Listen to the Music: 12 MP3 Players Tested

By
30 May 2003 07:20 PM
Tags: 15gb, 2, cd, zen, muvo, player, ipod, aac
Listen to the Music: 12 MP3 Players Tested You want music on the go? We've rounded up 12 MP3 players and put them head-to-head in our Australian review of the latest and greatest portable music devices.

MP3 as a format is certainly no spring chicken, but it's an area that more and more consumers are moving towards, whether that be for the portability advantages of the format or simply because they're amassing large quantities of MP3 material via less than legal methods. Once you've got your music, though, you're essentially tethered to your PC, unless you invest in a portable MP3 player of some sort. There are plenty of PDAs that will handle MP3 music, and of course every notebook on the market can handle something as simple as an MP3 file. Lugging around either a PDA or notebook simply to listen to some tunes is somewhat overkill, not to mention a potential weight problem. Notebooks and PDAs are often not particularly well equipped when it comes to audio playback, either. It's generally an afterthought that designers latch on at the last minute, meaning your audio experience may be fundamentally affected by a notebook or PDA with cruddy speakers.

MP3 Players
Introduction
1. Apple iPod 15GB
2. Creative CD MP3 Slim 600
3. Creative MP3 Player 2
4. Creative Nomad Jukebox 3
5. Creative Nomad Muvo
6. Creative Nomad Zen 20GB
7. Panasonic SD-SV50
8. Philips AZ5150
9. Philips eXpanium 213
10. Philips eXpanium 431
11. Sony NetMD MZ-N10
12. Sony NetMD MZ-N510
Editor's choice
One preferable option for portable MP3 music is to invest in a portable player, and here you're spoilt for choice. We've rounded up 12 likely candidates, ranging from the smallest capacity solid-state players that easily fall out of pockets, through CD-R/RW compatible players and all the way up to hard-drive enabled behemoths with multi-gigagbyte storage capacities.

One thing that can mark a mature format is a certain amount of stagnation in design, and that's certainly something that's true in the portable MP3 space. The vast majority of players we've reviewed here aren't spring chickens by any stretch of the imagination, and arguably only Apple is continuing to innovate in the MP3 space, beyond the simple 'must add more storage' kick that most vendors are on. The maturity of devices does have two advantages to the wary consumer however. Being mature, most of the bugs and kinks should have already been ironed out, and arguably more importantly, with the fierce competition in the portable MP3 space, older devices should experience sharp price drops, leading (at least potentially) to some bargain offerings.


Apple iPod 15GBEditor's choiceApple iPod 15GB

Apple's iPod leads the way in innovative player design and quality features.


Creative CD MP3 Slim 600Creative CD MP3 Slim 600

There's one word to describe the Slim 600. That word is "Shiny".


Creative Digital Mp3 Player 2Creative Digital Mp3 Player 2

The Digital Mp3 player 2 is very, very small. Be sure you don't accidentally lose it.


Creative Nomad Jukebox 3Creative Nomad Jukebox 3

Creative's grand old man of the hard-drive based Mp3 player market continues to impress.


Creative Nomad MuvoCreative Nomad Muvo

The Nomad Muvo has handy storage features not normally seen in its price range.


Creative Nomad Zen 20GB USB 2.0Creative Nomad Zen 20GB USB 2.0

Creative's answer to the iPod is the Zen. How does it stack up?


Panasonic e.wear SD-SV50Panasonic e.wear SD-SV50

Panasonic brings the smallest MP3 player to the table, redefining "titchy" along the way.


Philips AZ5150 DeckPhilips AZ5150 Deck

Philips, conversely, offers the largest MP3 deck we've ever seen that can still be described as 'portable'.


Philips Expanium EXP 213Philips Expanium EXP 213

The EXP 213 is a bare-bones CD-R/RW playback device.


Philips Expanium EXP 431Philips Expanium EXP 431

It's small in size, and only works with 8cm CD-R/RW media, but the Exp 431 has a large feature set on offer.


Sony NetMD Walkman MZ-N10Sony NetMD Walkman MZ-N10

Sony's flagship Minidisc-based player brings a hefty feature set and hefty price tag with it.


Sony NetMD Walkman MZ-N510Sony NetMD Walkman MZ-N510

The MZ-N510 is an entry level Minidisc player that should suit those with a recording bent who just happen to need MP3 playback as well.

ZDNet Australia's Alex Kidman, Brendon Chase, James Pearce and Jeremy Roche contributed to this feature.

Advertisement

Talkback 2 comments

    Hi! I recently put a Sony MZ-N ...Anonymous -- 01/10/04

    Hi! I recently put a Sony MZ-N510 on layby of $350. It's my first update sine a discman. Should I keep it or find another one? Any comments are more than welcome! Thanks!

    Don't know much about mp3 play ...Anonymous -- 20/01/05

    Don't know much about mp3 players but I am looking for something with an AM tuner - most models come with a FM tuner but I can't find anything with an AM tuner. Does such a thing exist?

Add your opinion

Reviews by category

Sponsored content

Power Centre - Content from our premier sponsors

Blogs

Tags

Back to top

Featured