Qantas ditches Lotus Notes for Outlook

Related gallery

Windows Mobile 6

Windows Mobile 6

Qantas today confirmed that it would shortly migrate its corporate email platform from IBM's Lotus Notes/Domino platform to Microsoft Exchange/Outlook.

Qantas

(Qantas 747-300 image
by planegeezer, CC2.0)

Confirming a report this morning in the AustralianIT, Qantas executive manager of corporate services and technology David Hall said the process of migrating to Exchange had already begun, with piloting underway across the airline's executive team.

"This is part of the Qantas technology group's focus on leveraging technology to improve efficiencies for the business and enhancing communication effectiveness across our workforce," said Hall.

"Subject to satisfactory piloting, we anticipate the migration to be substantially completed by the end of the year." It is expected that around 20,000 staff will be migrated to the Microsoft platform.

Hall said Qantas would also be consolidating "a large number" of Lotus Notes applications and databases as part of its drive to "standardise, reduce and simplify" the number of business applications and tools it used.

Since moving up to his current role in October 2008 from his previous position as chief financial officer at Qantas subsidiary Jetstar, Hall has made dramatic changes to Qantas' IT support operation.

In a landmark speech in August 2009, Hall said he believed Qantas could cut its IT costs by $100 million over the next financial year. Over the past couple of years the airline has pursued a number of IT outsourcing initiatives. For example, in mid-2009 some 200 Qantas staff were offered jobs at IBM as Big Blue took over responsibility for the airline's project delivery services.

Talkback

BS

..."leveraging technology to improve efficiencies for the business and enhancing communication effectiveness" - sounds like the Dack BS generator has been getting a workout!

AnonymousAnonymous February 3rd, 2010
Report offensive content Reply (0) (0)

notes is dead - according to the media

why is there is such a glut of pro MS stories? is it really because everyone is moving? or simply MS have a huge hospitality & marketing pot, of which journos get regular access? Some balance would be nice for a change. Still, easy to write what your told to I guess.

AnonymousAnonymous February 4th, 2010
Report offensive content Reply (0) (0)

Migrating Mail Infrastructure is never easy or cheap!

S/W is like religion, bit too much faith and not enough science in striving for utopia. If Qantas want to move to Exchange. I doubt they will cut costs. Here's 3 reasons why.

1/ For each Domino Server you want to migrate, you will require 3 (three) Windows Servers each running their own part of the Exchange architecture. And this doesn't include any extra bits for Application related servers either. so 3 is not less than 1 last time I checked my maths.

2/ You have a lot of applications built in Domino environments that will cost millions to sunset and convert (by hand) into an alternative technology. There is no magic conversion program, anyone who tells you that, also will sell you the harbour bridge. In the end all the business gets will be the same business function and a smaller bank balance. So, paying more for the same doesn't sound like a good investment does it ?

3/ Alternatively, If Qantas decide to not migrate app's then they will be left with a massive array of servers as you run a hybrid environment for at least 3-5 years of Notes application (utility) servers and the Exchange environment. Again the h/w cost + Admin cost (ie TCO) will hurt someone. So, having more technology only complicates the environment and will cost more to keep it working.

On another note, when CxO's decide to switch technologies. What's the motivation ? Reliability ? Cost ? longevity of the platform ? In Qantas' case it appears to be cost.

Reliability and Cost tends to revolve around people. You are swapping practices and skill levels when you swap out technologies. In the process you throw the baby out with the bath water. Before ebaying your servers, perhaps looking at the skills and habits of the team running it.

If it's about longetivity of the platform, Domino's been around for 20 years, and it looks like it will be around for 10 more, and all Domino upgrades are done "in place", not something Microsoft can testify to.

This sort of project is not easy, but the solutions if assessed in detail may point to very cheap solutions that save you money.

In conclusion, If Qantas decide to do the migration, (which I have seen time and time again), they'll most likely be a hybrid site forking out cash supporting duplicated servers for around least 3-5 years.

Giulio CampobassiGiulio Campobassi February 5th, 2010
Report offensive content Reply (0) (0)

Why go MS ? Google would do it better ?

Why fork out the cash for M$ gear. Google can federate your email for a fraction of the cost.

AnonymousAnonymous February 5th, 2010
Report offensive content Reply (0) (-1)

Google maybe cheaper if....

