Plan B for the NBN

Twisted Wire

Phil Dobbie

Tune in weekly for Twisted Wire, Phil Dobbie's weekly podcast on the tangled mess that is Australia's telecommunications industry.

Related gallery

CeBIT 2012 opens: photos

CeBIT 2012 opens: photos

Play or download the Twisted Wire podcast below:

Download Add to iTunes

Embed podcast:

If there's a change in government at the next election we know the National Broadband Network (NBN) will be ditched. So is there another way of achieving the objective of providing ubiquitous high speed broadband across the country?

Abbot's NBN plan

(Credit: Collage by Phil Dobbie/ZDNet Australia)

In this week's Twisted Wire we look to see if there's an alternative plan, for either political party. How can we ensure that there's high-speed internet access in the bush and drive the country to a fibre-enabled future while minimising government investment?

The coalition has been quiet on its alternate telecommunications policy beyond saying that its focus will be on ensuring access to under-served areas. Does that mean it will disband the NBN Co and throw away all the work that has already been done?

  • We try and help them formulate a more cohesive strategy with the help of:

  • Guy Cranswick, IBRS advisor
  • John Stanton, CEO of the Communications Alliance
  • Stephen King, dean of the Faculty of Business and Economics at Monash University
  • Dermot Cox, business development manager at C-Cor Broadband

What's your advice to Abbott and Gillard? Should we let the NBN carry on unabated, or is this time for a rethink?

Running time: 29 minutes, 42 seconds

Talkback

Well since Telstra has already agreed to a deal, and the work has already started, a new government would have to have rocks in their head to abandon the NBN. This is especially obvious given that all the experts in the field are strongly supportive of NBN. Plus a new government wouldn't have to worry about pushing Conroys ill-conceived filter notion, or wrestle with malicious nasties coming through the portal.

A new government could effectively scoop the cream off the top of all Labors hard work, ie they could keep the NBN, keep the Telstra deal, and then dump the ridiculous stuff such as the mandatory filter and forced ISP data retention, and effectively come out looking golden on the global telecommunications scene.

CHROMIUMCHROMIUM July 1st, 2010
Report offensive content Reply (0) (0)

How can it be more efficient to have two competing networks ?
You have twice the cost of building network infrastructure and only half the customers to pay for it
It does not make any sense at all

SimbaddySimbaddy July 1st, 2010
Report offensive content Reply (0) (0)

@Simbaddy, it makes no sense at all in the Australian context. Anyone who doubts this should look at the ten year history of HFC cable in this country, where the incumbent monopolist paralleled the Optus rollout to undermine its viability.

Result - no more rollout. Telstra could afford to wear the resulting losses but Optus couldn't, so any further endusers were denied further access to HFC cable.

gnomegnome July 1st, 2010
Report offensive content Reply (0) (0)

The alternative is simple: roll out government funded backhaul networks to regional areas (as is part of NBN policy) and let ISPs take care of the last mile. Where it is legitimately sustainable to deliver high speed DSL/wireless services to customers (which, considering the ever-falling price of microwave equipment, is a surprisingly large amount of the country) ISPs will do what they do best: build competitive networks. Where there is no alternatives, customers can be served by satellite.

The predominance of the cost of the NBN is in the last mile - which is already serviced (in most areas) with a copper and 2xHFC plant. Seems silly to replicate infrastructure in these areas.

curtis.baynecurtis.bayne July 1st, 2010
Report offensive content Reply (0) (0)

ISP's aren't good at building "the last mile". The last mile in Australia was built by public funds. Telstra simply inherited it and then abused its control to hurt competition. That's exactly what should be avoided this time around. Let the NBN Co build the pipes and ISP's compete on a level footing on services and price.

braomdbraomd July 1st, 2010
Report offensive content Reply (0) (0)

As much as I am a one-eyed conservative I think the policy of ending progress of the fibre network is something that Mr Abbott's approval rating will suffer for. The Liberal Party need to reverse this aspect of their policy platform quickly and just pay off the KRudd/Gillard bankcard a little slower.

Mel SommersbergMel Sommersberg July 1st, 2010
Report offensive content Reply (0) (0)

Trying to do a deal with the regulator has already failed under it's previous admin (previous CEO and Chairman).

Also, I would have thought that Telstra, throwing scenarios around, as David Thodey said, then they would have thought of scenario of opening up the exchanges etc, (I think France does this).

They have already lost that bargain option.

Also, why is current regulatory framework not enough to for multiple networks to rollout? Also why would less regulation be any more success than more regulation when multiple network rollouts ?

In-regards to BPON, GPON I thought BPON was older?

Oh, in regards to backhaul pricing etc, Pacific Fibre is going to build a new international cable, by 2013.

Should help the costs and competition on that lvl.

