The US Supreme Court on Monday denied a Microsoft appeal to an antitrust case that dates back to Novell's desktop PC software business in the mid-1990s.
The move leaves standing a lower court ruling that says Novell can sue Microsoft under federal antitrust laws. Novell argued that Microsoft used its monopoly power to sink Novell's QuattroPro spreadsheet and WordPerfect word processor.
The court had no comment and Chief Justice John Roberts abstained because he is a Microsoft shareholder, according to the Associated Press.
"Microsoft specifically targeted WordPerfect and Novell's other office productivity applications because they threatened Microsoft's Windows monopoly," according to the Novell court filing quoted by the Bloomberg news service.
In its case, Novell also said that Microsoft withheld technical information to make WordPerfect work with Windows 95.
In its appeal, Microsoft argued that federal antitrust laws don't apply to the case because Novell does not compete in operating systems.
In the late 1990s, Microsoft settled federal and state antitrust suits against it, which includes ongoing oversight over the company's actions.
The Novell case is the largest of remaining private suits against the company.
Microsoft contended in its appeal that Novell can't invoke the US antitrust laws because it didn't compete against Windows in the operating system market.
Microsoft on Monday explaining its rationale to appeal the lower court's ruling: "We realise the Supreme Court reviews a small percentage of cases each year, but we filed our petition because it offered an opportunity to address the question of who may assert antitrust claims. We look forward to addressing this and other substantive matters in the case before the trial court. We believe the facts will show that Novell's claims, which are 12 to 14 years old, are without merit."
This is really getting tiresome - Novell will disappear in the near future - their products - whilst technically good - lack consumer appeal.
WordPerfect was a good program - but lets face it - there will be no market penetration by any products other than Microsoft UNTIL THE MANUFACTURERS OF COMPETING PRODUCTS MAKE THEM 100% COMPATIBLE WITH MICROSOFT PRODUCTS.
THINK BETACORD VIDEO RECORDERS - technically brilliant but the VHS crowd just did better marketing.