...they didn't already have the Domino infrastructure in place. If this is just about the mail client, use Outlook against the Domino servers - done and over. Little to no expense, just time. But the people out there saying that you can easily move a mature Notes/Domino environment to Exchange/Outlook/Sharepoint/IIS/.NET/etc. - are lying.

AnonymousAnonymous February 9th, 2010
Report offensive content Reply (0) (-1)

Re: Migrating Mail Infrastructure is never easy or cheap!

Let me guess, your are an IBM employee. Never let facts get the in the way of an emotional response.

Maybe the reason they are moving to an Exchange platform is that they are sick of clients designed last century or maybe they are sick of inefficient databases that consume ridiculous amounts of HDD space.

Domino Should DieDomino Should Die February 9th, 2010
Report offensive content Reply (+1) (0)

talk about facts

At least get YOURS straight before posting typical MS FUD like that.

AnonymousAnonymous February 10th, 2010
Report offensive content Reply (0) (-1)

No

Giulio Campobassi gave very reasoned arguments, and any company facing a similar situation should have done the same level of due diligence to determine costings and benefits of such a move.
No I'm not a Lotus notes fan before you make uninformed accusations and I've administered Exchange and GroupWise mail systems and dealt with lotus notes.

DeonastDeonast February 10th, 2010
Report offensive content Reply (0) (-1)

Purely an emotional decision

The new CIO and CEO both wanted Outlook. It's as simple as that. David Hall came from Jetstar where they had Outlook and he just couldn't get his head around a real collaboration product like Lotus Notes & Domino. I mean, he's an accountant not an IT person. Basically, him and his exec team wanted an Outlook client and they are prepared to spend millions and millions of shareholders $ to get it. They will also attempt to "migrate" Notes apps to Sharepoint. What this really means is that they will spend millions more to completely rebuild all their apps from scratch. And the new desktop outsourcer (replacing Telstra) makes lots and lots of $ for doing the migration work.

AnonymousAnonymous February 9th, 2010
Report offensive content Reply (0) (-1)

Moving to LotusLive would make more sense

Why have not they moved to www.lotuslive.com instead? That would be more cheaper and faster. Panasonic has moved recently to lotuslive and they are quite happy with actual savings

AnonymousAnonymous February 10th, 2010
Report offensive content Reply (0) (-1)

"Subject to satisfactory piloting"

I wonder if they will come to their senses after their pilot is "unsatisfactory". Then what will the press release be? "Quantas bails on Outlook conversion, realizes the error of their ways, decides to upgrade to Notes R8". Of course not! Even if there is a complete failure in the pilot they will probably still go through with it... just so they don't look bad.

Brett HershbergerBrett Hershberger February 11th, 2010
Report offensive content Reply (0) (-1)

Let's follow up in a year...

I'd like to see the media follow up in a year and see how successful this project is. Oh wait, a failed IT project won't make the news will it? Especially Domino apps->Sharepoint... good luck to you!

AnonymousAnonymous March 13th, 2010
Report offensive content Reply (0) (-1)

Would definitely love a follow-up on this story in 12 to 18 months.

Blue TongueBlue Tongue March 26th, 2010
Report offensive content Reply (+1) (0)

I have put it in my diary.

Suzanne Tindal
News Editor, ZDNet.com.au

stindalstindal March 28th, 2010
Report offensive content Reply (+1) (0)

I wonder whether the Qantas CIO took into account the fact that everytime they want to upgrade Exchange to a new version, they'll have to rip out the old version and replace it. There's cost around that.

I sell reporting and policy enforcement solutions to Domino and Exchange customers and 90% of the time I see that those who migrated to Exchange still have all their Domino applications, so the license cost is not really eliminated.

Lastly, I'd like to comment that...in terms of emotional responses....I'd say the one from "Domino Should Die" is the MOST emotional and like it might come from a Microsoft employee.

Rafael Gomez
Not an IBM Employee, but a satisfied Lotus Notes user.

rafael00rafael00 April 6th, 2010
Report offensive content Reply (0) (-1)
Add your opinion

In order to post a comment, you need to be registered. (Sign In or register below)

Post your comment

ZDNet Australia Live

A user from Adelaide measured 19050kbps @ Broadband Speedtest.

4 minutes ago, Click here to find out how fast your internet speed is.

