Advertisement
To print: Select File and then Print from your browser's menu
-------------------------------------------------------------- This story was printed from ZDNet Australia. --------------------------------------------------------------
The best smartphone is...

By Alex Serpo and Joseph Hanlon, ZDNet.com.au
August 01, 2008
URL: http://www.zdnet.com.au/reviews/hardware/mobiles_pdas/soa/The-best-smartphone-is-/0,2000065782,339290574,00.htm


Read all the latest reviews but still confused about which smartphone to buy? Our review round-up lets you decide what is important to you.

In our most comprehensive comparison of business-focused smartphones, we've broken down our rating criteria so you can find the best phone based on the criteria you consider most valuable. Selecting the tabs above will re-order the list of best smartphones to fit our assessment of these criteria, with the best overall rating being a combination of these scores.

Best Overall

  1. 1.  Nokia E71

    Aesthetic 4.5 out of 5
    Usability 4 out of 5
    Performance 4 out of 5
    Connectivity 4 out of 5
    Features 4 out of 5
    Value for Money 5 out of 5
    ASUS Eee PC 900
    Overall: 82%
    Editor's Rating: 8/10
  2. 2.  Apple iPhone 3G

    Aesthetic 5 out of 5
    Usability 5 out of 5
    Performance 3.5 out of 5
    Connectivity 3.5 out of 5
    Features 4 out of 5
    Value for Money 4 out of 5
    Overall: 81%
    Editor's Rating: 7/10
  3. 3.  i-mate Ultimate 8502

    Aesthetic 3.5 out of 5
    Usability 2 out of 5
    Performance 4 out of 5
    Connectivity 5 out of 5
    Features 3.5 out of 5
    Value for Money 3 out of 5
    Overall: 77%
    Editor's Rating: 9.1/10
  4. 4.  i-mate Ultimate 9502

    Aesthetic 3 out of 5 Usability 2 out of 5
    Performance 4 out of 5 Connectivity 5 out of 5
    Features 4 out of 5 Value for Money 3 out of 5
    Overall 76% Editors' Rating 8.3/10
  5. 5.  HTC Touch Cruise

    Aesthetic 4 out of 5 Usability 3 out of 5
    Performance 3.5 out of 5 Connectivity 5 out of 5
    Features 3.5 out of 5 Value for Money 2 out of 5
    Overall 76% Editors' Rating 8/10
  6. 6.  HTC Touch Diamond

    Aesthetic 4.5 out of 5 Usability 4 out of 5
    Performance 4 out of 5 Connectivity 4 out of 5
    Features 3.5 out of 5 Value for Money 3 out of 5
    Overall 76% Editors' Rating 6.7/10
  7. 7.  i-mate Ultimate 6150

    Aesthetic 3 out of 5 Usability 2 out of 5
    Performance 4.5 out of 5 Connectivity 5 out of 5
    Features 3.5 out of 5 Value for Money 4 out of 5
    Overall 72% Editors' Rating 8.3/10
    i-mate Ultimate 6150
  8. 8.  BlackBerry Pearl 8120

    Aesthetic 5 out of 5 Usability 4 out of 5
    Performance 5 out of 5 Connectivity 2.5 out of 5
    Features 2 out of 5 Value for Money 2 out of 5
    Overall 72% Editors' Rating 8.2/10
    ASUS Eee PC 900
  9. 9.  Samsung i780

    Aesthetic 3 out of 5 Usability 3 out of 5
    Performance 3 out of 5 Connectivity 4 out of 5
    Features 4 out of 5 Value for Money 4 out of 5
    Overall 70% Editors' Rating 7.5/10
    Samsung i780
  10. 10.  Nokia E90 Communicator

    Aesthetic 2.5 out of 5 Usability 3 out of 5
    Performance 3.5 out of 5 Connectivity 4 out of 5
    Features 3 out of 5 Value for Money 1 out of 5
    Overall 68% Editors' Rating 8.5/10
    Nokia E90 Communicator
  11. 11.  HTC TyTN II

    Aesthetic 3 out of 5 Usability 3.5 out of 5
    Performance 2 out of 5 Connectivity 4 out of 5
    Features 4 out of 5 Value for Money 1 out of 5
    Overall 68% Editors' Rating 7.2/10
    HTC TyTN II
  12. 12.  Nokia N95 8GB

    Aesthetic 2 out of 5 Usability 3 out of 5
    Performance 4 out of 5 Connectivity 4 out of 5
    Features 3 out of 5 Value for Money 1 out of 5
    Overall 68% Editors' Rating 8.3/10
    Nokia N95 8GB
  13. 13.  HTC Touch Dual

    Aesthetic 4 out of 5 Usability 3.5 out of 5
    Performance 3 out of 5 Connectivity 3 out of 5
    Features 2.5 out of 5 Value for Money 3 out of 5
    Overall 65% Editors' Rating 7.6/10
    HTC Touch Dual
  14. 14.  Sony Ericsson W960i

    Aesthetic 3 out of 5 Usability 4 out of 5
    Performance 1 out of 5 Connectivity 4 out of 5
    Features 2.5 out of 5 Value for Money 2 out of 5
    Overall 62% Editors' Rating 7.6/10
    Sony Ericsson W960i
  15. 15.  Palm Treo 500v

    Aesthetic 3 out of 5 Usability 4 out of 5
    Performance 4 out of 5 Connectivity 5 out of 5
    Features 3.5 out of 5 Value for Money 3 out of 5
    Overall 60% Editors' Rating 7.1/10
    Palm Treo 500v

Aesthetic
Having a full featured smartphone may be important, but having a sexy handset that makes your colleagues drool is essential. This list ranks the best looking to the most bland.

