A former Google contractor is suing the company for allegedly stealing from him the idea for the Sky layer in Google Earth.
The lawsuit filed this week in federal district court in Atlanta seeks punitive damages of US$25 million from Google.
Jonathan Cobb claims in his suit that he disclosed the idea for a Google Sky idea in internal e-mail discussion groups when he worked at Google as a contractor beginning in 2006.
The Google Earth Sky layer, when it launched in August 2007, was similar in interface and functionality to what he had conceptualised, Cobb claims.
Google representatives did not return e-mails seeking comment.
The case may not be as straightforward as it sounds, says one Internet law expert.
"These types of misappropriation claims are easy to make and hard to disprove," says Eric Goldman, an assistant professor at Santa Clara University School of Law. "It's not entirely clear that Cobb wins even if everything he says is true."
"These types of misappropriation claims are easy to make and hard to disprove ... It's not entirely clear that Cobb wins even if everything he says is true."
Of course, that only applies when the infringing party is a major corporation. If Cobb released Sky himself and Google claimed he'd stolen it off them their lawyers would skin and gut him. And the case would be misreported showing him to be a greedy exploitative thief while the poor victimised Google loses billions of dollars from the "theft."
So we the people can be fined for everything we own for downloading an MP3, but corporations like Google can help themselves to others' work with impunity.
Democracy indeed! Plutocracy is what we live under.