Personal Assistance: 9 PDAs tested

By Alex Kidman
27 June 2003 01:00 PM
Tags: handheld, pdas, pocket pc, gadget, zire, axim, clie, toshiba

Palm Tungsten C

Palm Tungsten C The Tungsten C offers WiFi at an exceptionally good price.

The Tungsten C resembles Palm's legacy PDAs in a visual sense, and it's one of only two PDAs in our roundup to come with an integrated keyboard. There are two catches with the Tungsten's keyboard, however. Firstly, it's very small, and relies on a function button to access characters that you may need continually -- most notably, all of the numerical characters. Secondly, the existence of the keyboard means there's no Graffiti area, although you can set the screen to accept Graffiti input instead. This isn't perfect; if Graffiti failed to recognise our test character it often just scribbled on the screen.

The Tungsten C sports the current PDA heavyweight champ, the Intel PXA255 400MHz XScale processor; that's the same beast that powers the Dell Axim and HP iPAQ Pocket PC h5450. The main difference, of course, is that the Tungsten C isn't attempting to run Pocket PC 2002/2003; it's running Palm's considerably more streamlined Palm OS 5, which should in theory give the processor more headroom for future applications; for the moment, however, there's not a lot of perceptible difference outside of very heavy multimedia applications.

On the subject of applications, Palm's made pretty sure that the Tungsten C can be used for just about any PDA capable task right out of the box. These range from simple world clocks to Avantgo's web retrieval software to Acrobat reader and Kinoma Video player. As usual with most modern Palm PDAs, you get a copy of the useful Palm Desktop software for PC-based manipulation of your mobile data.

PDAs
Introduction
1. Dell Axim X5
2. HP iPAQ h1910
3. HP iPAQ h5450
4. Palm Tungsten C
5. Palm Zire 71
6. Sony CLIE PEG-SJ22
7. Sony CLIE PEG-TG50
8. Toshiba e350
9. Toshiba e750
Editor's choice
The Tungsten C is also Palm's pitch at the wireless connectivity market, using integrated 802.11b. Two things worried us with the Tungsten C's wireless implementation. Firstly, when you're setting up WEP implementation, the private WEP key is displayed for all the world to see. Subsequent access of this setting obscures it behind the industry standard asterisks, but we figure making WEP less secure isn't a good thing. The other problem we hit with the Tungsten's wireless implementation is that we couldn't get it to connect to our WEP-enabled wireless network in any way or shape. Ad-hoc it was fine, and with a non-WEP enabled network it was happy, and previous testing with a Tungsten has shown its wireless connectivity to be simple to use, so this may have just been a factor with our test model. It would also be nice if the OS supported an onscreen indicator to show that the wireless antenna is on; the only way you can see if you're connected and burning power is via the preferences panel.

Palm's always sold itself on battery life, and while the figures that vendors give are often suspect -- especially if you're intermittently using WiFi -- we've seen battery figures around the 7 hour mark in previous tests. That's well above anything that a Pocket PC device can currently manage without the use of additional batteries.

We reckon that the Tungsten C does just about everything right; it's got solid battery life, a mostly future-proof specification and wireless connectivity in a package that comes in at AU$999. The line between the three models competing for our high-end Editor's choice was very thin indeed, and if the Palm's attempts at connecting to our wireless LAN had been successful, it could well have come out on top. As it is, it's still highly recommended and certainly the best Palm PDA you can get.

Palm Tungsten C
Company: Palm Australia
Price: AU$999
Distributor: Selected resellers
Phone: 1300 302 959

Advertisement

Talkback 3 comments

    I am interested only in limite ...Anonymous -- 23/01/04

    I am interested only in limited features in a PDA like the Phonebook, Birthday or Anniversary date storages etc. etc.
    So which pDA do you recommend me to have that should have some high Battery backup and long-life warranty?

    I was very interested in your ...Anonymous -- 12/02/04

    I was very interested in your reviews of pdas and would like your opinion of the Viewsonic range of pda,s
    the V37 in particular.
    how does it compare to the HP models with similar
    price ,power etc.
    regards

    Has anyone successfully connec ...Anonymous -- 10/09/04

    Has anyone successfully connected a web-cam to an iPaq 3970 and used it in a car as a "reversing video" system? Details of software etc please?
    Maurie Costello

Add your opinion

Reviews by category

Sponsored content

Power Centre - Content from our premier sponsors

Blogs

  • Renai LeMay How reliable is IP telephony?
    Have you ever heard a weird kind of hissing, crackling or popping noise when calling someone on an IP telephony line? How rare is the phenomenon these days?
  • Array Forget the NBN, 100Mbps is already here
    Telstra and TransACT will shortly begin offering 100Mbps broadband to many customers. By moving early, the companies have not only raised the bar for Australia's broadband services, but thrown down a challenge to a government that now faces increased pressure to deliver the NBN as promised.
  • Array IT: Govt's cost-cutting bitch
    The government needs to stop looking at IT as a necessary evil or the place to remove costs when the Treasurer comes calling.
  • More blogs »

Tags

Back to top

Featured