Reaction round-up: Conroy's digital economy opus

Digital Economy Minister Stephen Conroy will be releasing the government's roadmap for Australia's participation in the digital economy today, but what does the industry expect from it?

Stephen Conroy
(Stephen Conroy, image by Kim Davies, CC2.0)

The goal of the paper was to outline the key areas of focus for Government, industry and the community, according to the Minister.

"Australia needs a digitally aware and enabling government, a digitally confident, innovative and skilled industry and a digitally literate and empowered community. The paper explores the actions we need to advance to enhance these key factors for success," Conroy has previously said of the effort. "It is time now for government, industry and the community to work together to foster and harness the benefits on offer in the digital economy."

The big gun
Microsoft Australia chief technology Greg Stone said that although he welcomed the paper, he didn't believe it was about laying out strategies for the future, but more about creating a picture of what current conditions were and what was being done so the industry could reflect.

"This is part of the government laying the building blocks for enablement," he said. "If these things are referred to in that paper, then that paper becomes a useful point for the reflections of society." He didn't believe the paper was supposed to be prescriptive, but more a milestone to mark the government's progress — an opportunity for the industry to pause and think about the future.

"In many ways what people are looking to in this whole thing is not the paper," he said. "We see the paper as a signal. We see it as part of the process ... I'm certainly not looking to it for where we should be placing our bets."

The government had recently removed an enormous stumbling block in promising to create widespread broadband connectivity, Stone said. The executive believed it was now up to the industry to use its own levers to make the best of that.

The start-ups
Martin Hosking, chairman of Aussie start-ups RedBubble and Aconex and Looksmart co-founder, said that he hoped the final version went past the grab bag of issues which was the draft paper. "The draft paper has 500 different things. That's all well and good, but you have to focus on a number of small things so you can win," he said.

Australia has poor performance in the digital economy sphere, according to Hosking. "There's not a single Australian company in the top 500 internet companies in the world," he said, noting Australia needed to focus on why that has happened.

Three main issues Hosking picked out were a lack of recognition of Australia's distance from the global markets, the very low numbers of engineers and computer science graduates coming from universities and the difficulty of getting capital for internet ventures. "If you need $25 to start the next Google in Australia, you can't," he said.

If you need $25 to start the next Google in Australia, you can't

Start-up veteran Martin Hosking

Austrade was often helpful on the first issue, he believed, but he thought there could be more done to ameliorate the concern. On the graduates, Hosking suggested making certain degrees free for bright students. The capital issue was a hard one to resolve, he said, needing a long-term commitment from the government.

Bart Jellema, the director of all things cool and wonderful at coupon discovery start-up Tjoos and active organiser of community start-up initiatives such as Startup Camp and BootUpCamp said that first he thought the government needed to do something about the price of international bandwidth to make its National Broadband Network investment worthwhile.

He also said it took too much effort to wade through the red tape to get government grants: "When you're doing a start-up, there's so many other things you have to learn. There's so many programs out there. Sometimes it's more trouble than it's worth."

Jellema thought that there should be a general tax cut for all starting businesses to make it simple and help companies right from the start, when it could be just two people in a garage.

Mick Liubinskas, web strategist, co-founder of start-up consultant Pollenizer and start-up veteran also called for more funding to be invested in digital technologies. He said that funding prototypes had been made necessary because of the sinking economy, which had meant that money from the usual sources — family, friends and fools — had dried up.

The internet provider
iiNet regulatory officer Steve Dalby said he hoped to see government support for the development of new applications to drive take up of the National Broadband Network. "100Mbps might be cool to brag about, but an export industry based in Australia that exploits that bandwidth, with productivity and lifestyle-enhancing applications, is much more exciting," he said.

Investment in Australian software and hardware development that could be traded to the rest of the world was needed. It would be great if there was an iPhone apps store-like model for the National Broadband Network, Dalby said.

The support could come in increased funding for the private sector, as well as universities, TAFEs, CSIRO — anyone who wanted to get creative. "The NBN should put Australia at the cutting edge in this world. Generalities about 'e-Health' and 'smart grids' just doesn't cut it anymore, it needs to be driven by incentives aimed at developing real applications," he said.

The opposition
Conroy's opposite Nick Minchin was not impressed by the report, because he saw it as a summary of where Australia was at, as opposed to providing any clarity on how the government intended to deal with the issues the industry faced.

He singled out convergence as one issue he believed required more clarity — those areas where boundaries were blurred between broadcasters, content providers and telcos.

