Microsoft Vista SP1 update can destroy data

By Tom Espiner, ZDNet UK
21 February 2008 08:01 AM
Tags: data, destroy, microsoft, sp1, suspend, vista, windows, nick white

Microsoft has stopped automatically distributing a prerequisite piece of software for Windows Vista Service Pack 1, following customer complaints that it had caused system problems.

Servicing stack update KB937287, released last week, contained updates to Windows Vista installation software, and was billed as being "necessary to successfully install and to remove Windows Vista SP1 (Service Pack 1) on all versions of Windows Vista."

Microsoft stopped distributing the update on Wednesday, according to a blog post by Microsoft product manager Nick White.

"We've heard a few reports about problems customers may be experiencing as a result of KB937287," wrote White. "Immediately after receiving reports of this error, we made the decision to temporarily suspend automatic distribution of the update to avoid further customer impact while we investigate possible causes."

Vista SP1 is already available to subscribers to the Microsoft Developer Network but won't receive a formal public release until mid-March.

One irate Windows Vista Ultimate user replied to White's blog post, saying the prerequisite had corrupted a PC and resulted in the need to reformat the hard drive, with the resulting loss of all of the files and programs. When advised by an anonymous contributor of the System Restore option on the Vista installation disc, the Vista Ultimate user replied that the copy of Vista had been purchased and downloaded from the Internet, so there was no disc.

Two users complained that Windows Update prompted them to install the prerequisite, even after they had installed it.

Another user, S Marusic, wrote: "New Dell Inspiron PC stuck on the update loop as well. Any ETA from Microsoft on when/how to fix it? My client has valuable data that I need to consider stripping off the (hard drive) unless a patch/fix comes out soon...Help!"

According to Microsoft's White: "This problem only affects a small number of customers in unique circumstances."

Advertisement

Talkback 8 comments

    Another Vista Problem? Anonymous -- 21/02/08

    My new DELL XPS 1530 has been having network connection issues since I did this update... Maybe the DELL tech didn't have to replace the motherborad after all???

    Ah well

    SP1 has NOT been released yet! Anonymous -- 21/02/08 (in reply to #320095948)

    Maybe you should have waited until SP1 had actually been officially released?

    There is an issue for a minority group of people, where certain drivers are installed wrongly (by their own installer - nothing to do with Microsoft) which will cause the system to fail. Again, THIS IS NOT Microsoft's FAULT! It is the 3rd party installers, incorrectly installing the driver.

    Yet again, Microsoft gets the blame for something that is nothing to do with them.

    THIS IS NOT AN SP1 UPDATE Anonymous -- 21/02/08 (in reply to #320095949)

    Did you even read the article?

    This is not the SP1 update, it is an update that prepares a Vista for the coming SP1 in March.

    This is automatically distributed as a recommended update via windows update.

    Who needs Viruses Anonymous -- 21/02/08

    This is all quite amusing. I am happy that am using a Linux/Fedora system that never has problems like this. Some people have had to re-format their hard drives because of these updates.

    Microsoft Download Endless Loop Problems Anonymous -- 22/02/08

    I am in New Zealand. My HP laptop got stuck in an endless loop of trying to download an update. Nothing would work so I phoned MS NZ who said not their problem but said phone HP. I did they said it was MS problem but talked me through to reformat ??(I am not technical but returned it to the state it was when we got it a couple of months ago)

    But of course we have lost all our information - luckily most backed up - but all programs like Spybot etc now have to be re-installed.

    I learnt something. Do not do as MS recommend - do not allow them to update without your approval. Wait 3-4 weeks at least before updating to see if they have put out another disaster.

    The worst of all is that they (HP - MS) say it is each others fault and don't care.

    Microsoft is human after all... Anonymous -- 25/02/08

    i've _never_ had a problem like this with my mac/linux systems

    Vista is terrible Allie -- 25/03/08

    My Dell laptop had a fault so Dell replaced it under warranty. Unfortunately they had to replace it with the newer model which runs Vista. I wasn't keen as I'd heard bad things and I liked XP. Since I got the new laptop I had a lot of problems with Vista. After receiving some advice from a message board I restored everything to factory condition and refused to install any Vista updates. Since then, so far so good. I definitely won't be installing SP1. My laptop has been working fine for the past 4 months now (touch wood this continues!) so why try & fix something that's not broken?

    Microsoft Integrity in Jeopardy Allen Buckner -- 02/05/08

    Unfortunately, Windows XP SP3 isn't the only data corruption glitch Microsoft's got!

    Just take a look at Windows Home Server and your find a proven data corruption design flaw (KB 946676) that hasn't been fixed since last year, and isn't even expected to arrive until sometime around June 2008!

    A defect that causes Windows Home Server’s Drive Extender technology toexperience data corruption with all the below Microsoft applications...

    Microsoft Office Outlook 2007
    Microsoft Money 2007
    Microsoft Office Excel
    Microsoft Digital Image Library
    Microsoft Windows Vista Photo Gallery
    Microsoft Windows Live Photo Gallery
    Microsoft Office OneNote 2007
    Microsoft Office OneNote 2003
    Microsoft Windows Media Player 11
    Microsoft Zune Software
    Microsoft Virtual PC 2008
    Microsoft Project 2000
    Microsoft SyncToy 2.0 Beta

    Doesn't Microsoft test it's own software? Have customers all become beta testers? Why are Microsoft customers paying for this level of vaporware?

Add your opinion

Latest Videos

Sponsored content

Power Centre - Content from our premier sponsors

Blogs

  • Suzanne Tindal Sick of broken tender sites
    Some of the state governments desperately need to invest in more user-friendly tender sites so that looking for information on government tenders doesn't have to be a game of blind man's bluff.
  • Array Cyberwar: What is it good for?
    In this week's episode, Cyberwar. What is Australia's place in the world of digital warfare? What are the implications for the NBN?
  • Array Is wholesale-only backhaul just a pipedream?
    The potential acquisition of Pipe Networks by SP Telemedia has raised the question about whether vertically integrated backhaul providers will mean higher wholesale prices for ISP customers.
  • More blogs »

Tags

Back to top

Featured