Listen to the Music: 12 MP3 Players Tested

By
30 May 2003 07:20 PM
Tags: 15gb, 2, cd, zen, muvo, player, ipod, aac

Philips AZ5150 Deck

Philips AZ5150 Philips offers the largest MP3 deck we've ever seen that can still be described as 'portable'

When we decided to compile a feature on portable music players, we were excited to see the large number of tiny yet feature-packed MP3 players coming through the mailbox here at ZDNet. Surprisingly, we also received a much larger box containing the Philips AZ5150 deck.

Unless you suffer from extreme gigantism, the AZ5150 isn't going to fit in your pocket. Still, it can run on batteries and has a plastic handle at the top so by definition it is a portable music player, albeit only just. We haven't tested a boom box for some time, and it certainly gave us a nostalgic feeling having a cassette player in the office.

The AZ5150 has a sleek silver finish a grey covered top. This along with a top-loading, 20-track programmable CD player drags the player out of the 80s, as does its ability to playback VCD/MP3-CDs. In regards to MP3-CDs, the AZ5150 has some unusual limitations. The maximum number of tracks it'll read off a CD is 256, so if you have plenty of smaller files this isn't the player for you. Supported bit-rates are 96, 128, 192 and 256 kbps. Windows Media Audio (wma) and Advanced Audio Coding (aac) files are not supported.

MP3 Players
Introduction
1. Apple iPod 15GB
2. Creative CD MP3 Slim 600
3. Creative MP3 Player 2
4. Creative Nomad Jukebox 3
5. Creative Nomad Muvo
6. Creative Nomad Zen 20GB
7. Panasonic SD-SV50
8. Philips AZ5150
9. Philips eXpanium 213
10. Philips eXpanium 431
11. Sony NetMD MZ-N10
12. Sony NetMD MZ-N510
Editor's choice
There are a couple of quirks during MP3-CD playback. To select another track during playback mode you have to press the next or previous button to set the track number, then hit the play button to swap to the new track. Holding down the search buttons have no effect so you are unable to find a specific passage in a song. Despite being the largest player, the 7-segment LCD display is entirely unable to display track names, relying instead on track numbers to keep order.

There is a shuffle feature that works on both audio CDs and MP3-CDs. Similarly the repeat buttons work on both formats with the option of repeating the current track or the whole disc. There is a 2-digit LCD that displays the current repeat/shuffle modes as well as track information and the type of disc in the reader.

The sound quality from the stereo speakers was only of average quality. Switching on the dynamic bass boost enhances the quality by beefing up bass tones. Beside the DBB button is the rotary volume control. While the sound is clear enough to listen to (even at loud volume) the speakers do not compare to the clarity and range of more expensive mini/micro systems.

Directly out of the box the AZ5150 only runs on AC mains power via the supplied detachable power cord. There are no batteries included and it will take six D cells to power this baby up on its own. Add an additional two AAs if you want to use the remote control, and be ready to shell out extra for batteries over the life of the unit.

In terms of unique extras, the AZ5150 has one feature that no other player in this roundup could come near; an integrated single cassette deck. We normally wouldn't even mention this, but it does offer synchronised CD recording (to tape), so you could transport your MP3 files into another format this way. For what it's worth, there's also an analogue AM/FM tuner with a rotary dial and a telescopic FM antenna at the back of the system. There are no auxiliary inputs but there is a stereo AV output for playback of VCDs. Video output can be swapped from PAL to NTSC via a switch on the back of the unit. Next to this is a headphone jack.

It's a bit hard to classify the AZ51510 next to all of the small and light systems we've reviewed as part of this feature. It does have the distinction of being the equal cheapest and by far the largest, which gives it an interesting set of tradeoffs. Ultimately, it's only really recommended if you need an MP3 player you're unlikely to move around much with.

Philips AZ5150
Company: Philips
Price: AU$249
Distributor: Selected resellers
Phone: 1800 009 300

Advertisement

Talkback 2 comments

    Hi! I recently put a Sony MZ-N ...Anonymous -- 01/10/04

    Hi! I recently put a Sony MZ-N510 on layby of $350. It's my first update sine a discman. Should I keep it or find another one? Any comments are more than welcome! Thanks!

    Don't know much about mp3 play ...Anonymous -- 20/01/05

    Don't know much about mp3 players but I am looking for something with an AM tuner - most models come with a FM tuner but I can't find anything with an AM tuner. Does such a thing exist?

Add your opinion

Reviews by category

Sponsored content

Power Centre - Content from our premier sponsors

Blogs

  • Suzanne Tindal Sick of broken tender sites
    Some of the state governments desperately need to invest in more user-friendly tender sites so that looking for information on government tenders doesn't have to be a game of blind man's bluff.
  • Array Cyberwar: What is it good for?
    In this week's episode, Cyberwar. What is Australia's place in the world of digital warfare? What are the implications for the NBN?
  • Array Is wholesale-only backhaul just a pipedream?
    The potential acquisition of Pipe Networks by SP Telemedia has raised the question about whether vertically integrated backhaul providers will mean higher wholesale prices for ISP customers.
  • More blogs »

Tags

Back to top

Featured