Report calls anti-OOXML crowd poseurs

Large organisations should consider adopting Microsoft's Office Open XML (OOXML) document format, according to new research.

Burton Group research directors Guy Creese and Peter O'Kelly released a report this week backing OOXML for the enterprise, saying of the heated debate inspired by the document format: "The competitive stakes are huge, and the related political posturing is sometimes perplexing."

The report concludes that organisations that already use Microsoft's Office should use the Office Open XML file formats which are the default in Office 2007.

While the authors predict that OOXML will gain significant market adoption, they add that OOXML's main rival, OpenDocument Format (ODF), will continue to have a market influence. ODF, which is the default file format of the open source OpenOffice suite, has seen growing interest from government customers concerned with long-term access to documents.

Burton Group argues that choosing OpenOffice or ODF is done primarily as an anti-Microsoft move saying in the report: "ODF should be seen as more of an anti-Microsoft political statement than an objective technology selection."

Opponents of the OOXML format believe that the software was released by Microsoft as a means of stifling the open source market.

IBM spokesperson and OOXML opponent Paul Robinson recently described the format to ZDNet Australia as a "redundant replacement for other standards".

The Burton Group study does however warn that Microsoft needs to live up to its commitments to make OOXML a standard that includes input from other vendors and customers.

"If Microsoft abuses standards initiatives, the market response will be swift and severe," the study concludes.

Advertisement

Talkback 3 comments

  1. Read this first Anonymous -- 16/01/08

    Before deciding on OOXML/ODF people should read this article from Ars Technia on the Burton report: http://arstechnica.com/news.ars/post/20080114-analyst-group-slams-odf-downplays-microsoft-iso-abuses.html

  2. Dispelling Myths Around ODF Erwin Tenhumberg -- 16/01/08

    My name is Erwin Tenhumberg. I work for Sun Microsystems and co-chair the ODF Adoption Technical Committee at OASIS. People reading this article might also be interested in my post which hopes to address some of the misconceptions surrounding ODF. It can be found at:

    http://blogs.sun.com/dancer/entry/dispelling_myths_around_odf

    Best regards,
    Erwin

    1. Thanks Erwin Anonymous -- 17/01/08

      That answers a lot of questions.

Add your opinion


Latest Videos

ZDNet's CIO Vision Series

Department of Defence | Greg Farr, CIO (part two)

In the second part of his interview, Defence CIO Greg Farr talks about outsourcing, the skills crisis and reveals his most urgent IT priority.

Sponsored content

Power Centre - Content from our premier sponsors

Blogs

  • Angus Kidman I'm a celebrity, don't back me up
    Celebrity comes with its perks — free alcohol, better-looking partners, lots of holiday time — and disadvantages — constant media intrusions, being forced to appear in films with Eddie Murphy for the long-term good of your career, and having to do mindless radio interviews with angry men who've been awake since 4am.
  • Array Lies, damned lies and telco stupidity
    Earlier this month, Telstra put out a press release trumpeting that it's come up with a new phone coaching service to help people who are "bamboozled" by their mobiles. Another excellent example of wrongheaded thinking from the mobile industry.
  • Array Dear carriers: More walking, less talking
    Sometimes, a well-placed and well-timed letter can make all the difference. Other times, it can make no difference at all — and even hurt your case. This week's missive by the Competitive Carriers' Coalition, I would suggest, falls into the latter category.
  • More blogs »

Tags

Back to top

Featured