Power trip: Four high-end notebooks tested

By
28 February 2003 03:40 PM
Tags: high end, acer, thinkpad, toshiba, ibm, lifebook, fujitsu, power

Acer Travelmate 426LC

Acer Travelmate 426LC

Acer's entry into our dream notebook review has a couple of things that make it noteworthy. For a start, it's the cheapest unit, by quite a long margin; AU$3,999 will net you a basic Travelmate 426LC, more than a thousand dollars cheaper than the next contender, the IBM Thinkpad T30.

Some of this relative budget status comes from the internal hardware used. The Travelmate 426LC is the only system in our roundup to use a desktop Pentium processor -- a 2.4Ghz Pentium 4, making it, in MHz terms at least, the fastest system in our roundup. The plus of having a desktop processor -- cheaper overall price -- does bring with it some drawbacks, however. For a start, desktop processors use more power than their notebook cousins, and this was amply demonstrated in the Travelmate 426LC's comparatively dismal battery life scores, where it consistently came last. This was most marked in the reader tests, where it piked out half an hour before its competition.

Physically the most striking thing about the Travelmate 426LC is the keyboard, which is arranged in a smile-like pattern, with the external keys most noticeably splayed outwards and upwards. Presumably this is for ergonomic reasons, but if you're used to more conventional keyboards, it will take some getting used to. Mouse control is via a fairly standard touchpad with some highly unusual buttons underneath it. We were somewhat irked by the mouse buttons underneath, which are quite large but quite unresponsive to go with it. Acer's forgone a rocker switch in favour of an unusual rocker circle. Again, it's an oddity that you'd have to get used to.

The Travelmate 420's 15" screen was quite acceptable and visible from quite a wide angle. Like most Acer notebooks, a feature of the Travelmate 426LC is an integrated secure digital slot. In the case of this notebook, it sits above the single PCMCIA slot. Like IBM, Acer's rather keen on corporate customers, and positions the SD slot as part of a complete security package.

Power trip:
Four high-end
notebooks tested

Introduction
1. Acer Travelmate 426LC
2. Fujitsu Lifebook E7010
3. IBM Thinkpad T30
4. Toshiba Satellite 5200
Benchmark results
Specifications
Its mix of desktop and notebook parts gave the Travelmate 426LC an interesting spread in our benchmarking tests. Shipping with only 256MB of memory saw it fall behind the technically slower systems that came with 512MB in our performance tests, although it did beat out the IBM Thinkpad T30 in performance terms. The larger price paid, though, was in battery life in all of our tests, as noted above.

Ultimately the Travelmate 426LC isn't a bad notebook by any stretch of the imagination, but it is rather overshadowed by some of the powerhouses offered to us by other companies. At its current price, too, we were rather surprised to find that the notebooks in our budget notebooks coverage nipped at its heels in overall performance terms.

Acer Travelmate 426LC
Company: Acer Computer Australia
Price: AU$3,999
Distributor: Selected resellers
Phone: 1300 366 567

Advertisement

Talkback 0 comments

Reviews by category

Sponsored content

Power Centre - Content from our premier sponsors

Blogs

  • David Braue 12 days without ADSL: A local loop eulogy
    When your broadband speeds are limited to 38Kbps it's not hard to join the ranks of people demanding the NBN already. Telstra's copper network is a renovator's delight.
  • Array An abridged history of the Aussie internet
    Journalist Glenda Korporaal has written "20 years of the internet in Australia" to commemorate two decades of AARNET. On this week's Twisted Wire I talk to Glenda and Chris Hancock, the CEO of AARNET.
  • Array G'Day USA: Aussie start-ups head to America
    The G'Day USA: Australia Week campaign today announced the finalists for the Innovation Shoot Out event, which will see eight Australian technology start-ups travel to San Francisco in January 2010 to demonstrate the commercial viability of their products in the US.
  • More blogs »

Tags

Back to top

Featured