Top 10 phones for road warriors

Charles McLellan, ZDNet UK

03 October 2007 02:15 PM

Mobile phones have come a long way in the last few years, and it's now feasible to consider going on a business trip leaving your notebook PC behind, trusting in the functionality of your mobile phone or phone-equipped handheld.

That can mean a significant difference in technology travel weight -- under 500g for a mobile and its charger, compared to 2-3kg for a notebook and its associated paraphernalia.

The device you choose depends, as ever, on precisely what you want to do with it. But most business travellers will have a minimum set of requirements, which we suggest will include the following: access to e-mail (preferably "push" e-mail from the company mail server); the ability to open (and preferably edit) business files such as word processor documents, spreadsheets, presentations and PDFs; and a Web browser (preferably with VPN access to the company network).

Increasingly, IT departments (if not always users themselves) will be looking for the ability to manage mobile phones and handhelds in the field so that they can be provisioned with software updates, made secure and if necessary wiped clean should they fall into the wrong hands.

Users, or their IT managers, need to consider whether their usage is primarily voice-centric or data-centric. That will determine the kind of form factor required. Luckily there's a wide choice available, ranging from conventional-looking phones to BlackBerry-like devices with QWERTY keyboards, to hybrids with slide-out keyboards. Search around and you should find something with ergomonics that suit you.

Then there's connectivity, which will primarily depend on the amount of data you need to shift around. If you're a heavy data user, you're looking at 3G/HSDPA with perhaps a side order of Wi-Fi (which will also be required to take advantage of fixed-mobile convergence); if you just want to check e-mail occasionally, GPRS will probably do.

Here are the most popular business phones, as determined by ZDNet Australia readers, over the past month. Have a look through to see if there's one that's best suited to your specific needs.

BlackBerry Curve 8300 BlackBerry Curve 8300

The BlackBerry Curve takes both good and bad factors from the Pearl and 8800, making it an enticing phone -- but we're still waiting for the ultimate consumer BlackBerry

Samsung E590 Samsung E590

Samsung's teeny tiny E590 packs a whole lot of features into a fuss-free candy bar model.

Nokia E61i Nokia E61i

Nokia's successor to the E61 boasts a slimmer side profile and a 2-megapixel shooter.

Nokia N95 Nokia N95

If you need an all-in-one communications, navigation and imaging device and don't mind charging it every night, Nokia's N95 raises the bar in the mobile world.

Motorola Q 9h Motorola Q 9h

If you're looking for an attractive 3.5G PDA-phone with push email, Windows Mobile 6 and a QWERTY keyboard, the Motorola Q 9h is worthy of consideration, so long as you don't need a touchscreen or Wi-Fi.

Motorola RAZR2 V9 Motorola RAZR2 V9

Far from being another update, the sequel to the V3 is a whole different kind of RAZR, with rounder edges, shiny surfaces and -- somehow -- a thinner silhouette.

HTC Touch HTC Touch

While not a iPhone killer, the HTC Touch represents good value for money. If you can do without 3G support or a high-res camera, then the Touch will offer most features you'd require from a smartphone.

Palm Treo 750 Palm Treo 750

Here's a dollop of irony: the best Windows Mobile smartphone has been created by Palm! A bevy of OS enhancements and access to Telstra's Next G mobile broadband network easily make it the best Windows Mobile device we've ever used.

Dopod D810 Dopod D810

The Dopod D810 is packed with a bevy of useful features including 3.5G HSDPA support, quad-band GSM, and Wi-Fi, but suffers from some glaring shortcomings.

Dopod 838 Pro Dopod 838 Pro

An extremely well-equipped Pocket PC PDA-phone, Dopod has made sure that the 3G-enabled 838 Pro balances features with power so it doesn't leave you hanging when you need to access applications like Skype. However, due to its size and weight you might need a bag to carry it around.

Advertisement

Talkback 3 comments

    10 business phones for road warriors? Where are they? Anonymous -- 03/10/07

    How does 4 phone-less PDAs relate to the articles title "10 business phones for road warriors"????

    Corrected ZDNet Australia staff -- 04/10/07 (in reply to #320087141)

    Thanks for your feedback - we had a technical issue which has since been sorted.

    ZDNet Australia staff.

    Stability testing, anyone? :-) Lorenzo Modesto -- 04/01/09

    Just letting you know that testing the stability of the phones (especially PDA phones) in question is essential, as I've already motored through a Palm Treo (unreliable when hammered), 3 imate Jazjams (hardware failure and unreliable when hammered) and a Nokia E61(also unreliable when hammered) to finally settle on an HTC TYTNII, which requires proactive daily reboots but takes the punishment (so far, after 6 months).

    I don't think the TYTNII was out at the time of publication.

    Either way, let us know which ones work reliably when they're *really* used (email, messaging, browsing, task list, calendar at the same time for a few days and synchronisation of all of the above for a 6 month period).

    In my experience, it should only take around 3-4 days of hammering to get one (or all) to start to twitch and/or die :-)

Add your opinion

Reviews by category

Sponsored content

Power Centre - Content from our premier sponsors

Blogs

  • Chris Duckett Get extensions going in Firefox, redux
    Previously on Null Pointer we looked at getting extensions working in Firefox betas, and that was great until the fine folks at Firefox changed their minds.
  • Array How reliable is IP telephony?
    Have you ever heard a weird kind of hissing, crackling or popping noise when calling someone on an IP telephony line? How rare is the phenomenon these days?
  • Array Forget the NBN, 100Mbps is already here
    Telstra and TransACT will shortly begin offering 100Mbps broadband to many customers. By moving early, the companies have not only raised the bar for Australia's broadband services, but thrown down a challenge to a government that now faces increased pressure to deliver the NBN as promised.
  • More blogs »

Tags

Back to top

Featured