Best Aesthetic

  1. 1.  Apple iPhone 3G

    Aesthetic 5 out of 5
    Usability 5 out of 5
    Performance 3.5 out of 5
    Connectivity 3.5 out of 5
    Features 4 out of 5
    Value for Money 4 out of 5
    Overall: 81%
    Editor's Rating: 7/10
  2. 2.  BlackBerry Pearl 8120

    Aesthetic 5 out of 5
    Usability 4 out of 5
    Performance 5 out of 5
    Connectivity 2.5 out of 5
    Features 2 out of 5
    Value for Money 2 out of 5
    ASUS Eee PC 900
    Overall: 72%
    Editor's Rating: 8.2/10
  3. 3.  Nokia E71

    Aesthetic 4.5 out of 5
    Usability 4 out of 5
    Performance 4 out of 5
    Connectivity 4 out of 5
    Features 4 out of 5
    Value for Money 5 out of 5
    ASUS Eee PC 900
    Overall: 82%
    Editor's Rating: 8/10
  4. 4.  HTC Touch Diamond

    Aesthetic 4.5 out of 5 Usability 4 out of 5
    Performance 4 out of 5 Connectivity 4 out of 5
    Features 3.5 out of 5 Value for Money 3 out of 5
    Overall 76% Editors' Rating 6.7/10
  5. 5.  HTC Touch Dual

    Aesthetic 4 out of 5 Usability 3.5 out of 5
    Performance 3 out of 5 Connectivity 3 out of 5
    Features 2.5 out of 5 Value for Money 3 out of 5
    Overall 65% Editors' Rating 7.6/10
    HTC Touch Dual
  6. 6.  HTC Touch Cruise

    Aesthetic 4 out of 5 Usability 3 out of 5
    Performance 3.5 out of 5 Connectivity 5 out of 5
    Features 3.5 out of 5 Value for Money 2 out of 5
    Overall 76% Editors' Rating 8/10
  7. 7.  i-mate Ultimate 8502

    Aesthetic 3.5 out of 5 Usability 2 out of 5
    Performance 4 out of 5 Connectivity 5 out of 5
    Features 3.5 out of 5 Value for Money 3 out of 5
    Overall 77% Editors' Rating 9.1/10
  8. 8.  i-mate Ultimate 9502

    Aesthetic 3 out of 5 Usability 2 out of 5
    Performance 4 out of 5 Connectivity 5 out of 5
    Features 4 out of 5 Value for Money 3 out of 5
    Overall 76% Editors' Rating 8.3/10
  9. 9.  i-mate Ultimate 6150

    Aesthetic 3 out of 5 Usability 2 out of 5
    Performance 4.5 out of 5 Connectivity 5 out of 5
    Features 3.5 out of 5 Value for Money 4 out of 5
    Overall 72% Editors' Rating 8.3/10
    i-mate Ultimate 6150
  10. 10.  Samsung i780

    Aesthetic 3 out of 5 Usability 3 out of 5
    Performance 3 out of 5 Connectivity 4 out of 5
    Features 4 out of 5 Value for Money 4 out of 5
    Overall 70% Editors' Rating 7.5/10
    Samsung i780
  11. 11.  HTC TyTN II

    Aesthetic 3 out of 5 Usability 3.5 out of 5
    Performance 2 out of 5 Connectivity 4 out of 5
    Features 4 out of 5 Value for Money 1 out of 5
    Overall 68% Editors' Rating 7.2/10
    HTC TyTN II
  12. 12.  Sony Ericsson W960i

    Aesthetic 3 out of 5 Usability 4 out of 5
    Performance 1 out of 5 Connectivity 4 out of 5
    Features 2.5 out of 5 Value for Money 2 out of 5
    Overall 62% Editors' Rating 7.6/10
    Sony Ericsson W960i
  13. 13.  Palm Treo 500v

    Aesthetic 3 out of 5 Usability 4 out of 5
    Performance 2 out of 5 Connectivity 2 out of 5
    Features 3 out of 5 Value for Money 4 out of 5
    Overall 60% Editors' Rating 7.1/10
    Palm Treo 500v
  14. 14.  Nokia E90 Communicator

    Aesthetic 2.5 out of 5 Usability 3 out of 5
    Performance 3.5 out of 5 Connectivity 4 out of 5
    Features 3 out of 5 Value for Money 1 out of 5
    Overall 68% Editors' Rating 8.5/10
    Nokia E90 Communicator
  15. 15.  Nokia N95 8GB

    Aesthetic 2 out of 5 Usability 3 out of 5
    Performance 4 out of 5 Connectivity 4 out of 5
    Features 3 out of 5 Value for Money 1 out of 5
    Overall 68% Editors' Rating 8.3/10
    Nokia N95 8GB

Usability
Running complex mini-computers in a handheld form factor requires excellent interface design and intuitive input. This list indicates the easiest smartphones to use through to those that require more practice.

