Desktop Linux a vehicle for pirating Windows

PCs running Linux are growing in popularity in part because they can be loaded with a pirated copy of Windows, according to a study from analyst Gartner.

The consulting firm issued a report on Wednesday stating that about 40 percent of Linux PCs will be modified to run an illegal copy of Windows, a bait-and-switch maneuver that lowers the cost of obtaining a Windows PC.

In emerging markets, where desktop Linux enjoys wider popularity, the trend is even starker. Around 80 percent of the time, Linux will be removed for a pirated copy of Windows. Pirated copies sell for around US$1 in the streets of Shanghai and other cities in Asia and Eastern Europe, but can also be bought in stores selling brand name PCs.

As a result, the number of desktop Linux PCs that ship will exceed the actual percentage of Linux machines that get installed in the real world. Desktop Linux will account for about 5 percent of desktops shipped in 2004, according to Gartner, with 10.5 percent of the desktops in Asia shipping with Linux this year. However, the installed base of Linux will come to only 1.3 percent.

In 2008, Linux will account for 7.5 percent of PCs shipped, but only 2.6 percent of the installed base, about the same that Apple's installed base will be then.

A comparable lack of drivers, training costs and migration headaches will also retard desktop Linux growth.

"Linux on the desktop may be generating a lot of publicity, but there are very few large-scale dedicated Linux deployments," the firm stated. "Governments in several European countries have announced plans to migrate to Linux, but most of these projects are in the evaluation phase."

Price, of course, is a huge motivator in piracy. All of the components inside PCs have dropped in price in the past several years, except Windows. Windows accounted for around 5 percent to 6 percent of the cost of building a "professional"-level PC in 1996. Now, the operating system accounts for 12 percent to 15 percent of the cost.

Still, the growing acceptance of Linux has prompted Microsoft to hatch plans for releasing an inexpensive version of Windows, called Windows XP Starter Edition in Thailand, Malaysia, Indonesia, Russia and India.

"It is likely that Microsoft would prefer the initial OS on a new PC to be a Windows variant rather than Linux, even if piracy were to continue," the report stated. "This would reduce the amount of interest that Linux is generating because of its increasing presence on new PCs."

Gartner is a tough audience these days. In August, Gartner wrote a report criticising Windows XP Starter Edition, claiming that it lacked some features and would "likely increase software piracy."

Talkback 10 comments

    Microsoft's _ludicrous_ pricin ...Anonymous -- 30/09/04

    Microsoft's _ludicrous_ pricing is what causes Windows piracy. If Windows was sold for what it's worth, US$25 per copy, piracy would be recuded dramatically.

    Reverse Gartner? Oh, but of co ...Anonymous -- 30/09/04

    Reverse Gartner? Oh, but of course! Rentrag!

    And let's scratch the surface ...Anonymous -- 30/09/04

    And let's scratch the surface to see who owns the largest slice of Gartner? Lo and behold: Bill Gates and his pals! Surprise surprise!

    Source:
    http://www.informationweek.com/story/showArticle.jhtml?articleID=15800394

    This article has all the hallm ...Anonymous -- 30/09/04

    This article has all the hallmarks of a very large helping of FUD from Redmond. Those discerning computer users, savvy enough to actually purchase a PC with a Linux desktop installed are hardly likely to be so stupid as to DOWNGRADE to any version of Windose.

    What a crock. My customers bu ...Anonymous -- 30/09/04

    What a crock. My customers buy Linux systems because they WANT to run Linux. Its fast, its secure, and its customizable.

    Gartner is way too generous, w ...Anonymous -- 30/09/04

    Gartner is way too generous, working in Asia for 7 years now. the odds are that more than 90% of the "Linux" systems are reformated to Windows. Several Notebooks I have know of come with a 7 day "trial" version of Win XP, but the manufacture gives you a localized version of Linux, which the store techs don't even know how to install or use. I asked them.
    The problem is there aren't even a full set of drivers for the linux that is provided with the system, there is however a complete set for Windows XP.

    What a Crock, saying any system is "secure" there are "holes" in all OS, and more found everyday, the ones that make the news are the ones caught.

    Gartner also missed the acutal ...Anonymous -- 30/09/04

    Gartner also missed the acutal percentage cost.
    Let's look a $450 computer, $240 for Win XP, and $375 for MS-Office, that is $615 for the programs that is 136% of the hardware value and 58% of the systems cost for a legal setup. compair that to $450 for the hardware and $3 for the programs.

    As for the Win XP Start (the "low Price edition"), it has no networking in it, and you are only allowed to open 3 windows for 3 programs at a time. That OS will be "Upgraded" to Win XP Pro (Pirate), as soon as the computer is in the consumers hands. There are stores that you can pay to install all the programs you want, while you are "Shopping" for the games you like.

    How can Micro$aft charge so mu ...Anonymous -- 30/09/04

    How can Micro$aft charge so much for such buggy software. Thats why piracy exists!

    Ill stick with my Mac OS X and if ever forced from my Mac platform(hell would have to freeze over) it would only be in the Linux direction.

    What a DOLLAR ! that's a 100% ...Anonymous -- 01/10/04

    What a DOLLAR ! that's a 100% markup on a perfectly good CD-R which was destroyed by putting such a wretched OS on it. Systems are ordered with Linux because that's what the customer asked for and wishes to use.

    Notice Microsoft uses this as ...Anonymous -- 01/05/05

    Notice Microsoft uses this as an anti-linux push??

    Users are perfectly capable of saying "no operating system thanks I already have my own from the computer I threw out, my friend will install it for me"

    But Microsoft would rather blame Linux. I can't blame them, ever person that bought one with Linux was someone who hated windows and was looking for an alternative.

Add your opinion

Latest Videos

Sponsored content

Power Centre - Content from our premier sponsors

Blogs

Tags

Back to top

Featured