Flat-panel festival



The prices are coming down which means LCD monitors are fast becoming standard on the desktop. And business-grade 19-inch monitors are holding their own when it comes to the desktop market.


Contents
Introduction
Acer AL1922
AG Neovo E-19A
BenQ FP91G
HP 1955
LG L1980Q
Mitsubishi DV197SB
NEC 1970NX
NewQ LVNR190
Philips 190B6
Sony SDM-HS95B
ViewSonic VX924
Specifications
How we tested
Editor's choice
About RMIT

Flat-panel LCD monitors are fast becoming a lot more common on our nation's desktops. The appeal of an uncluttered desk, that still has the advantages of an expansive working screen is obvious, and as the prices begin to drop, large, flat LCDs are becoming a realistic proposition for any business desk. The traditional CRT (Cathode Ray Tube) screens already seem bulky and outdated in comparison, and LCD vendors are eagerly promoting the virtues of this new wave of monitors.

For this review, we will look at sub-AU$1000 19-inch models. What these monitors lack in depth they make up for in width and height. And such a large screen means you can push these models far away and still be able to see. We had 11 vendors submit monitors for this review, and as mentioned they are all sub-AU$1000, some well under this price.

What to look for

  • Quality of image. Look for sharpness of text, refresh rate, and contrast ratio. In particular, look at tearing: the effect noticed when there are fast moving graphics or video images displayed on the screen. This is mostly a large jagged line across the screen which flashes up for a millisecond -- it is fairly hard to percieve and occurs mostly during high-contrast changes, ie black background with fast white flashes across it. Also look at bleeding: when colours tend to run into each other, primarily around their edges. This occours mostly with colours such as yellow and light pinks.
  • Policy. Scrutinise the vendor's dead/bright pixel policy (zero-pixel means not one faulty pixel) to ensure that if the worst case happens you will have manufacturer support.
  • Features. Look for USB hubs, and inbuilt speakers, which may be a benefit if those clunky separate speakers are taking up real estate on the desk.
  • Style. Aesthetics in the office are becoming an important fact of life, especially in professional environments.

All the monitors submitted for this review were spot-on 19 inches in viewable size, and all had both digital (DVI) and analogue (D-Sub) video inputs. Some had USB ports, some had speakers, others had landscape/portrait display swivels and some had really great adjustment options.

Both the AG Neovo and the New Q feature a glass pane. Glass does protect the LCD screen itself, however, displays which have glass can be too reflective, picking up light which affects the display. It can go either way -- good protection for the panel but poor visibility due to the reflections. It is a personal or purchasing choice that will need to be evaluated at the time of procurement and it should consider the environment that displays will be used in.

Advertisement

Talkback 5 comments

    Benq FP91G Marc Jones -- 19/01/06 (in reply to #120127529)

    Great monitor, clear graphics display.

    Im running 2 computers in my room one running DVI and the other D-SUB, and i love the feature to be able to switch between the 2 displays!

    Life is not good with LG R Moore -- 05/04/06

    My experience with LG monitors is not a positive one. The 19" monitor I bought lasted 2 weeks and turned up its toes and it has been with the service agent for 3 weeks with no end in sight. LGE Australia have been of no assistance whatsoever with getting me a solution. Most of the time they will not respond to queries posted on their website and do not seem to care about any inconvenience I might have to suffer. I would not recommend their products to anyone. They may be OK if they do not break down but if they do, you are most certainly on your own.

    HP 1955 Anonymous -- 14/12/06

    Horrible monitor. Corporate setting. All cubicles have these monitors. At least 10 burned out this year.

    Don't Buy them.

    Hp 1955 Eric -- 17/03/08

    yeah, same with mine at home, just burned out one evening, useless product.

    HP 1955 Anonymous -- 28/03/08

    I bought my HP 1955 with the xw4300 workstation back in 2005 and it hasn't given me a bit of trouble. Truly reliable, no dead pixels, works flawlessly.

    Contrast that with -- In '07 I bought a Polaroid FLM-1911 Monitor/TV so I could watch football (American style!) while working but also use the monitor as an extension for presentation in my office. It's already dead. TV (via cable) stopped working, DVD output only works on HDTV now, and VGA flickers with a pinkish hue.

    I'll take HP quality over Polaroid any day.

Add your opinion

Back to top

Featured