He agreed with the paper's points on the dangers of badly constructed regulation, but pointed out the hypocrisy of saying that the digital economy was market-led while supporting an enormous government owned investment in it — the National Broadband Network.

"The reality is there is currently a great deal of uncertainty in the sector and most of that has been caused by the government's mishandling of broadband policy since coming to office," Minchin said.

Talkback

Add your opinion

In order to post a comment, you need to be registered. (Sign In or register below)

Post your comment

Terms of Service - As a ZDNet registrant, and by using this service, you indicate that you agree to our Terms and Conditions and have read and understand our Privacy Policy.

ZDNet Australia Live

RT @Techmeme: RIP webOS: Again and for good this time (@jkendrick / ZDNet) http://t.co/RhADp6WL http://t.co/fFYGIy5R

Cybercrime golden age over in two years? http://t.co/LyqqjWYU #Cybercrime #Gescrise #Riskmanagement (via @ECCOUNCIL)

RT: ECCOUNCIL: Cybercrime golden age over in two years? http://t.co/X0In9ijs #infosec #hack #cybersecurity

Cybercrime golden age over in two years? http://t.co/VJnt6nEo #infosec #hack #cybersecurity

NBN users opt for 100Mbps - http://t.co/C2Vs7d3t

Yes, if only he had access to FTTP instead of wishing for wireless or space optics, perhaps the comedy site would still be up and running...

33 minutes ago by Beta on NBN users opt for 100Mbps

I could not resist :-)

I remember that website well, you must too, it was full of so many comedy pieces.

39 minutes ago by Hubert Cumberdale on NBN users opt for 100Mbps

Bazaarvoice acquires rival PowerReviews; adds SMBs to CRM portfolio: By Andrew Nusca | May 25, 2012, 4:42am PDT ... http://t.co/WngvcsxL

MikeSkoey, what a naive collection of words. How do you know what context Paul has been working in. How do you know he implemented whats ...

59 minutes ago by AnonymousCIO on 30 servers to 7: BUPA redoes virtualisation

Post 'social' improved speed to information and context http://t.co/7u9odG7N

HC, don't be so mean to Todd...

He is actually one who may not be just politically opposed ;-)

1 hour ago by Beta on NBN users opt for 100Mbps

No, Quigley is, as CEO's of all companies are, quite simply motivated for his company to be a professional and successful company, as it ...

1 hour ago by Beta on NBN users opt for 100Mbps

Forced lol. btw I tried to load your website www.nonbn.org but all I got was a "website unavailable" I really wanted to donate some mone...

1 hour ago by Hubert Cumberdale on NBN users opt for 100Mbps

http://t.co/aDIOqQ4c http://t.co/NeUOcLt5

What has the debt level got to do with what plan people chose? I'd point out that the debt wont be $50 billion but i'd be wasting my bre...

1 hour ago by mstat_z on NBN users opt for 100Mbps

Quigley is entirely politically motivated, this is headline grabbing and nothing more. The statistic should read - "of those who took up ...

2 hours ago by merarischroeder on NBN users opt for 100Mbps

RT @zdnetaustralia: NSW outs datacentre deal details: http://t.co/A1Cj4Eot ^LH

"the artificial speed tiers will mean that on average speeds the country will be left well behind others and social inequality will incre...

2 hours ago by Hubert Cumberdale on NBN users opt for 100Mbps

The most insulting aspect of the ads is CommBank's expectation that we would accept a bank account with fees unless you deposit $2000/mth...

2 hours ago by gikku on Triple J's Spotify conundrum

NBN users opt for 100Mbps - Communications - News http://t.co/3A84AASP

That's right. Quigley DOES know best. So when Quigley presents a plan to the shareholders (us) and says "this is our worst case scenario...

2 hours ago by Hubert Cumberdale on NBN users opt for 100Mbps

"NBNCo predict 13% of premises passed by fibre will opt for wireless because it is cheaper." Which leaves 87% well above the 70% estimate...

2 hours ago by Beta on NBN users opt for 100Mbps

HC the critics said the NBN wouldn't make a cent (yes, yes here comes the, it's still in debt arguments - we know what you meant and so d...

2 hours ago by Beta on NBN users opt for 100Mbps

Look what you did Gwyn...LOL. Yes, but as you have been told umpteen times Mathew (whenever you sprout the same old repetitive lines abo...

2 hours ago by Beta on NBN users opt for 100Mbps

It's great that in one area NBNCo are beating the prediction on speed tiers in the Corporate Plan (page 118). Unfortunately it is the onl...

