Red Hat Linux upgrade bug hides Windows

Red Hat's newest hobbyist and developer version of Linux, Fedora Core 2, caused trouble for some who found they couldn't start Windows after installing the Linux upgrade side-by-side with it.

The bug had cropped up in testing, but after Red Hat released Fedora Core 2 in May, many more users reported their systems no longer would boot Windows.

No data on the Windows side was destroyed, and some manual hard drive reconfiguration fixed the problem.

"We do not think this is a severe problem," said Red Hat programmer Cristian Gafton in an e-mail interview, because information isn't destroyed, the problem is repairable, and "a very small fraction of systems are affected."

However, he added, "We recognize that it is an annoying issue for the users that are affected by it and we are working on publishing a fix that will address it."

Fedora Core is designed to satisfy the appetites of those who want the latest software while maturing Linux improvements more quickly for use in the corporate product, Red Hat Enterprise Linux. The company makes no pretenses Fedora's stability; the Web site includes the disclaimer, "The Fedora Project is not a supported product of Red Hat."

Until 2002, Red Hat offered an identical version of Linux as a free, unsupported download or as a paid product with support. Now only Fedora Core 2 is available for free, while Enterprise Linux, which changes more slowly, costs between US$349 and US$18,000 per one-year support subscription.

The problem with Fedora Core 2 apparently had to do with changes made to a computer's description of the physical layout of its hard disk, data called the partition table, Gafton said.

In some cases, Fedora Core 2 would use a different convention to record the information, and Windows XP wouldn't recognise the disk. In other cases, the problem stemmed differences in how Windows, Linux and a computer's BIOS--basic input-output software used in the early stages of starting a computer--handle the partition table information, Gafton said.

Advertisement

Talkback 2 comments

    Obviously Christian hasn't been onto the Linuxquestions.org website forums and read some of the horror stories relating to this "issue". I did fix the problem, only after completely destroying my 60Gb Windoze partition, resetting the BIOS to LBAAnonymous -- 09/06/04

    Obviously Christian hasn't been onto the Linuxquestions.org website forums and read some of the horror stories relating to this "issue". I did fix the problem, only after completely destroying my 60Gb Windoze partition, resetting the BIOS to LBA mode for the drive then reinstalling from scratch.
    Interesting to hear that the bug was known about previous to actually releasing a downloadable "final" release. I know I don't have the time or the space here but there are a raft of issues with this release of FC. Thank God for Slackware 9.1

    To 'anonymous' above. This is not a Red Hat problem, but a Linux 2.6.x kernel problem, specifically with the disk partioning table sizes returned by the kernel. Other distros, like Mandrake have had the same problem. Also, most versionAnonymous -- 09/06/04

    To 'anonymous' above.

    This is not a Red Hat problem, but a Linux 2.6.x kernel problem, specifically with the disk partioning table sizes returned by the kernel. Other distros, like Mandrake have had the same problem.

    Also, most versions of Windows have, for years, often damaged or obfuscated Linux partitions, but this didn't make the news.

    Having said that, this problem should have been fixed prior to FC 2 release.

Add your opinion


Latest Videos

Blogs

  • Suzanne Tindal E-health too unsexy for COAG
    There will always be something more politically sexy than e-health for state governments, meaning the National E-Health Transition Authority's business case for a national electronic medical record might just sit on the shelf gathering dust forever.
  • Array Will Rudd's bush backhaul bonanza deliver?
    Rural areas will be welcoming the government's decision to put its money where its politicising is, funnelling $250m into a regional fibre upgrade to six rural centres. Remedying over a decade of near-neglect at the hands of telecoms privatisation, the investment could be the firmest step yet for Labor's NBN dream — but with inevitable political questions and a looming election, Rudd and Conroy need to deliver, and quickly, to preserve the NBN's credibility.
  • Array Doing for AV what VoIP did for telephony
    Sydney-based start-up Audinate is making traditional analog cabling obsolete in favour of TCP/IP-based networking technology. And it's doing a pretty good job so far, with its technology used by World Youth Day and the Sydney Opera House.
  • More blogs »

Tags

Back to top

Featured