Flat out: Ten 17-inch LCD monitors tested

By
12 August 2003 07:20 PM
Tags: 17", technology, business, monitors, lcd, t&b, 17-inch, rmit

How we tested

Interoperability
How will the monitor work with your existing equipment; which connectors does it have?

Futureproofing
Does the monitor support emerging standards such as DVI inputs and widescreen format?

ROI
Does the monitor provide good value for money and do the features justify the price?

Service
How long is the warranty and what is the vendor's policy on repairing the monitor if it has dead pixels?

17" LCD Displays
Introduction
1. AG Neovo F-417
2. AOC LM720
3. BenQ FP791
4. IBM 6374-AB1 Thinkvision
5. Mitsubishi Diamond View DV172
6. Panasonic Panaview TX-LCD17SSIL
7. Philips 107S4FB
8. Samsung 172W
9. Sony SDM-HS73
10. Viewsonic VX700
Features table
How we tested
Look out for...
Final words
About RMIT
We used DisplayMate for Windows Video Edition to adjust each monitor according to the application's instructions and patterns. Once setup was completed, we looked at subjective image samples, movie clips, and patterns to get a feel for the image quality and clarity. Our test rig stayed the same for all units, comprising of a Intel 875 mainboard and Pentium 4 3GHz CPU, 512MB DDR RAM, 120GB SATA drives, and a 128MB GeForce 3 Titanium video card with DVI, S-Video, and 15-pin D-Sub outputs. Wherever available we used the best connection, which is DVI. If DVI was not an option on a particular model, then we used the 15-pin D-Sub output.

If you are looking at upgrading from a CRT monitor to an LCD, particularly in the larger sizes, it's worth checking if your existing graphics card has a DVI port on it, or buying a graphics card that supports it. The difference in image reproduction on some monitors between the 15-pin D-Sub port and the DVI port is amazing; somewhere around a 10 to 15 percent improvement in visible image sharpness.

Look out for...
When buying an LCD monitor, look out for the following:

  • Extra features that may suit your business, eg, S-video and composite inputs, TV tuners, widescreen panels, and features like the BenQ picture frame.
  • If you are looking for superior picture quality in the office, then ensure that your PCs and LCD monitors have DVI interface.
  • In-built speakers are a bonus on some models, particularly if you are aiming to reduce the desktop clutter around the office, but many offices may not need them.
  • If your business plans to put these monitors in a stylish environment where clients could potentially see the rear of the units (eg, reception desks or customer service areas) then ensure that the cable routing is good and that there are no stickers or awkward styling on the rear casing.

Final Words
This review certainly shows that the larger LCDs are finally hitting the mainstream, and with this bunch of ten 17in LCDs, we can see that the future is looking good. Competition is certainly hotting up and it looks like it will be a features competition instead of price. Some models now sport relatively unique features, such as TV tuners, flash memory card slide show slots, or a 16:9 widescreen format. There was very little difference between the models, and virtually any one could work well.

Subscribe now to Australian Technology & Business magazine.

About RMIT Test Labs
RMIT Test Labs RMIT IT Test Labs is an independent testing institution based in Melbourne, Victoria, performing IT product testing for clients such as IBM, Coles-Myer, and a wide variety of government bodies. In the Labs' testing for T&B, they are in direct contact with the clients supplying products and the magazine is responsible for the full cost of the testing. The findings are the Labs' own--only the specifications of the products to be tested are provided by the magazine. For more information on RMIT, please contact the Lab Manager, Steven Turvey.

< Prev 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13
Advertisement

Talkback 8 comments

    Help! From the above page, th ...Anonymous -- 26/01/04

    Help! From the above page, the links to the "Features Table", "What to Look for" etc. etc. do not work. Can you please fix?

    On the above page, the links t ...Anonymous -- 26/01/04

    On the above page, the links to "Features Table", "What to Look For" etc. etc. do not work.
    Can you please fix?

    Is the TX-LCD17SSIL available ...Anonymous -- 06/02/04

    Is the TX-LCD17SSIL available in Australia?
    Panasonic havei indicated that they do not have that one. TX-LCD17AE and TX-LCD17M appear to be the only 2 that exist. Is this correct?

    thanks for an excellent and in ...Anonymous -- 21/02/04

    thanks for an excellent and informative article. I was considering changing my existing monitor and with the information in your article I am now in a far better position to select. keep up the good work

    thanks for an excellent and in ...Anonymous -- 21/02/04

    thanks for an excellent and informative article. I was considering changing my existing monitor and with the information in your article I am now in a far better position to select. keep up the good work

    Hi, I have the same question a ...Anonymous -- 21/04/04

    Hi, I have the same question as Anonymous, I am reseller and can't find this model, wanted by customer.

    Tim

    Fullname: Anonymous
    Location: Brisbane, Qld, Australia
    Occupation: Engineer
    Comments:
    Is the TX-LCD17SSIL available in Australia?
    Panasonic havei indicated that they do not have that one. TX-LCD17AE and TX-LCD17M appear to be the only 2 that exist. Is this correct?

    I tried to see your comments o ...Anonymous -- 29/12/04

    I tried to see your comments on 17-inch LCD, but none of those ten reviews is availiable!

    How can we get the test result ...Anonymous -- 12/01/05

    How can we get the test results?

    We will buy the 17"LCD monitor, we have to consider the price, quality, and service. It would be highly appreciated if you can send me the test results.

    We are T&B subscriber.

Add your opinion

Back to top

Featured