Best Usability

  1. 1.  Apple iPhone 3G

    Aesthetic 5 out of 5
    Usability 5 out of 5
    Performance 3.5 out of 5
    Connectivity 3.5 out of 5
    Features 4 out of 5
    Value for Money 4 out of 5
    Overall: 81%
    Editor's Rating: 7/10
  2. 2.  Nokia E71

    Aesthetic 4.5 out of 5
    Usability 4 out of 5
    Performance 4 out of 5
    Connectivity 4 out of 5
    Features 4 out of 5
    Value for Money 5 out of 5
    ASUS Eee PC 900
    Overall: 82%
    Editor's Rating: 8/10
  3. 3.  HTC Touch Diamond

    Aesthetic 4.5 out of 5
    Usability 4 out of 5
    Performance 4 out of 5
    Connectivity 4 out of 5
    Features 3.5 out of 5
    Value for Money 3 out of 5
    Overall: 76%
    Editor's Rating: 6.7/10
  4. 4.  Sony Ericsson W960i

    Aesthetic 3 out of 5 Usability 4 out of 5
    Performance 1 out of 5 Connectivity 4 out of 5
    Features 2.5 out of 5 Value for Money 2 out of 5
    Overall 62% Editors' Rating 7.6/10
    Sony Ericsson W960i
  5. 5.  BlackBerry Pearl 8120

    Aesthetic 5 out of 5 Usability 4 out of 5
    Performance 5 out of 5 Connectivity 2.5 out of 5
    Features 2 out of 5 Value for Money 2 out of 5
    Overall 72% Editors' Rating 8.2/10
    ASUS Eee PC 900
  6. 6.  Palm Treo 500v

    Aesthetic 3 out of 5 Usability 4 out of 5
    Performance 2 out of 5 Connectivity 2 out of 5
    Features 3 out of 5 Value for Money 4 out of 5
    Overall 60% Editors' Rating 7.1/10
    Palm Treo 500v
  7. 7.  HTC TyTN II

    Aesthetic 3 out of 5 Usability 3.5 out of 5
    Performance 2 out of 5 Connectivity 4 out of 5
    Features 4 out of 5 Value for Money 1 out of 5
    Overall 68% Editors' Rating 7.2/10
    HTC TyTN II
  8. 8.  HTC Touch Dual

    Aesthetic 4 out of 5 Usability 3.5 out of 5
    Performance 3 out of 5 Connectivity 3 out of 5
    Features 2.5 out of 5 Value for Money 3 out of 5
    Overall 65% Editors' Rating 7.6/10
    HTC Touch Dual
  9. 9.  Samsung i780

    Aesthetic 3 out of 5 Usability 3 out of 5
    Performance 3 out of 5 Connectivity 4 out of 5
    Features 4 out of 5 Value for Money 4 out of 5
    Overall 70% Editors' Rating 7.5/10
    Samsung i780
  10. 10.  Nokia E90 Communicator

    Aesthetic 2.5 out of 5 Usability 3 out of 5
    Performance 3.5 out of 5 Connectivity 4 out of 5
    Features 3 out of 5 Value for Money 1 out of 5
    Overall 68% Editors' Rating 8.5/10
    Nokia E90 Communicator
  11. 11.  HTC Touch Cruise

    Aesthetic 4 out of 5 Usability 3 out of 5
    Performance 3.5 out of 5 Connectivity 5 out of 5
    Features 3.5 out of 5 Value for Money 2 out of 5
    Overall 76% Editors' Rating 8/10
  12. 12.  Nokia N95 8GB

    Aesthetic 2 out of 5 Usability 3 out of 5
    Performance 4 out of 5 Connectivity 4 out of 5
    Features 3 out of 5 Value for Money 1 out of 5
    Overall 68% Editors' Rating 8.3/10
    Nokia N95 8GB
  13. 13.  i-mate Ultimate 8502

    Aesthetic 3.5 out of 5 Usability 2 out of 5
    Performance 4 out of 5 Connectivity 5 out of 5
    Features 3.5 out of 5 Value for Money 3 out of 5
    Overall 77% Editors' Rating 9.1/10
  14. 14.  i-mate Ultimate 9502

    Aesthetic 3 out of 5 Usability 2 out of 5
    Performance 4 out of 5 Connectivity 5 out of 5
    Features 4 out of 5 Value for Money 3 out of 5
    Overall 76% Editors' Rating 8.3/10
  15. 15.  i-mate Ultimate 6150

    Aesthetic 3 out of 5 Usability 2 out of 5
    Performance 4.5 out of 5 Connectivity 5 out of 5
    Features 3 out of 5 Value for Money 1 out of 5
    Overall 68% Editors' Rating 8.3/10
    Nokia N95 8GB

Performance
As with any computer system strong performance is paramount. Under-powered smartphones cannot only impair productivity but also seriously test your patience.

