the i250's absolute achilles heel; it doesn't come with an output paper tray for stacking finished prints, which are instead spat out directly onto whatever surface happens to be in front of the printer. Depending on where you intend to place the i250 that may not be an issue, and for a relatively nominal AU$40 more you could upgrade to the similar i350 which does feature a paper exit tray, along with the capability for borderless prints.

Unlike every other printer in our roundup, the i250 lacks a setup poster, instead bundling in an installation leaflet. It's a tad confusing, however, as the same leaflet is used for the superior i350 printer as well -- for some time we were wondering where the printer out tray mentioned in the leaflet  was in fact. The i250 also differs from every other printer in our roundup in that installing print cartridges is a two-step affair. The i250 uses a permanent but removable print head that slots in before the black and tricolour cartridges can be inserted. It's an interesting move for a budget printer, but one that allows Canon to offer its actual ink cartridges at a substantial price discount compared to its competitors. Canon's driver offering is easy enough to follow, and the company completes the package with utitities for easy photo and web page printing, although these are optional installation components.

The i250 and HP Deskjet 3550 jostled for first place in our text printing tests, with the Canon managing our colour prints just a tad faster but black text prints a little slower. Where it beat the competition handily was in speedy photo processing; our test A4 image was visually the equal of the Epson Stylus C43UX's in terms of quality, but in only four and a half minutes, the i250 absolutely blew away the field in time terms.

As mentioned, the i250 uses a distinct print head that makes the physical cartridges cheaper than those of competing printers -- Canon doesn't have to build in a new print head for each new cartridge, essentially. Black cartridges come in at AU$13.95, while colour ones cost AU$29.95. With expected page yields of 300 and 170 pages respectively, that works out to a very cheap 4.65c per black page or 17.6c per colour page, making it solidly the cheapest printer to run in our comparative group.

We like the i250 a lot, and if it weren't for the lack of an output tray, it would simply walk all over the competition. For most users, however, we suspect that'll be a rather large issue to overcome.

Canon i250 Bubble Jet Printer
Company: Canon
Price: AU$99
Distributor: Selected resellers
Phone: 1800 021 167

Advertisement

Talkback 3 comments

    A Canon wins and the ads on th ...Anonymous -- 01/04/04

    A Canon wins and the ads on the site are for Epson? Ya gotta love that.

    Thanks for the review info. Lo ...Anonymous -- 11/04/04

    Thanks for the review info. Looks like Canon offers most economical operation with reasonable quality and print speed. I'm not worried about the output tray - will mount printer on a shelf, and make my own tray, which I will screw with some brackets under the printer shelf to catch the pages being spat out.

    Thank you! A big help in my se ...Anonymous -- 21/03/05

    Thank you! A big help in my search for a cheap printer.Have tried very hard on lots of websites to buy the:Canon i250 bubble jet printer,but no one have one 4 sale,not even a second one.

Add your opinion

Reviews by category

Sponsored content

Power Centre - Content from our premier sponsors

Blogs

  • Suzanne Tindal Sick of broken tender sites
    Some of the state governments desperately need to invest in more user-friendly tender sites so that looking for information on government tenders doesn't have to be a game of blind man's bluff.
  • Array Cyberwar: What is it good for?
    In this week's episode, Cyberwar. What is Australia's place in the world of digital warfare? What are the implications for the NBN?
  • Array Is wholesale-only backhaul just a pipedream?
    The potential acquisition of Pipe Networks by SP Telemedia has raised the question about whether vertically integrated backhaul providers will mean higher wholesale prices for ISP customers.
  • More blogs »

Tags

Back to top

Featured