Vic Govt releases report by independent consultancy saying the state's smart meter roll-out will save up to $5bn http://bit.ly/beNoXF

Samsung's Android tablet will arrive in Australia in time for Christmas http://bit.ly/dzyjxV

Daehn's Brain: Google Chrome turns 2: Can we skip the toddler years? - ZDNet (blog) http://ow.ly/18Qu8X

Firefox (google): Google Chrome turns 2: Can we skip the toddler years? - ZDNet (blog) http://ht.ly/18QtIz

`Mockingjay' receives midnight launch at NYC store: At guides of Wonder, fans stood for severa... http://bit.ly/aarsGx etailersXclusive.com

A fantastic SEO for Firefox Plugin to extend your SEO/PPC efforts beyond the first step http://bit.ly/9qu5OJ

http://www.zdnet.com/blog/networking/does-cisco-buying-skype-make-sense/115


cisco buying skype

Samsung's Android tablet will arrive in Australia in time for Christmas http://bit.ly/dzyjxV

Google Chrome turns 2: Can we skip the toddler years? http://bit.ly/95m6df

@Delaypat that's what I thought.. well you may have to do a bios update so.. http://bit.ly/bW4I8C . Some of them have been over heating

How green is your mobile phone? » ZDNet: http://zd.net/biKDBK

Samsung's iPad rival set for Christmas http://zdnet.com.au/339305780/

Waukee Fest offers taste of Americana http://bit.ly/d3ai1a

RT @darrenpauli: Police mole busted by IT audithttp://bit.ly/cZYIA8

RT @dbmoore: RT @mkrigsman: On ZDNet: Understanding Marin County's $30 million ERP failure http://zd.net/dcikhw #CIO #itfail #EnSW

Want a decent tablet that isn't an iPad? You're in luck. Samsung has your Christmas present. http://bit.ly/dzyjxV

Police mole busted by IT audithttp://bit.ly/cZYIA8

The Government (if it stays in) is headed for a big fall and will take down Australia down with it. The Australian public and most of the...

32 minutes ago by flezzkk on Conroy ignored industry on NBN: Slattery

Cisco Data Center Ethernet: Cisco has worked very closely with VMware to create new technologies that enable virtu... http://bit.ly/bS5B3g

#Barbers and ##security_professionals: [zdnet.com] The wonderfully self-contradictory report from the Commission on... http://dlvr.it/4dk8J

分享 http://tinyurl.com/2fjtmcj ZDNet Taiwan%3A %B7s%BBD (蘋果Ping、Apple TV 台灣沒得玩?) http://plurk.com/p/7c5ji7

Google Chrome turns 2: Can we skip the toddler years? http://bit.ly/djt7Zo #html5

News: NBN key to open government: Lundy - ZDNet Australia: Sydney Morning HeraldNBN key to open government: LundyZ... http://bit.ly/b4vmnc

Google Chrome turns 2: Can we skip the toddler years? - ZDNet (blog) http://goo.gl/fb/JrKyP #google

RT @deehoseo: Google Chrome turns 2: Can we skip the toddler years? http://bit.ly/a1sg7t

Google Chrome turns 2: Can we skip the toddler years? - ZDNet (blog) http://bit.ly/9TqOKx

And again, NBN = National Broadband Network. The aim is for everyone nationally, to benefit. And yes people pay via their taxes and will...

46 minutes ago by RS on Telco alliance acting on self-interest: IDC

Commonwealth Bank chooses Brisbane based GBST for new institutional equities trading solution http://ow.ly/2yTCx. http://ow.ly/2yTFh.

peaking of which, I have asked you 2 questions many times, which have gone unanswered just as many times, so seriously... what is good fo...

53 minutes ago by RS on Telco alliance acting on self-interest: IDC

peaking of which, I have asked you 2 questions many times, which have gone unanswered just as many times, so seriously... what is good fo...

53 minutes ago by RS on Telco alliance acting on self-interest: IDC

Slattery - your parent company was consulted I think...TPG? And calling the govt communists does not help your cause. Oh and how does c...

53 minutes ago by Uh_ah on Conroy ignored industry on NBN: Slattery

Time = Money. To put it bluntly Linton. Optical Fiber to the premises = reduced transit times for sending and receiving data, multi pur...