ZeroNutZeroNut July 1st, 2010
Report offensive content Reply (0) (0)

Mel, please don't fall for the line that gets trotted out by the Libs on debt. Most economists would agree that sustainable debt used to procure productive infrastructure is not a bad use for debt. If we do not go into debt for this type of infrastructure then we will never get it, instead we will get a mis match of different technologies that similar to what we currently endure. Broadband shouldn't only be for the lucky who happen to live in the right area.
Mr Abbott does need to re-think the NBN because I agree with you that it is a vote turner. The last thing we need is another backward thinking Prime Minister EG John Howard in speedos. This infrastructure is vital to our future so please wake up Mr Abbott and start smelling the roses.

dicksterdickster July 1st, 2010
Report offensive content Reply (0) (0)

If its between mandatory censorship and the nbn, i'll still vote for whoever will ditch the filter.

peternisspeterniss July 1st, 2010
Report offensive content Reply (+1) (0)

peterniss, then vote greens?

ZeroNutZeroNut July 1st, 2010
Report offensive content Reply (0) (0)

Regarding the comment on where FTTH has been successful before, Portugal Telecom was brought up. Even though there are a lot of Homes passed, the most expensive part remain, i.e. to connect the homes. And in order to get revenue the operators needs to connect the homes. And today there are VERY few homes connected. And with one of the most stretched economies in Europe its going to be difficult to get government subsidies. Hence, the Business Case does not look to good today.

For Australia its going to very interesting to see how NBN Business Case will take care of this. Building a backbone network is quite straight forward, but how to plan the take-up of subscribers with the very expensive homes connected part to make the Business case acceptable is the key.

duringduring July 1st, 2010
Report offensive content Reply (0) (0)

I'm quite concerned that the filter's black list is already being populated with suppression of political dissent in mind. This is not about the children, this is about our children's children's children. Didn't we fight a war or two over that principle?

nefariouswheelnefariouswheel July 6th, 2010
Report offensive content Reply (0) (0)

dickster is one all right! Tassie was asked and didn't want it. Now Conroy evidently wants to force it on us all. Socialists aaaah they are such a pain in the neck.

Big billBig bill August 1st, 2010
Report offensive content Reply (0) (0)
Add your opinion

In order to post a comment, you need to be registered. (Sign In or register below)

Post your comment

Terms of Service - As a ZDNet registrant, and by using this service, you indicate that you agree to our Terms and Conditions and have read and understand our Privacy Policy.

ZDNet Australia Live

You can also use the help of these links, just incase your stuff failed, I probably got Windows build by using the Pebuilder as per the i...

1 minute ago by WindowsAnalyzer on Boot Windows XP from a USB flash drive

RT @CorrieB: An iPad for every child: Inevitable or impossible? http://t.co/I7uS8l9s Thx to @timbuckteeth for this; http://t.co/jxkqIRIp

RT @MADinMelbourne: roxon "will enable more families to access credit" @MLolderandwiser: Privacy Act amendments http://t.co/Mv4c7PC2 via @zdnetaustralia

NBN users opt for 100Mbps - ZDNet Australia http://t.co/fLfHMzPn #australia #technews

RT @konradski: Whaddayaknow - turns out Wi-Fi CAN interfere with a plane's navigation systems http://t.co/ospQCU2S

This story has been voted 5 times in the last 24 hours!

3 hours ago, NBN's Tassie upgrade to cost $1.3 million

Sorry no deal Cinders, I'd rather send my money to someone and watch them desperately try to stop the NBN as this has much better enterta...

3 hours ago by Hubert Cumberdale on NBN users opt for 100Mbps

What else can you expect from a Dodo customer?

3 hours ago by Hubert Cumberdale on NBN users opt for 100Mbps

NBN users opt for 100Mbps - Communications - News - ZDNet Australia: NBN users opt for 100Mbps - Communications ... http://t.co/btB9gKWg

NBN users opt for 100Mbps http://t.co/xKqEb4bE via @zdnetaustralia

Biometric bugs too dangerous for public? http://t.co/8JLz5tdF via @zdnetaustralia

Oh please dont be unkind, I gotta have some fan's. btw I agree I dont set the standard, but who does I wonder?

6 hours ago by Doubt on NBN users opt for 100Mbps

You agree but give him thumbs down... I think you'd better take the medication before one of your alter ego's Fred/Frank/Frergers appear...

6 hours ago by Beta on NBN users opt for 100Mbps

Exploring: http://t.co/rT7RPZLA

+1

6 hours ago by Beta on NBN users opt for 100Mbps

War talk dominates #AusCERT 2012 - http://t.co/SlBpMj0c - #security #cyber

So we agree it was a stupid idea and even stupider comment then ;-)

6 hours ago by Beta on NBN users opt for 100Mbps

Not you obviously ;-)

And stop giving yourself thumbs up FFS.

6 hours ago by Beta on NBN users opt for 100Mbps

Ok Beta, understand now, just one point who sets the standard?

6 hours ago by Doubt on NBN users opt for 100Mbps

Oh no Beta you misunderstand me. I like my waterfront home and deep water jetty, it's those "other" people who can move to Willunga.

