Web directory under fire from WA minister

Western Australia's Minister for Consumer Protection, John Kobelke, has issued a public warning about Web-based business service Australian Trade Register, describing its services as "questionable".

ATR, an online business registry owned by Thailand resident Gary John Solah, invites small businesses to join www.traderegister.com.au to attract business for a fee of AU$227. The business is registered at a Canberra mailing address that forwards on to a Gold Coast post-office box.

The Minister said the design of the registration form that ATR sends to invite business to join the site was a major concern. Kobelke said the "looks like a fee is payable to government agency".

"The Web site, although in existence, is very basic and falls short of Mr Solah's claims in his letter and does not represent value for money," said Kobelke.

He added later that businesses should consider whether the fee that the service demands could not be spent better.

However the Minister's power to take action against Solah appears to end at public criticism.

A spokesperson for the Minister conceded that the consumer protection investigators that Solah had breached any consumer codes or trade practice laws.

The Minister said Solah had "not been very cooperative" with consumer protection investigators. Consumer investigators had requested to meet with Solah in Thailand and Australia but so far he has refused.

"He has declined to provide any kind of personal contact details other than those of his secretarial service," said the Minister

However a spokesperson for Kobelke conceded that Solah had spoken to the minister's investigators.

The warning had been issued as consumer protection investigators were "not satisfied" with Solah's explanations regarding their concerns, said the spokesperson.

Like this article? Click below to send it to your mobile for free!

Talkback 1 comments

  1. I have recieved many letters from ATR, These letters could quite easily be seen as a Invoice or a debt to be paid. With a canberra address, it could be seen as government bill, not requiring the wording TAX INVOICE, such as car registration. This is , no Anonymous -- 01/02/04

    I have recieved many letters from ATR, These letters could quite easily be seen as a Invoice or a debt to be paid. With a canberra address, it could be seen as government bill, not requiring the wording TAX INVOICE, such as car registration. This is , no doubt, a scam to collect monies with no intent to provide the service implied, similar to offers from the Crime Prevenion Revue magazine.


Sponsored content

Power Centre - Content from our premier sponsors

Blogs

  • Alex Serpo Will the NSW Govt put Linux in schools?
    The NSW Government's release this week of an expressions of interest tender to give low-cost laptops to every senior public school student in NSW is a big step, but will these systems be Windows or Linux?
  • Array Naked Mac versus protected PC: What wins?
    What's easier to manage — 200 Mac OS X systems without antivirus or 200 Windows systems running a leading antivirus package?
  • Array Dear Telstra: pack up your toys, go home
    Rejecting Telstra's proposal, after all, is the only conclusion Conroy can reach: as someone whose entire philosophy is built around transparency and process, he simply cannot keep Telstra as part of the NBN bidding process anymore.
  • More blogs »

Tags

Back to top

Featured