Microsoft tackles AMD conflict in SP2

A problem in the Service Pack 2 update for Windows XP may keep owners of AMD-based computers from using the long-awaited security package under certain circumstances, according to Microsoft.

In an article posted in the Knowledge Base section of its Web site, Microsoft says that Service Pack 2 may not work with computers running Advanced Micro Devices' 64-bit microprocessors. The Redmond, Washington-based company said earlier that owners of such PCs may want to bypass the update completely, but has now come up with a workaround.

AMD's 64-bit chips include the Athlon 64 for PCs and the Opteron for servers.

A Microsoft representative declined to comment directly on the AMD-related issue but said the company "continually investigates all issues and vulnerabilities" reported to it regarding SP2 and other products.

However, an AMD representative said the chipmaker believes the problem has only occurred, so far, with one application, Sigma Designs' Realmagic Hollywood Plus DVD Decoder. Microsoft also identifies the application as being able to cause the problem.

Microsoft said in its advisory that PCs with 64-bit AMD processors may restart repeatedly after installing Service Pack 2, if those machines are also configured to enforce so-called data execution prevention (DEP) and contain hardware that requires a driver software known as Mpegport.sys. Sigma Designs' Realmagic Hollywood Plus DVD decoder application is one such application that uses the driver, the software maker said.

Microsoft says users may be able to resolve the problem by configuring a so-called DEP exception. AMD also recommends that people affected by the problem do so. Otherwise, Microsoft advises AMD users to remove SP2 altogether.

The AMD problem is the latest in a slew of issues that have dogged SP2 since it was first released to PC manufacturers at the beginning of August. By mid-month, Microsoft had detailed some 50 different software applications and games that may encounter problems with the update.

The potential for conflicts caused some high-profile businesses, including IBM, to order their employees to avoid installing SP2 until its ramifications can be better understood. Other organisations are moving forward with the update, expecting that its security enhancements outweigh the integration issues.

Microsoft has launched a do-it-yourself kit to help IT professionals assess their software's compatibility with the update. The compatibility guide, which can be retrieved from Microsoft's Download Center, is designed to help administrators "test and mitigate application compatibility issues."

Advertisement

Talkback 7 comments

    Hi, I recently installed SP2 i ...Anonymous -- 30/08/04

    Hi,
    I recently installed SP2 in my Athlon XP2800+ system, just to find it continually rebooting.
    I could not get through safe mode or do a windows repair, so I ended up having to reinstall windows.
    Thanks for nothing Microsoft!!!!!!!!

    Installed on Athlon 64 3200 an ...Anonymous -- 30/08/04

    Installed on Athlon 64 3200 and no problems whatsoever. This will probably be the normal SP2 experience, however there will always be a small number of users upon whos systems SP2 won't operate correctly, usually due to pre-existing problems which the upgrading process falls over.

    See video review of SP2 issues ...Anonymous -- 30/08/04

    See video review of SP2 issues here:

    http://www.zdnet.com.au/reviews/software/os/0,39023442,39157680,00.htm

    The most significant issue I h ...Anonymous -- 05/09/04

    The most significant issue I have encountered with SP2 so far has been the inability to install Office 97 SP1 AFTER Windows XP SP2 has been installed.

    If this is attempted, after the files have all been copied, during the DLL registration stage an error relating to an OLE registration issue is reported for a DLL having a name starting with "HTML" and containing a Q (sorry, can't remember the full name and it is not on the computer I am using). This aborts the installation of Office 97.

    If you uninstall Windows XP SP2 and then install Office 97, all goes Ok. Having installed Office 97, it is possible to install Windows XP SP2 without breaking anything.

    When I reported this (in all the detail above) to Microsoft, their response was "Office 97 is no longer a supported product".

    I told them that that was not the product that was broken - as it works on every other version of Windows - but they couldn't have been less interested, despite my pointing out that this may be a pointer to wider issues.

    My apologies - I should have c ...Anonymous -- 05/09/04

    My apologies - I should have contextualised my last comment - about the Office 97 installation.

    I have installed SP2 on top of existing installs on multiple different platforms, including two Athlon XP systems, with no severe issues.

    There have been multiple firewall configuration issues (the need to understand exactly what ports needed to be opened), and we needed to upgrade our Symantec AntiVirus Corporate Edition to the latest release (high praise due here for the knowledge and responsiveness of the Symantec support staff) but generally, everything has gone well.

    On at least two occasions on two different PCs, when changing the network configuration (eg. changing the IP address of an adapter), the configuration wizard has locked up solid, leaving the system otherwise responsive, but obliging a forced power down to get out.

    Apart from this, the greater memory footprint and the Office 97 install issue, the transition has been labour intensive, but acceptable.

    My biggest grumble is the fact that Microsoft are totally unwilling to accept reports on issues that don't fit their own particular definition of "worthy".

    Been getting a lot of memory e ...Anonymous -- 07/09/04

    Been getting a lot of memory error message on my XP 2600 ever since i installed XP SP2

    I tried to install the pack an ...Anonymous -- 08/09/04

    I tried to install the pack and my whole system crashed (Joybook 5000) Thanks a lot Microsoft, you could at least have some kind of warning on the site.

Add your opinion

Latest Videos

Sponsored content

Power Centre - Content from our premier sponsors

Blogs

  • Suzanne Tindal Love me, tender
    Considering how expensive and drawn-out tender processes can be to solve problems that might be very immediate, it's little wonder that the Victorian Police IT department tried to work the tender exemptions system.
  • Array 2009 funding drought rolls on
    For Australian start-ups looking for venture capital, 2009 was a very bad year. 2010 may be no better.
  • Array Can not-so-smart meters help the NBN?
    It was interesting to witness Conroy's recent enthusiasm to spruik the NBN's role in supporting the Smart Grid, Smart City initiative. What a pity that Conroy hadn't yet seen the damning report from the Victorian auditor-general about that state's smart-meter roll-out.
  • More blogs »

Tags

Back to top

Featured