Best Performance

  1. 1.  BlackBerry Pearl 8120

    Aesthetic 5 out of 5
    Usability 4 out of 5
    Performance 5 out of 5
    Connectivity 2.5 out of 5
    Features 2 out of 5
    Value for Money 2 out of 5
    ASUS Eee PC 900
    Overall: 72%
    Editor's Rating: 8.2/10
  2. 2.  i-mate Ultimate 6150

    Aesthetic 3 out of 5
    Usability 2 out of 5
    Performance 4.5 out of 5
    Connectivity 5 out of 5
    Features 3.5 out of 5
    Value for Money 4 out of 5
  3. 3.  Nokia E71

    Aesthetic 4.5 out of 5
    Usability 4 out of 5
    Performance 4 out of 5
    Connectivity 4 out of 5
    Features 4 out of 5
    Value for Money 5 out of 5
    Nokia E71
    Overall: 82%
    Editor's Rating: 8/10
  4. 4.  i-mate Ultimate 8502

    Aesthetic 3.5 out of 5 Usability 2 out of 5
    Performance 4 out of 5 Connectivity 5 out of 5
    Features 3.5 out of 5 Value for Money 3 out of 5
    Overall 77% Editors' Rating 9.1/10
  5. 5.  i-mate Ultimate 9502

    Aesthetic 3 out of 5 Usability 2 out of 5
    Performance 4 out of 5 Connectivity 5 out of 5
    Features 4 out of 5 Value for Money 3 out of 5
    Overall 76% Editors' Rating 8.3/10
  6. 6.  Nokia N95 8GB

    Aesthetic 2 out of 5 Usability 3 out of 5
    Performance 4 out of 5 Connectivity 4 out of 5
    Features 3 out of 5 Value for Money 1 out of 5
    Overall 68% Editors' Rating 8.3/10
    Nokia N95 8GB
  7. 7.  HTC Touch Diamond

    Aesthetic 4.5 out of 5 Usability 4 out of 5
    Performance 4 out of 5 Connectivity 4 out of 5
    Features 3.5 out of 5 Value for Money 3 out of 5
    Overall 76% Editors' Rating 6.7/10
  8. 8.  Apple iPhone 3G

    Aesthetic 5 out of 5 Usability 5 out of 5
    Performance 3.5 out of 5 Connectivity 3.5 out of 5
    Features 4 out of 5 Value for Money 4 out of 5
    Overall 81% Editors' Rating 7/10
  9. 9.  HTC Touch Cruise

    Aesthetic 4 out of 5 Usability 3 out of 5
    Performance 3.5 out of 5 Connectivity 5 out of 5
    Features 3.5 out of 5 Value for Money 2 out of 5
    Overall 76% Editors' Rating 8/10
  10. 10.  Nokia E90 Communicator

    Aesthetic 2.5 out of 5 Usability 3 out of 5
    Performance 3.5 out of 5 Connectivity 4 out of 5
    Features 3 out of 5 Value for Money 1 out of 5
    Overall 68% Editors' Rating 8.5/10
    Nokia E90 Communicator
  11. 11.  Samsung i780

    Aesthetic 3 out of 5 Usability 3 out of 5
    Performance 3 out of 5 Connectivity 4 out of 5
    Features 4 out of 5 Value for Money 4 out of 5
    Overall 70% Editors' Rating 7.5/10
    Samsung i780
  12. 12.  HTC Touch Dual

    Aesthetic 4 out of 5 Usability 3.5 out of 5
    Performance 3 out of 5 Connectivity 3 out of 5
    Features 2.5 out of 5 Value for Money 3 out of 5
    Overall 65% Editors' Rating 7.6/10
    HTC Touch Dual
  13. 13.  Palm Treo 500v

    Aesthetic 3 out of 5 Usability 4 out of 5
    Performance 2 out of 5 Connectivity 2 out of 5
    Features 3 out of 5 Value for Money 4 out of 5
    Overall 60% Editors' Rating 7.1/10
    Palm Treo 500v
  14. 14.  HTC TyTN II

    Aesthetic 3 out of 5 Usability 3.5 out of 5
    Performance 2 out of 5 Connectivity 4 out of 5
    Features 4 out of 5 Value for Money 1 out of 5
    Overall 68% Editors' Rating 7.2/10
    HTC TyTN II
  15. 15.  Sony Ericsson W960i

    Aesthetic 3 out of 5 Usability 4 out of 5
    Performance 1 out of 5 Connectivity 4 out of 5
    Features 2.5 out of 5 Value for Money 2 out of 5
    Overall 62% Editors' Rating 7.6/10
    Sony Ericsson W960i

Connectivity
The ability to connect to the internet and other devices is one of the hallmarks of smartphones. The highest rating devices include 3.5G data speeds, Wi-Fi, GPS, Bluetooth and USB connections. Those with lower scores include varying combinations of these options.

