|
|
To print: Select File and then Print from your browser's menu
-------------------------------------------------------------- This story was printed from ZDNet Australia. --------------------------------------------------------------
|
Apple AirPort Express Base Station (802.11n) By Rich Brown, CNET.com March 26, 2008 URL: http://www.zdnet.com.au/reviews/hardware/networking/soa/Apple-AirPort-Express-Base-Station-802-11n-/0,2000065582,339287673,00.htm
Apple's AirPort Express Base Station has always been remarkable in that it is networking hardware that people actually seem to get excited about. Thanks to an update to the 802.11n wireless networking standard, this compact, easy-to-use device can now add increased wireless networking performance to its list of pros. It might not be as fast as some of the more robust 802.11n wireless devices, and at AU$129, it's also on the pricier side of basic 802.11n routers. Still, for its portability and its integration with iTunes, we recommend it to anyone interested in setting up a wireless network on the go, or if you're after some basic music streaming capability. Design and setup
As with the original model, setting up the AirPort Express is remarkably easy. You simply plug the AirPort Express into a power outlet, install the software onto a PC on your network, and follow the basic prompts via Apple's AirPort Utility. The experience is basically the same on a Windows PC, the main exception being that it installs Apple's Bonjour network device discovery software as well, if you don't already have it. The AirPort Express supports both the 2.4GHz and 5.0GHz wireless frequencies, so you can opt for the faster 5.0GHz band if you only need to worry about 802.11a/n-compatible devices. Features
That audio out is one of the main features that the AirPort Express can hold over Apple's Time Capsule, the pricier AirPort Extreme Base Station, and indeed most other wireless routers. If you plug a set of speakers (or any audio output device) into the AirPort Express, you can then use any iTunes-equipped computer on the AirPort's network to stream music to that device. It's no replacement for a dedicated music-streaming device such as Logitech's Squeezebox Duet, but if you're okay with playing DJ through the iTunes interface on your computer, the AirPort Express can provide a straightforward way to pipe music throughout your house. Apple also still hasn't opened up iTunes' DRM to other audio-streaming hardware vendors, which means the AirPort Express and the Apple TV are still the only networking devices that can stream music from iTunes. Because audio streaming is generally not that demanding on your networking bandwidth, the benefit of the AirPort Express's move to 802.11n feels like more of a "keeping up with the Joneses" kind of upgrade, although its wider bandwidth opens up the possibility for streaming high definition video smoothly across your network. The 802.11n standard certainly has its benefits. The rated specs for the standard include twice the bandwidth of 802.11g (74 megabits per second versus 23 megabits per second), and also twice the range, with about 70 metres for 802.11n versus 35 metres for the older standards. But, as you'll see from our testing, the AirPort Express's actual network performance sits on the lower end of the 802.11n scale.
Performance Ixia IxChariot maximum throughput tests (at 4.5 metres)
(Longer bars indicate better performance) D-Link DGL-4500
Xtreme Gaming Router (5.0Ghz)
116.1
Apple Time
Capsule (5.0Ghz)
103.1
Netgear
RangeMax Next WNR854T
85.5
SMC
SMCWGBR14-N Barricade N
83.7
D-Link
DGL-4500 Xtreme Gaming Router
81.9
Edimax
BR-6504N nMax
76.7
Apple AirPort
Express (5.0GHz)
66.5
Apple Time
Capsule
65.1
Asus WL-500W
802.11n
62.9
Apple AirPort
Express
52.8
LevelONe N-One
WBR-6000
47.3
Ixia IxChariot maximum throughput tests with
mixed 802.11b/g and draft N clients (at 4.5 metres)
(Longer bars indicate better performance) Edimax BR-6504N nMax
68
Netgear
RangeMax Next WNR854T
67.5
Asus WL-500W
802.11n
55.1
SMC
SMCWGBR14-N Barricade N
52.4
Apple Time
Capsule
51.5
D-Link
DGL-4500 Xtreme Gaming Router
50.9
Apple AirPort
Express
50.5
LevelONe N-One
WBR-6000
23.9
Turn over to see our range test results. Our testing shows that the AirPort Express is actually among the slowest 802.11n devices. Its speed is still plenty fast for streaming music or HD video, but even under the best conditions, at close range on a 5.0GHz 802.11n-only network, it hit 66Mbps, or just barely faster than the Time Capsule in slower 2.4GHz mode. If you have demanding networking tasks in mind, with many users all streaming various kinds of media at once, for example, you will likely want a more robust 802.11n product.
Ixia IxChariot long-range tests
(Longer bars indicate better performance) D-Link DGL-4500
Xtreme Gaming Router (5.0Ghz)
49.7
Apple Time
Capsule (5.0Ghz)
42.27
Asus WL-500W
802.11n
29.7
D-Link
DGL-4500 Xtreme Gaming Router
27
Netgear
RangeMax Next WNR854T
26.9
SMC
SMCWGBR14-N Barricade N
24.3
Apple Time
Capsule
21.36
Apple AirPort
Express (5.0Ghz)
18.4
Apple AirPort
Express
11.7
Edimax
BR-6504N nMax
11.4
LevelONe N-One
WBR-6000
5.3
We also found that the AirPort Express takes a significant hit compared with other 802.11n devices when you use it at long distance. At the 5.0GHz frequency, Apple's Time Capsule is actually near the top of its class at range, posting an impressive 42.27Mbps from 60 metres. The AirPort Express loses more than half of that throughput, coming in at only 18.4Mbps. Its long-distance 2.4GHz performance is lower still. At those speeds, your HD streaming experience would suffer, so if you intend to work the AirPort Express into a media-streaming situation, you will want to keep the various components fairly close together.
Copyright © 2009 CBS Interactive, a CBS Company. All Rights Reserved. |