Virtual privacy: 8 VPN appliances tested



If you are in the market for a VPN, don't go past this review. We test the latest appliances and provide tips on purchasing and setting it up.


Contents
Setting up a VPN
Netgear FVL-328
CyberGuard SG575
Juniper NS-5GT
Fortinet FortiGate-60
Watchguard Firebox 1000
Symantec SGS 460
Nortel Contivity 1100
Sonicwall Pro 2040
Specifications
How we tested
Sample scenario
Editor's choice
About RMIT

A VPN is a virtual private network, which is basically a private tunnel that connects two networks through a public network (usually the Internet). VPNs have been used to replace owned or leased lines so that a company can share the same capabilities but at a lower cost by using a shared public network.

A VPN works by encrypting data before sending it across a public network and decrypting it at the receiving end. Security features differ from product to product, but VPNs generally include encryption, authentication of remote users or sites, and mechanisms for disguising information about the private network from the public network. VPN functionality is often part of a firewall, so many of the appliances tested in this review include varying amounts of firewall functionality.

For this review we look at eight VPN appliances from the following vendors: Cyberguard, Fortinet, Juniper, Netgear, Nortel Networks, SonicWall, Symantec, and Watchguard.

How is the Data Secured?
The IPSec protocol suite provides a complete secure communications suite; with authentication, integrity, and confidentiality, and makes key exchange practical even in larger networks.

Generally speaking, with IPSec-compliant products you can build a secure VPN in any existing IP-based network.

We did however encounter a few problems trying to create a tunnel between two sites using two different VPN appliances. We imagine that this sort of thing would be happening out in the field as well. Ideally you would use appliances from the same vendor as it makes life so much easier.

IPSec also handles the encryption at the packet level. The protocol it uses is called ESP. ESP supports pretty much any kind of symmetric encryption. The default standard built into ESP that assures basic interoperability is 56-bit DES. Most of the appliances tested are capable (and were tested at) triple DES.

Advertisement

Talkback 7 comments

    VPN Privacy Anonymous -- 31/01/08

    Good and usefull review. It is i say as vpn service provider. We represent anonymous vpn service ( http://vpnprivacy.com ) for our customer.

    VPN Privacy Anonymous -- 30/09/09 (in reply to #320094608)

    I find the terms of sale highly misleading. For instance buying one week's access commits to regular renewal of their service. Why would anyone want to buy one week's service and commit to renew it weekly? When some one commits to pay for one week, they are more than likely trying to test the service out. No need to rope them in. It does not bode well, as VPN is a trust business. Your business lost my trust even before I put the order in!

    Anonymous Surfing Anonymous -- 13/03/08

    Good review. Additional VPN help to sufr anonymous.

    check the website
    www.blacklogic.com

    Appliance for the average Joe Jason Walker -- 16/12/08

    Ive been using this personal vpn appliance lately and it's cheap and works great. My mission was to unblock Skype in the UAE and it worked. http://www.surfbouncer.com/vpn_appliance.htm

    SSL VPN Service Mark Ariyes -- 19/03/09

    If you don't want to be responsible for managing VPN hardware I recommend trying a service instead. Look for a SSL based VPN because they have by far better speed & accessibility than the others. SlickyProxy.com is the best of the services I've evaluated so far.

    Unlimited VPN Anonymous -- 02/06/09

    SonicWall is the best of all VPN equipment providers.

    For fast, anonymous, unlimited VPN service check out this site ****

    http://www.solvpn.com

    OpenVPN Bob Thornton -- 13/08/09

    Of course the best VPN providers allow OpenVPN connections for increased security. Personally, I've found http://www.overplay.net to be about the fastest around - they even have a speed tester on the website

Add your opinion

Back to top

Featured