Wireless crackdown


Contents
Introduction
AirDefense v AirMagnet
AirDefense v AirMagnet 2
AirDefense v AirMagnet 3
Comparison table
Bluesocket WG-1100
SonicWall Pro 5060
Specifications
Editor's choice
About RMIT

User interface -- AirDefense
While looking a little bland when compared to the AirMagnet front end, the AirDefense user interface is comprehensive and relatively easy to navigate, although at times you do have to drill down further than its competitor to glean information. The front dashboard does, at a glance, convey lot of critical information and it could be argued that because it is simpler and less cluttered than AirMagnet, alerts are more easily noticed.

A particularly neat screen is the Alarm display which, for example, can be configured to display the last seven days with concise descriptions of the events in the left pane and a graphical representation of each day in the right pane. Reporting is not as extensive as AirMagnet's and the reports not quite as fancy as its competitor but they are complete and do not lack in critical information.

Another string to AirDefense's bow is AirDefense Personal which can be installed on your fleet of roaming notebooks to provide security outside of your secure infrastructure, it fully integrates into the AirDefense Enterprise system and policies and policy changes are automatically uploaded to AD Personal when users reconnect to the LAN. While out and about the user is notified of any threats and the threat log is downloaded to the enterprise system when the notebook next logs on.

User interface -- AirMagnet
Of the two interfaces AirMagnet's is certainly the most attractive and it manages to cram an astonishing amount of information in the status screen. The large swag of information is presented very well, but the sheer volume can be a bit daunting for a first time user as you don't quite know which graph to peruse.

The remainder of the displays do not present the user with such an information overload and are definitely less intimidating although they do manage to still squeeze more information into each screen than AirDefense.

Luckily, or perhaps unluckily, AirMagnet's colour code all items, so at times the display is a riot of colour, but once you become familiar with it your eye can quickly target the information you are after.

AirMagnet's array of "canned" reports are extensive, far more so than AirDefense, and as you might imagine given the colourful nature of the interface they are cosmetically prettier. But do not mistake good looks for lack of information, the reports are every bit as detailed as the AirDefense reports and are formatted in such a way that they can slip right into your management reports with minimal tinkering.

         
 
Product AirDefense
Price AU$39,007
Vendor Pacific Data (distributor)
Phone 03 9820 0322
Web www.airdefense.net
www.pacificdata.net.au
 
Interoperability
Software resides on a hardened appliance, integrates with Cisco WLSE, can utilise APs from Cisco as basic sensors.
Futureproofing ½
The 1150 appliance only supports 250 sensors but the 2270 can support 600 sensors; good notification features.
ROI
Very good performance, simple user interface, extensive feature list but very costly when compared to the competition.
Service
Maintenance includes 5 x 12 technical support via phone, fax, e-mail, and Web support. Four hour guaranteed response time. AirDefense customers also have access to AirDefense channel partner service maintenance agreement.
Rating ½
 
Product AirMagnet Enterprise
Price AU$11,595
With Dell SC430 Server AU$14,357
Vendor Redbridge Solutions (distributor)
Phone 02 9959 9620
Web www.airmagnet.com
www.redbridge.com.au
 
Interoperability
Relatively modest server hadware requirements, Windows only for server, integrates with Cisco WLSE and other vendors, can utilise APs from Cisco with limited functionality.
Futureproofing
Modest hardware can support up to 1500 sensors, very good notification features.
ROI
Very good performance, relatively simple user interface, extensive feature list, relatively inexpensive.
Service
First-year support (including free upgrades) included with package. Support available Mon-Fri 6am to 6pm, phone, e-mail, and Web support. Warranty turn around time is one day.
Rating
 
         
Advertisement

Talkback 0 comments

Back to top

Featured