Did Google steal the Sky for its Earth?

A former Google contractor is suing the company for allegedly stealing from him the idea for the Sky layer in Google Earth.

The lawsuit filed this week in federal district court in Atlanta seeks punitive damages of US$25 million from Google.

Jonathan Cobb claims in his suit that he disclosed the idea for a Google Sky idea in internal e-mail discussion groups when he worked at Google as a contractor beginning in 2006.

The Google Earth Sky layer, when it launched in August 2007, was similar in interface and functionality to what he had conceptualised, Cobb claims.

Google representatives did not return e-mails seeking comment.

The case may not be as straightforward as it sounds, says one Internet law expert.

"These types of misappropriation claims are easy to make and hard to disprove," says Eric Goldman, an assistant professor at Santa Clara University School of Law. "It's not entirely clear that Cobb wins even if everything he says is true."

Advertisement

Talkback 2 comments

  1. One law for us, and another for them Steve Roper -- 19/02/08

    "These types of misappropriation claims are easy to make and hard to disprove ... It's not entirely clear that Cobb wins even if everything he says is true."

    Of course, that only applies when the infringing party is a major corporation. If Cobb released Sky himself and Google claimed he'd stolen it off them their lawyers would skin and gut him. And the case would be misreported showing him to be a greedy exploitative thief while the poor victimised Google loses billions of dollars from the "theft."

    So we the people can be fined for everything we own for downloading an MP3, but corporations like Google can help themselves to others' work with impunity.

    Democracy indeed! Plutocracy is what we live under.

  2. why is this not thrown out? Anonymous -- 19/02/08

    so a guy working at a company
    suggests an idea via internal company discussion boards
    and the company use this idea
    and the guy tries to sue?
    Little guy trying to rip off the big guy who has lots of money.
    Sure there's more to the story we aren't told, but that is what it comes down to.

Add your opinion


Latest Videos

ZDNet's CIO Vision Series

Department of Defence | Greg Farr, CIO (part two)

In the second part of his interview, Defence CIO Greg Farr talks about outsourcing, the skills crisis and reveals his most urgent IT priority.

Sponsored content

Power Centre - Content from our premier sponsors

Blogs

  • Angus Kidman I'm a celebrity, don't back me up
    Celebrity comes with its perks — free alcohol, better-looking partners, lots of holiday time — and disadvantages — constant media intrusions, being forced to appear in films with Eddie Murphy for the long-term good of your career, and having to do mindless radio interviews with angry men who've been awake since 4am.
  • Array Lies, damned lies and telco stupidity
    Earlier this month, Telstra put out a press release trumpeting that it's come up with a new phone coaching service to help people who are "bamboozled" by their mobiles. Another excellent example of wrongheaded thinking from the mobile industry.
  • Array Dear carriers: More walking, less talking
    Sometimes, a well-placed and well-timed letter can make all the difference. Other times, it can make no difference at all — and even hurt your case. This week's missive by the Competitive Carriers' Coalition, I would suggest, falls into the latter category.
  • More blogs »

Tags

Back to top

Featured