Say goodbye to airport lounges: 5 Videoconferencing systems tested



Say goodbye to airport lounges The latest generation of videoconferencing systems supports high-quality MPEG4 video, prefers IP to ISDN connections, and costs you less than a couple of business-class tickets to New York.

 Videoconferencing
 Review
 Polycom VSX 7000
 Sony PCS-1P
 Tandberg 990
 Tandberg T7000
 Zoom Networks
   Penteview 2012


 Specifications
 How We Tested
 3G videoconferencing
 Editor's choice
 About RMIT

In the 12 months since we last took a look at Video Conferencing (VC) there have been some new models introduced although perhaps surprisingly some of the units have lasted the distance and are still "current" products, such as the Tandberg 990.

Perhaps more importantly, since we last tested VC there have been some new standards that have worked their way into the products' firmware. When we last visited VC, MPEG4 (H.264) was not quite there yet, but this time only the Penteview as tested did not feature this standard. The Penteview should however be provided with updated firmware that will include H.264 by the time you read this.

So what improvements does H.264 bring? Quite simply the video coding algorithm provides equal picture quality at half the bit rate of H.263, so if you have limited bandwidth issues, H.264 will be a sight for sore eyes.

Last time we looked IP was making inroads into a field previously dominated by ISDN. With the latest products, IP has further strengthened its position: for example, Sony doesn't support ISDN out of the box, although a six-port ISDN unit is available as an option. ISDN is the more secure of the connections as it's point to point. To provide security for IP connections, all the vendorsâ€"with the exception of the Penteviewâ€"provide encryption, in some cases both AES and DES. Another strength of ISDN is that the bandwidth is guaranteed, whereas your call over IP will probably have a bandwidth that is anything but constant.

The Polycom and Sony also don't have data conferencing or collaboration supported as standard. Both vendors supply optional equipment to bring this capability to the units, but the facility adds significant cost.

We evaluated five products from four vendors:

Advertisement

Talkback 0 comments

Back to top

Featured