Broadband to go: 3G data card round-up

By David Flynn, ZDNet Australia
20 December 2005 12:08 PM
Tags: broadband, internet, mobile, wireless, data, access, card, 3g

After years of fiddling with mobile phone hook-ups just to dawdle along at GSM speeds, hunting down hotspots or just making do without Net access on the road, the arrival of 3G is like manna from heaven for the mobile digerati.

3G data cards slide into a notebook's PC Card slot and hitch a ride on the nascent third-gen phone networks. 3G data speeds peak at 384kbps -- slightly more than entry-level ADSL but a serious leg-on on the 50kbps ceiling of the GSM-based GPRS channels, which in the real world tend to lag behind even a dial-up modem.

Of course, the coverage of a 3G card is only as good as the underlying network, which can make a difference depending on your travel habits. The limited roll-out of 3G means it's certainly not a case of being 'Internet anywhere': that honour goes to Telstra's BigPond Wireless Broadband, which piggybacks onto Telstra's advanced EV-DO service. It's also why most data cards can fall back to their parents' more extensive GSM networks when 3G isn't available.

(The exceptions are Telstra's card, which drops back onto CDMA; and 3's NetConnect card, which connects to Telstra's GSM service because 3 has no GSM network of its own. This can in fact happen inside 3G coverage areas where the Telstra signal is stronger than the 3G one. This roaming incurs an AU$1.65/MB tariff, although the NetConnect card's software settings can be adjusted to prevent GSM handover).

Telstra, 3, Vodafone and Optus aren't the only ways to get into the broadband on-the-move game. Wireless ISPs iBurst and Unwired also have PC Cards and run on dedicated data network at speeds closer the true 'broadband' rate of to 1Mbps, but with obviously limited coverage compared to the phone networks - for example, Unwired's PC card service works best only in selected locations in Sydney and isn't really meant for use 'on the move'. Unwired has, however, announced plans to start selling a long-awaited PCMCIA card version of its broadband modem for laptops on Boxing Day (December 26, 2005).


Vodafone Mobile Connect
Vodafone Mobile Connect
Read review


Aggressive pricing, a slice of speed-boosting tech and a tempting 'unlimited' downloads plan puts Vodafone in pole position in the race for 3G datacard customers.


Optus Wireless Connect
Optus Wireless Connect
Read review


Optus' combo PC Card ticks every box on the wireless menu, including 3G, GPRS and Wi-Fi, to serve road warriors with a smorgasbord of connectivity.


Telstra BigPond Wireless Broadband
Telstra BigPond Wireless Broadband
Read review


As long as you're a metropolitan broadband user, Telstra BigPond Wireless Broadband delivers well, but it can't be said to be an inexpensive broadband option.


3 Mobile Internet NetConnect Card
3 Mobile Internet NetConnect Card
Read review


The 3 Mobile Internet NetConnect Card is a reliable wireless broadband option, but the usual "subject to coverage area" caveats apply.

Advertisement

Talkback 1 comments

    Better attention to detail, please Mr Three Gee -- 09/01/06 (in reply to #120126703)

    David Flynn says...

    "After years of fiddling with mobile phone hook-ups just to dawdle along at GSM speeds, "

    Interesting - most people would use either GPRS or CDMA 1xRTT.

    "3G data speeds peak at 384kbps -- "

    Not really. The theoretical speed of EV-DO is 2.4Mbit/s down, 153kbit/s up; however, due to a limitation in the PCMCIA interface, 2Mbit/s is the best you'll get under laboratory conditions, and 8-900kbit/s down in ideal real-world ones.

    UMTS is 1,920kbit/s down although the current implementation on most networks usually only reaches 384kbit/s. It's not a peak rate however, but the sustained rate as long as the network is lightly loaded. Presently, the upstream data rate is 64kbit/s on most UMTS networks and don't forget the latency, which is about twice as high at ~220ms average compared to EV-DO.

    It's also worth nothing that UMTS drops down to the very slow and extremely high-latency GPRS when out of 3G coverage. EV-DO in comparison drops down to CDMA 1xRTT, which is more tolerable in terms of data speeds (153kbit/s down) and latency.

Reviews by category

Sponsored content

Power Centre - Content from our premier sponsors

Blogs

  • Chris Duckett Get extensions going in Firefox, redux
    Previously on Null Pointer we looked at getting extensions working in Firefox betas, and that was great until the fine folks at Firefox changed their minds.
  • Array How reliable is IP telephony?
    Have you ever heard a weird kind of hissing, crackling or popping noise when calling someone on an IP telephony line? How rare is the phenomenon these days?
  • Array Forget the NBN, 100Mbps is already here
    Telstra and TransACT will shortly begin offering 100Mbps broadband to many customers. By moving early, the companies have not only raised the bar for Australia's broadband services, but thrown down a challenge to a government that now faces increased pressure to deliver the NBN as promised.
  • More blogs »

Tags

Back to top

Featured