Best Connectivity

  1. 1.  i-mate Ultimate 8502

    Aesthetic 3.5 out of 5
    Usability 2 out of 5
    Performance 4 out of 5
    Connectivity 5 out of 5
    Features 3.5 out of 5
    Value for Money 3 out of 5
    Overall: 77%
    Editor's Rating: 9.1/10
  2. 2.  i-mate Ultimate 9502

    Aesthetic 3 out of 5
    Usability 2 out of 5
    Performance 4 out of 5
    Connectivity 5 out of 5
    Features 4 out of 5
    Value for Money 3 out of 5
    Overall: 76%
    Editor's Rating: 8.3/10
  3. 3.  i-mate Ultimate 6150

    Aesthetic 3 out of 5
    Usability 2 out of 5
    Performance 4.5 out of 5
    Connectivity 5 out of 5
    Features 3.5 out of 5
    Value for Money 4 out of 5
    i-mate Ultimate 6150
    Overall: 72%
    Editor's Rating: 8.3/10
  4. 4.  Nokia E71

    Aesthetic 4.5 out of 5 Usability 4 out of 5
    Performance 4 out of 5 Connectivity 4 out of 5
    Features 4 out of 5 Value for Money 5 out of 5
    Overall 82% Editors' Rating 8/10
    Nokia E71
  5. 5.  Samsung i780

    Aesthetic 3 out of 5 Usability 3 out of 5
    Performance 3 out of 5 Connectivity 4 out of 5
    Features 4 out of 5 Value for Money 4 out of 5
    Overall 70% Editors' Rating 7.5/10
    Samsung i780
  6. 6.  HTC TyTN II

    Aesthetic 3 out of 5 Usability 3.5 out of 5
    Performance 2 out of 5 Connectivity 4 out of 5
    Features 4 out of 5 Value for Money 1 out of 5
    Overall 68% Editors' Rating 7.2/10
    HTC TyTN II
  7. 7.  Nokia E90 Communicator

    Aesthetic 2.5 out of 5 Usability 3 out of 5
    Performance 3.5 out of 5 Connectivity 4 out of 5
    Features 3 out of 5 Value for Money 1 out of 5
    Overall 68% Editors' Rating 8.5/10
    Nokia E90 Communicator
  8. 8.  HTC Touch Diamond

    Aesthetic 4.5 out of 5 Usability 4 out of 5
    Performance 4 out of 5 Connectivity 4 out of 5
    Features 3.5 out of 5 Value for Money 3 out of 5
    Overall 76% Editors' Rating 6.7/10
  9. 9.  Sony Ericsson W960i

    Aesthetic 3 out of 5 Usability 4 out of 5
    Performance 1 out of 5 Connectivity 4 out of 5
    Features 2.5 out of 5 Value for Money 2 out of 5
    Overall 62% Editors' Rating 7.6/10
    Sony Ericsson W960i
  10. 10.  HTC Touch Cruise

    Aesthetic 4 out of 5 Usability 3 out of 5
    Performance 3.5 out of 5 Connectivity 5 out of 5
    Features 3.5 out of 5 Value for Money 2 out of 5
    Overall 76% Editors' Rating 8/10
  11. 11.  Nokia N95 8GB

    Aesthetic 2 out of 5 Usability 3 out of 5
    Performance 4 out of 5 Connectivity 4 out of 5
    Features 3 out of 5 Value for Money 1 out of 5
    Overall 68% Editors' Rating 8.3/10
    Nokia N95 8GB
  12. 12.  Apple iPhone 3G

    Aesthetic 5 out of 5 Usability 5 out of 5
    Performance 3.5 out of 5 Connectivity 3.5 out of 5
    Features 4 out of 5 Value for Money 4 out of 5
    Overall 81% Editors' Rating 7/10
  13. 13.  HTC Touch Dual

    Aesthetic 4 out of 5 Usability 3.5 out of 5
    Performance 3 out of 5 Connectivity 3 out of 5
    Features 2.5 out of 5 Value for Money 3 out of 5
    Overall 65% Editors' Rating 7.6/10
    HTC Touch Dual
  14. 14.  BlackBerry Pearl 8120

    Aesthetic 5 out of 5 Usability 4 out of 5
    Performance 5 out of 5 Connectivity 2.5 out of 5
    Features 2 out of 5 Value for Money 2 out of 5
    Overall 72% Editors' Rating 8.2/10
    ASUS Eee PC 900
  15. 15.  Palm Treo 500v

    Aesthetic 3 out of 5 Usability 4 out of 5
    Performance 2 out of 5 Connectivity 2 out of 5
    Features 3 out of 5 Value for Money 4 out of 5
    Overall 60% Editors' Rating 7.1/10
    Palm Treo 500v

Features
Similar to basic consumer mobile phones, smartphones can include a range of useful features, but rarely does a single device include all sought-after features. The list below ranks the smartphones with the best collection of sought-after features.

