HSDPA: BigPond vs Vodafone

High-speed mobile broadband has arrived! We compare Telstra's BigPond Wireless Next G service with Vodafone's HSDPA-enhanced 3G network.

At first it was enough just to remain online while you were on the road. But the joy of go-anywhere convenience came with a caveat: even 3G failed to match the speed of the cheapest and slowest home ADSL line.

Now wireless broadband has hit its stride, with the mobile carriers leading their super-charged networks in a new race for the road warrior's business. Telstra and Vodafone are first off the starter's line, with real-world speeds that bend the needle past 1Mbps. So if you want downloads to hurtle rather than turtle over the airwaves and onto your laptop, read on to find the best mobile broadband bet.

BigPond Next G Wireless Broadband Mobile Card BigPond Next G Wireless Broadband Mobile Card
Fancy a 1.3Mbps broadband pipeline direct to your notebook, without a cable in sight? The new BigPond wireless data card makes good on Telstra's lofty promises for its Next G network.


Vodafone Mobile Connect 3G HSDPA Card Vodafone Mobile Connect 3G HSDPA Card
Vodafone's enhanced notebook PC Card delivers what the mobile telco calls 'business class 3G broadband' -- but until more of the 3G network is upgraded with HSDPA, most users will remain stuck in economy seats.

Advertisement

Talkback 8 comments

    Voda doesnt compare Milton Foddder -- 16/11/06

    How can you compare Voda to Telstra...Next G is Australia wide and Voda is only in a few capital cities. Once you go outside Voda's network you get .........not much. As long as they only concentrate on Sydney and Melbourne they will never be anything

    Voda/ Telstra HSDPA Anonymous -- 16/11/06 (in reply to #320071470)

    Lets remember that Rome was not built over night... The technology across both networks is the same. I had tried my new card on the Gold Coast and received 1.8Mbps straight off the mark. I gather that Voda likes to make sure that the coverage is what it says it is before bragging too much and that may be the reason why only Melbourne and Sydney have been officially announced. Its great to see good competition.

    850MHz versus 2Ghz Anonymous -- 29/11/06 (in reply to #320071498)

    The technology is not quite identical in so far the frequencies used by the two carriers are distinctly differnet- The main advantage of NextG is the fact that it operates within the 850MHz band.

    This fact gives the NextG network much better coverage as higher frequency signals such as used by Vodaphone on their HSDPA network will result in more signal attenuation for the same distance covered.

    At the end of the day coverage will be better using the 850MHz band versus the 1800 - 2.1 GHz bands.

    Telstra NextG lives up to promise Brian C -- 16/11/06

    I have just got the imate JASJAM PDA phone from a Telstra shop and tried that as a wireless modem for my laptop. The speed I got was close to 1 Mbps. That is sensational. And as others has pointed out, NextG has much wider coverage. Let's give credit where credit is due. Telstra wins this round, no doubt.

    Jasjam Anonymous -- 24/12/06 (in reply to #320071492)

    For nearly $2k? You've gotta be havin a larf!

    Telstra $80 plan is great value BrianC -- 01/03/07 (in reply to #320072433)

    I spent over $80 every month for the last few years. When I realised Telstra has the $80 plan that includes a free JASJAM, I jumped at the offer. Have been using it since Nov last year. Great phone. Great quality. My best investment.

    $80 great value ???? Anonymous -- 10/12/07 (in reply to #320075568)

    I'd check your bill. Its an $ 80 plan, plus $41.20 for 24 months, plus $ 300 initial outlay (as the phone is valued at over $1000) plus $ 30/month for your mobile broad band. ie In excess of $ 140 per month.

    The Jasjam imate (hardware) is a joke, Ive had two go to the tip within 12 months. The only thing worse than the hardware is the (lack of) service with Telstra dealing with it.

    Summary. Dont touch it. Look elsewhere.

    JasJam Call Drop-outs Michael Doherty -- 05/05/07

    I have been experiencing lots of call drop outs in Sydney with the JasJam on NextG/UMTS. Git the SMS message a few weeks back asking me to instakk a new ROM version for it (apparently so that the device can do simultaneous voice / data calls - something that I have done in the past anyway) did the upgrade, (a bit of a pain as everything gets wiped) and now the call drop-outs seem to be even worse! Jasam seems like a good device (it replaced by iMate PocketPC) but the combination of JAsJAm and NextG does not make for a good mobile phone experience...

Add your opinion

Reviews by category

Latest Videos

Sponsored content

Power Centre - Content from our premier sponsors

Blogs

  • Phil Dobbie A guide to the future of the internet
    Last week we looked at the history of the internet in Australia. It's been around for 20 years and changed our lives in so many ways. Imagine what it could do given another 20 years.
  • Array Carelessness busts Linux security
    No operating system can ever properly protect a computer from trojans as long as users continue to do silly things. Just because Linux is immune to your standard drive-by viruses it does not mean that it can escape trojan horses.
  • Array Sun shining on Ajnaware
    Graham Dawson talks about the future of iPhone app development and augmented reality.
  • More blogs »

Tags

Back to top

Featured