6 hours ago by Doubt on NBN users opt for 100Mbps

I agree with you Magnus, but really most people like living on the coastal fringe.

6 hours ago by Doubt on NBN users opt for 100Mbps

Travel Tech Q&A: Skyscanner's Ewan Gray http://t.co/vYexrDwu #ipad

Exploring: http://t.co/YNVjdrct

Exploring: Travel Tech Q and A: Skyscanner's Ewan Gray: Ewan Gray, Skyscanner's director for Asia ... http://t.co/bNLCyobv #ICTChallenge

Exploring: Travel Tech Q and A: Skyscanner's Ewan Gray: Ewan Gray, Skyscanner's director for Asia ... http://t.co/HEPuJgyt #ICTChallenge

#NewSouthWales ditches registration stickers 4 light #vehicles in favour of #technology http://t.co/xX5N0Rp9

Another use is city based top surgeons using 8K resolution monitors to provide real-time assistance to country surgeons and doctors to op...

6 hours ago by Magnus on NBN users opt for 100Mbps

In terms of capacity, fibre is basically future proof. Never mind 100Mbps or even 1Gbps. Computer scientists have already achieved 100 gi...

7 hours ago by Magnus on NBN users opt for 100Mbps

What I like about Mike Quigley is that he is making it happen, despite all the bull**t barriers being put in front of him by Coalition po...

7 hours ago by Magnus on NBN users opt for 100Mbps

Anonymous hacks Reliance's Internet filtering server - ZDNet (blog) http://t.co/uObU1HBP http://t.co/0UBXxwX4

Which Windows will make for a better tablet? http://t.co/4mAHg850

Gonna be crowded when TA switches of the inter webby thingy and everyone moves there, just as you suggested though.

8 hours ago by Beta on NBN users opt for 100Mbps

Yes "without secure internet identification methods" I cannot see a future for online voting be it a referendum or selecting a Gov (at ...

9 hours ago by Taskmanager on A farewell to democracy: Kaspersky

Oh of course you would would want something in return. hmmm I see, well maybe my best wishes for and your family. btw, Western Union is ...

9 hours ago by Doubt on NBN users opt for 100Mbps

Well Willunga looks like a nice place to live, close to wine growing areas, a golf club. Houses are probably reasonably priced. Very nice...

9 hours ago by Doubt on NBN users opt for 100Mbps

Listening to @stilgherrian cover AusCERT and cyberwar, http://t.co/6lGUEz8H

http://edfarmaciaes.com/#0500 generico viagra barcelona EdFarmaciaEs sildenafil y sulfatos

9 hours ago by buy priligy cheap on Top alternatives to Microsoft Outlook

Travel Tech Q and A: Skyscanner's Ewan Gray http://t.co/VN5tGJzC

#Westpac Board goes paperless with #Ipads with #Tabula #App http://t.co/duxuj2fd #Cybersecurity #Bank

Microsoft is serious about open source??? http://t.co/mqQGgta7

If I give you money what do I get in return? Do you know how commerce works or are you just a filthy poor that wants my monies for nothin...

10 hours ago by Hubert Cumberdale on NBN users opt for 100Mbps

@joedamato just try varying caps randomly. Maybe they do this http://t.co/1FN5FwYv

NSW outlines datacentre migration plans - Hardware - News - ZDNet Australia http://t.co/OQfUl0D1

"on the new fast Internets everyone wants the fast plan" #orly #nareally #yarly http://t.co/kvfCa84A

Chrome overtakes IE: does it matter? http://t.co/e4SILk8a

A ZDNet study showed that British Facebook users are drunk in 76 percent of their photos.

The HDMI cable ripoff and why retail is really dying http://t.co/eFT7zEW7

Travel Tech Q and A: Skyscanner's Ewan Gray http://t.co/IUysbyKf

Travel Tech Q and A: Skyscanner's Ewan Gray http://t.co/V7vL5QB9

ZDNet reports Microsoft launches its own social service http://t.co/VJS5BkwF

by http://t.co/vmlLt4bh: Travel Tech Q and A: Skyscanner's Ewan Gray: Ewan Gray, Skyscanner's director for Asia P... http://t.co/4bfDRXo4

Travel Tech Q and A: Skyscanner's Ewan Gray http://t.co/CtNlVWN7

Travel Tech Q and A: Skyscanner's Ewan Gray: Ewan Gray, Skyscanner's director for Asia Pacific, shares some of h... http://t.co/ZxjpmqiM

Microsoft is serious about open source: 10 proof points http://t.co/iv2ji74q

Accelerator targets 'clean-tech' start-ups http://t.co/p9VPCzCa

RT @vexnews: NBN users opt for highest speed plan http://t.co/8eUvvVvQ

This story has been voted 12000 times in the last 24 hours!

2 days ago, Is Bill Gates a great leader?

Facebook Activity

Keep up with ZDNet Australia

ZDNet Events Calendar

ZDNet Events Calendar