Best Features

  1. 1.  Nokia E71

    Aesthetic 4.5 out of 5
    Usability 4 out of 5
    Performance 4 out of 5
    Connectivity 4 out of 5
    Features 4 out of 5
    Value for Money 5 out of 5
    Nokia E71
    Overall: 82%
    Editor's Rating: 8/10
  2. 2.  i-mate Ultimate 9502

    Aesthetic 3 out of 5
    Usability 2 out of 5
    Performance 4 out of 5
    Connectivity 5 out of 5
    Features 4 out of 5
    Value for Money 3 out of 5
    Overall: 76%
    Editor's Rating: 8.3/10
  3. 3.  Apple iPhone 3G

    Aesthetic 5 out of 5
    Usability 5 out of 5
    Performance 3.5 out of 5
    Connectivity 3.5 out of 5
    Features 4 out of 5
    Value for Money 4 out of 5
    Overall: 81%
    Editor's Rating: 7/10
  4. 4.  Samsung i780

    Aesthetic 3 out of 5 Usability 3 out of 5
    Performance 3 out of 5 Connectivity 4 out of 5
    Features 4 out of 5 Value for Money 4 out of 5
    Overall 70% Editors' Rating 7.5/10
    Samsung i780
  5. 5.  HTC TyTN II

    Aesthetic 3 out of 5 Usability 3.5 out of 5
    Performance 2 out of 5 Connectivity 4 out of 5
    Features 4 out of 5 Value for Money 1 out of 5
    Overall 68% Editors' Rating 7.2/10
    HTC TyTN II
  6. 6.  i-mate Ultimate 8502

    Aesthetic 3.5 out of 5 Usability 2 out of 5
    Performance 4 out of 5 Connectivity 5 out of 5
    Features 3.5 out of 5 Value for Money 3 out of 5
    Overall 77% Editors' Rating 9.1/10
  7. 7.  HTC Touch Cruise

    Aesthetic 4 out of 5 Usability 3 out of 5
    Performance 3.5 out of 5 Connectivity 5 out of 5
    Features 3.5 out of 5 Value for Money 2 out of 5
    Overall 76% Editors' Rating 8/10
  8. 8.  HTC Touch Diamond

    Aesthetic 4.5 out of 5 Usability 4 out of 5
    Performance 4 out of 5 Connectivity 4 out of 5
    Features 3.5 out of 5 Value for Money 3 out of 5
    Overall 76% Editors' Rating 6.7/10
  9. 9.  i-mate Ultimate 6150

    Aesthetic 3 out of 5 Usability 2 out of 5
    Performance 4.5 out of 5 Connectivity 5 out of 5
    Features 3.5 out of 5 Value for Money 4 out of 5
    Overall 72% Editors' Rating 8.3/10
    i-mate Ultimate 6150
  10. 10.  Palm Treo 500v

    Aesthetic 3 out of 5 Usability 4 out of 5
    Performance 2 out of 5 Connectivity 2 out of 5
    Features 3 out of 5 Value for Money 4 out of 5
    Overall 60% Editors' Rating 7.1/10
    Palm Treo 500v
  11. 11.  Nokia N95 8GB

    Aesthetic 2 out of 5 Usability 3 out of 5
    Performance 4 out of 5 Connectivity 4 out of 5
    Features 3 out of 5 Value for Money 1 out of 5
    Overall 68% Editors' Rating 8.3/10
    Nokia N95 8GB
  12. 12.  Nokia E90 Communicator

    Aesthetic 2.5 out of 5 Usability 3 out of 5
    Performance 3.5 out of 5 Connectivity 4 out of 5
    Features 3 out of 5 Value for Money 1 out of 5
    Overall 68% Editors' Rating 8.5/10
    Nokia E90 Communicator
  13. 13.  HTC Touch Dual

    Aesthetic 4 out of 5 Usability 3.5 out of 5
    Performance 3 out of 5 Connectivity 3 out of 5
    Features 2.5 out of 5 Value for Money 3 out of 5
    Overall 65% Editors' Rating 7.6/10
    HTC Touch Dual
  14. 14.  Sony Ericsson W960i

    Aesthetic 3 out of 5 Usability 4 out of 5
    Performance 1 out of 5 Connectivity 4 out of 5
    Features 2.5 out of 5 Value for Money 2 out of 5
    Overall 62% Editors' Rating 7.6/10
    Sony Ericsson W960i
  15. 15.  BlackBerry Pearl 8120

    Aesthetic 5 out of 5 Usability 4 out of 5
    Performance 5 out of 5 Connectivity 2.5 out of 5
    Features 2 out of 5 Value for Money 2 out of 5
    Overall 72% Editors' Rating 8.2/10
    ASUS Eee PC 900

Value for money
Perhaps the most difficult criteria to evaluate, value for money takes all other criteria into consideration and compares this result to the recommended retail price.