2 hours ago by mathew42 on NBN users opt for 100Mbps

10 cool iPad apps you'll wish you found sooner | 2 of 10 http://t.co/M9SXbnJS via @zite

Do you have a reference for the 40% in Willunga? The only public figures I've seen are 29% for Willunga and 26% for Kiama. It would cert...

3 hours ago by mathew42 on NBN users opt for 100Mbps

Considering that Quigley wrote the corporate plan based on a number of studies one would expect him and the plan to know best.

3 hours ago by mathew42 on NBN users opt for 100Mbps

yep don't worry, I'm sure the anti-NBN zealots will find some other ridiculous line to fill the void. I imagine it'll be "oh but these ar...

3 hours ago by Hubert Cumberdale on NBN users opt for 100Mbps

SA Health's journey to ehealth Business News ZDNet Australia: Implementing e-health services for an entire state... http://t.co/QuiOy7OQ

London to become Intel's city-living R&D testbed - ZDNet UK (blog): IT PROLondon to become Intel's city-living R... http://t.co/5qdivDa1

You would think so, but after this post went live Turnbull's office finally got back to me and said that, if they win office next year, t...

3 hours ago by braue on NBN cost-benefit analyses are so 2011

Carriage dialect poke is a vastly predominant brand in a completely logical price. Honourableness quality of products of the modern coach...

3 hours ago by Teleuplique on Appeal to save wiki-linked Twitter accounts

#Google #Australia Much ado about Google's tax http://t.co/DCMsJGyN

RT @zdnetaustralia: NSW outs datacentre deal details: http://t.co/A1Cj4Eot ^LH

by http://t.co/vmlLt4bh: Build your own smartphone stand: Looking for a smartphone stand, but not interested in d... http://t.co/DptVvkoB

Build your own smartphone stand: Looking for a smartphone stand, but not interested in dishing out the dough? We... http://t.co/TgSeZIdM

last couple of hours to submit your application for #crmidol. Step up and take your chance! http://t.co/7vQxdbY3 #scrm #crm #value

The rural Silicon Valley http://t.co/vqV6bl5i

RT @JamesVickery: NBN users opt for 100Mbps http://t.co/atP8fi1L

Build your own smartphone stand http://t.co/IY6VxA7n

RT @zdnetaustralia: NSW outs datacentre deal details: http://t.co/A1Cj4Eot ^LH

The rural Silicon Valley http://t.co/jhEFQwSX

JobWatch: where the ICT jobs are http://t.co/e6gQvhxz via @zdnetaustralia #ICT #recruitment

The rural Silicon Valley: What happened in Senate Estimates this week? What's the issue with tech company taxes?... http://t.co/Umoa7CHX

Sweet: "Customers are picking the top fibre plan that is available on the #NBN more than any other plan" http://t.co/yUFHdYFc

RT @CorrieB: An iPad for every child: Inevitable or impossible? http://t.co/I7uS8l9s Thx to @timbuckteeth for this; http://t.co/jxkqIRIp

Interesting tech analysis podcast re: phone cloning and Craig Thomson from zdnet http://t.co/p8jlCvvG

@zdnetaustralia Thoughtful piece to end the week on. Thanks @joshgnosis

Triple J's Spotify conundrum http://t.co/iy1e2DRp via @zdnetaustralia

RT @zdnetaustralia: NSW outs datacentre deal details: http://t.co/A1Cj4Eot ^LH

Triple J not bound to advertising rules like its broadcast. No diff to ABC online or magazines though... http://t.co/JPUr7Fv4

Triple J's Spotify conundrum: Has Triple J managed to find the balance between meeting editorial policy and keep... http://t.co/8UYsHZ6D

Listening to Triple J on Spotify has ads for Commonwealth Bank. But that's okay apparently. http://t.co/O7zmcpvT

How does Triple J find the balance with meeting editorial policy and keeping up with the latest technology? http://t.co/qdWgybfm ^jt

This story has been voted 12000 times in the last 24 hours!

1 day ago, Is Bill Gates a great leader?

This story has been voted 10 times in the last 24 hours!

3 days ago, CeBIT 2012 opens: photos

This story has been voted 15 times in the last 24 hours!

3 days ago, Lenovo ThinkPad 3G tablet (32GB)

Facebook Activity

Keep up with ZDNet Australia

ZDNet Events Calendar

ZDNet Events Calendar