54 minutes ago by Jahm Mitt on 1Gbps NBN fans 'just plain stupid': Linton

RT @joshgnosis Should Microsoft apologise to "MEN" for the meter maids at #auteched last week ? http://bit.ly/cDI50d [ HUH ? WTF ?! ]

I like sex. I like masturbating. I like porn. I like Meter Maids and most women. I don't think much of the christian "anti-se...

1 hour ago by Jahm Mitt on Microsoft sorry for Meter Maid bikinis

Costs, security burden private cloud ideal | ZDNet.Au Priorities http://bit.ly/9v09BI via@Tessa_Alfred

NBN key to open government: Lundy http://zdnet.com.au/339305772/ #gov2 #gov2au

Senator Stephen Conroy must be on of (if not the) most incompetent people in politics!! http://goo.gl/tzA6 #conboy

RT @joshgnosis: NBN key to open govt: Lundy http://bit.ly/cO0n13 #openinternet #gov2

I have asked this question of you before, so what is your prediction of the population/SMB shifts to the already NBN enabled areas of Smi...

2 hours ago by advocate on Telco alliance acting on self-interest: IDC

NBN key to open govt: Lundy http://bit.ly/cO0n13

Why am I surprised Conroy didn't consult with anyone credible whilst dreaming up this scheme. NBN shouldn't be about fibre or ...

2 hours ago by Scott W on Conroy ignored industry on NBN: Slattery

The bank and retailers have no interest in your security, as long as it's quicker and cheaper for them to make money. Contactless ...

2 hours ago by Scott W on NAB rolls out contactless terminals

Charge them all!

2 hours ago by Scott W on NAB rolls out contactless terminals

Well it's a reasonably simple premise, FTTH will be a direct benefit to your business which you don't have to pay for, you accuse...

2 hours ago by advocate on Telco alliance acting on self-interest: IDC

Walk in the door, get charged. Walk out the door, get charged. Hey, doesn't that sound like a new banking charge? Walk into the b...

2 hours ago by Scott W on NAB rolls out contactless terminals

Maihi had referred to the manipulation of ATM software to steal customer bank details as phishing; even though this is not the usual use ...

2 hours ago by darrenpauli on Banks struggle against ATM bombings

Just imagine walking past a disguised 'rogue' scanner and being billed for multiple sub $100 values. No imagine some dodgey busin...

2 hours ago by Scott W on NAB rolls out contactless terminals

Do you agree that Microsoft should apologise to men for the meter maid debacle? http://bit.ly/cDI50d

Conroy ignored industry on #NBN: Slattery: http://bit.ly/b6ankQ [Who's surprised?]

Doctor, CEO demands crippling health IT - Business - News http://ff.im/-q984M

Victoria attracts 400 more IT jobs http://zdnet.com.au/339305513/

This story has been liked 5 times in the last 24 hours!

RT: @zdnetaustralia: Easy access to data is more impt than location, w/ cost & security preventing companies creating.. http://bit.ly/c9IKY6

Easy access to data is more impt than location, with cost and security preventing companies creating a private cloud http://bit.ly/c9IKY6

RT @SydneyHomeless: Conroy ignored industry on #NBN: Slattery - http://bit.ly/cXDfnT

Slattery accuses Conroy of ignoring the telco industry when it came to building the NBN http://bit.ly/cHKKqJ

Banks struggle against ATM bombings http://bit.ly/bQPCgG

Chrome usage creeps up on Microsoft http://bit.ly/9OlhG5

New iPods in Australia next week http://bit.ly/d9UQCB

Elements of this copyroght discussion are a cause for concern - what if it is a shared internet connection? http://icio.us/tzynoy

Yesterday, it distressed me greatly that an Australian MP was forced to resign. NSW MP internet misuse 'flawed' - News http://bit.ly/b69tN2

Thanks, @Audrey_William. #RNOW's latest high profile client in Australia RT #Vividwireless takes on #RightNow CRM http://tiny.cc/crru1

The internet is full, what now? http://bit.ly/cNEbaT

This story has been liked 5 times in the last 24 hours!

This story has been liked 5 times in the last 24 hours!

1) Apple iPhone 4 16GB44 plans 4%
2) Apple iPhone 4 32GB44 plans 15%
3) HTC Desire4 plans 4%
4) Apple iPhone 3GS 8GB33 plans 9%
5) Sony Ericsson Xperia X10 Mini Pro37 plans 4%

Mobile Phones | Broadband Plans

CBS - ZDNET Australia Partner Services