Best Value

  1. 1.  Nokia E71

    Aesthetic 4.5 out of 5
    Usability 4 out of 5
    Performance 4 out of 5
    Connectivity 4 out of 5
    Features 4 out of 5
    Value for Money 5 out of 5
    Nokia E71
    Overall: 82%
    Editor's Rating: 8/10
  2. 2.  Apple iPhone 3G

    Aesthetic 5 out of 5
    Usability 5 out of 5
    Performance 3.5 out of 5
    Connectivity 3.5 out of 5
    Features 4 out of 5
    Value for Money 4 out of 5
    Overall: 81%
    Editor's Rating: 7/10
  3. 3.  Samsung i780

    Aesthetic 3 out of 5
    Usability 3 out of 5
    Performance 3 out of 5
    Connectivity 4 out of 5
    Features 4 out of 5
    Value for Money 4 out of 5
    Samsung i780
    Overall: 70%
    Editor's Rating: 7.5/10
  4. 4.  i-mate Ultimate 8502

    Aesthetic 3.5 out of 5 Usability 2 out of 5
    Performance 4 out of 5 Connectivity 5 out of 5
    Features 3.5 out of 5 Value for Money 3 out of 5
    Overall 77% Editors' Rating 9.1/10
  5. 5.  i-mate Ultimate 9502

    Aesthetic 3 out of 5 Usability 2 out of 5
    Performance 4 out of 5 Connectivity 5 out of 5
    Features 4 out of 5 Value for Money 3 out of 5
    Overall 76% Editors' Rating 8.3/10
  6. 6.  HTC Touch Diamond

    Aesthetic 4.5 out of 5 Usability 4 out of 5
    Performance 4 out of 5 Connectivity 4 out of 5
    Features 3.5 out of 5 Value for Money 3 out of 5
    Overall 76% Editors' Rating 6.7/10
  7. 7.  i-mate Ultimate 6150

    Aesthetic 3 out of 5 Usability 2 out of 5
    Performance 4.5 out of 5 Connectivity 5 out of 5
    Features 3.5 out of 5 Value for Money 4 out of 5
    Overall 72% Editors' Rating 8.3/10
    i-mate Ultimate 6150
  8. 8.  HTC Touch Dual

    Aesthetic 4 out of 5 Usability 3.5 out of 5
    Performance 3 out of 5 Connectivity 3 out of 5
    Features 2.5 out of 5 Value for Money 3 out of 5
    Overall 65% Editors' Rating 7.6/10
    HTC Touch Dual
  9. 9.  Sony Ericsson W960i

    Aesthetic 3 out of 5 Usability 4 out of 5
    Performance 1 out of 5 Connectivity 4 out of 5
    Features 2.5 out of 5 Value for Money 2 out of 5
    Overall 62% Editors' Rating 7.6/10
    Sony Ericsson W960i
  10. 10.  Palm Treo 500v

    Aesthetic 3 out of 5 Usability 4 out of 5
    Performance 2 out of 5 Connectivity 2 out of 5
    Features 3 out of 5 Value for Money 4 out of 5
    Overall 60% Editors' Rating 7.1/10
    Palm Treo 500v
  11. 11.  BlackBerry Pearl 8120

    Aesthetic 5 out of 5 Usability 4 out of 5
    Performance 5 out of 5 Connectivity 2.5 out of 5
    Features 2 out of 5 Value for Money 2 out of 5
    Overall 72% Editors' Rating 8.2/10
    BlackBerry Pearl 8120
  12. 12.  HTC Touch Cruise

    Aesthetic 4 out of 5 Usability 3 out of 5
    Performance 3.5 out of 5 Connectivity 5 out of 5
    Features 3.5 out of 5 Value for Money 2 out of 5
    Overall 76% Editors' Rating 8/10
  13. 13.  HTC TyTN II

    Aesthetic 3 out of 5 Usability 3.5 out of 5
    Performance 2 out of 5 Connectivity 4 out of 5
    Features 4 out of 5 Value for Money 1 out of 5
    Overall 68% Editors' Rating 7.2/10
    HTC TyTN II
  14. 14.  Nokia N95 8GB

    Aesthetic 2 out of 5 Usability 3 out of 5
    Performance 4 out of 5 Connectivity 4 out of 5
    Features 3 out of 5 Value for Money 1 out of 5
    Overall 68% Editors' Rating 8.3/10
    Nokia N95 8GB
  15. 15.  Nokia E90 Communicator

    Aesthetic 2.5 out of 5 Usability 3 out of 5
    Performance 3.5 out of 5 Connectivity 4 out of 5
    Features 3 out of 5 Value for Money 1 out of 5
    Overall 68% Editors' Rating 8.5/10
    Nokia E90 Communicator

Editors' rating
Our editors' rating not only compares the basic criteria and value for money, but also considers the market the smartphone is released into. With technology changing rapidly our editors' ratings act as a barometer of value that is otherwise difficult to assess based on specifications alone.

Editors' Rating

  1. 1.  i-mate Ultimate 8502

    Aesthetic 3.5 out of 5
    Usability 2 out of 5
    Performance 4 out of 5
    Connectivity 5 out of 5
    Features 3.5 out of 5
    Value for Money 3 out of 5
    Overall: 77%
    Editor's Rating: 9.1/10
  2. 2.  Nokia E90 Communicator

    Aesthetic 2.5 out of 5
    Usability 3 out of 5
    Performance 3.5 out of 5
    Connectivity 4 out of 5
    Features 3 out of 5
    Value for Money 1 out of 5
    Nokia E90 Communicator
    Overall: 68%
    Editor's Rating: 8.5/10
  3. 3.  i-mate Ultimate 9502

    Aesthetic 3 out of 5
    Usability 2 out of 5
    Performance 4 out of 5
    Connectivity 5 out of 5
    Features 4 out of 5
    Value for Money 3 out of 5
    Overall: 76%
    Editor's Rating: 8.3/10
  4. 4.  i-mate Ultimate 6150

    Aesthetic 3 out of 5 Usability 2 out of 5
    Performance 4.5 out of 5 Connectivity 5 out of 5
    Features 3.5 out of 5 Value for Money 4 out of 5
    Overall 72% Editors' Rating 8.3/10
    i-mate Ultimate 6150
  5. 5.  Nokia N95 8GB

    Aesthetic 2 out of 5 Usability 3 out of 5
    Performance 4 out of 5 Connectivity 4 out of 5
    Features 3 out of 5 Value for Money 1 out of 5
    Overall 68% Editors' Rating 8.3/10
    Nokia N95 8GB
  6. 6.  BlackBerry Pearl 8120

    Aesthetic 5 out of 5 Usability 4 out of 5
    Performance 5 out of 5 Connectivity 2.5 out of 5
    Features 2 out of 5 Value for Money 2 out of 5
    Overall 72% Editors' Rating 8.2/10
    ASUS Eee PC 900
  7. 7.  HTC Touch Cruise

    Aesthetic 4 out of 5 Usability 3 out of 5
    Performance 3.5 out of 5 Connectivity 5 out of 5
    Features 3.5 out of 5 Value for Money 2 out of 5
    Overall 76% Editors' Rating 8/10
  8. 8.  Nokia E71

    Aesthetic 4.5 out of 5 Usability 4 out of 5
    Performance 4 out of 5 Connectivity 4 out of 5
    Features 4 out of 5 Value for Money 5 out of 5
    Overall 82% Editors' Rating 8/10
    Nokia E71
  9. 9.  HTC Touch Dual

    Aesthetic 4 out of 5 Usability 3.5 out of 5
    Performance 3 out of 5 Connectivity 3 out of 5
    Features 2.5 out of 5 Value for Money 3 out of 5
    Overall 65% Editors' Rating 7.6/10
    HTC Touch Dual
  10. 10.  Sony Ericsson W960i

    Aesthetic 3 out of 5 Usability 4 out of 5
    Performance 1 out of 5 Connectivity 4 out of 5
    Features 2.5 out of 5 Value for Money 2 out of 5
    Overall 62% Editors' Rating 7.6/10
    Sony Ericsson W960i
  11. 11.  Samsung i780

    Aesthetic 3 out of 5 Usability 3 out of 5
    Performance 3 out of 5 Connectivity 4 out of 5
    Features 4 out of 5 Value for Money 4 out of 5
    Overall 70% Editors' Rating 7.5/10
    Samsung i780
  12. 12.  HTC TyTN II

    Aesthetic 3 out of 5 Usability 3.5 out of 5
    Performance 2 out of 5 Connectivity 4 out of 5
    Features 4 out of 5 Value for Money 1 out of 5
    Overall 68% Editors' Rating 7.2/10
    HTC TyTN II
  13. 13.  Palm Treo 500v

    Aesthetic 3 out of 5 Usability 4 out of 5
    Performance 4 out of 5 Connectivity 5 out of 5
    Features 3.5 out of 5 Value for Money 3 out of 5
    Overall 60% Editors' Rating 7.1/10
    Palm Treo 500v
  14. 14.  Apple iPhone 3G

    Aesthetic 5 out of 5 Usability 5 out of 5
    Performance 3.5 out of 5 Connectivity 3.5 out of 5
    Features 4 out of 5 Value for Money 4 out of 5
    Overall 81% Editors' Rating 7/10
  15. 15.  HTC Touch Diamond

    Aesthetic 4.5 out of 5 Usability 4 out of 5
    Performance 4 out of 5 Connectivity 4 out of 5
    Features 3.5 out of 5 Value for Money 3 out of 5
    Overall 76% Editors' Rating 6.7/10

Copyright © 2009 CBS Interactive, a CBS Company. All Rights Reserved.
ZDNET is a registered service mark of CBS Interactive. ZDNET Logo is a service mark of CBS Interactive.