Browsers squabble over best browser claim

Ingrid Marson, ZDNet UK

13 June 2005 03:03 PM

Tags: browser, opera, firefox, ie, award, pc world, best, won

A Mozilla Foundation employee has hit out at Opera Software for claiming it won a best browser award, saying this award was actually won by the open source browser Firefox.

Opera Software sent out a press release last week claiming that it had been named the best Web browser by technology magazine PC World. "A winning streak: Opera once again wins PC World's World Class Award for best Web browser," stated the release.

A few days later Asa Dotzler, an employee at the Mozilla Foundation, claimed that PC World had named Firefox as the best browser.

"Firefox not only won the coveted Product of the Year award, sweeping all 99 other products in the list, but it beat out two other browsers, Maxthon at number 12 and Opera way down at number 88," said Dotzler in his blog on Tuesday.

An Opera employee, known as Haavard, said on Wednesday that the company was no longer sure whether it had won this award and had updated its Web site to make this clear.

"At closer inspection, it appears that Opera might not have won the best browser of 2005 award from PC World after all. Opera is listed as the only browser in the 'Web' category, which I guess got us confused," said Haavard in his blog. "We've removed the 'best browser' stuff from Opera.com until PC World gets back to us to clarify things. We're posting a statement in the near future as well."

Despite the vehemence of Dotzler's initial blog posting, he said in a later posting that he does not hold any hard feelings against Opera and would celebrate if it took significant market share from Microsoft's Internet Explorer.

"There have been a lot of people accusing me of hating Opera. They're simply wrong. I don't hate the Opera browser at all. I think it's moving in the right direction and for my use (and I suspect for many power users) it's the second or third best browser available -- depending on whether or not you have access to a Mac," said Dotzler. "If Opera can start taking significant market share away from IE, I will be cheering right along with the Opera users."

More information on PC World's best products of 2005 award is available here.

Advertisement

Talkback 3 comments

  1. Definitely Firefox !!! At least you don't have to pay for it as you would with Opera. Anonymous -- 14/06/05

    Definitely Firefox !!!
    At least you don't have to pay for it as you would with Opera.

  2. best because its free, now there is asuggestion about vlaue, not becuase it is the most secure, best featured, most flexible, but it is free. Obviously you went to the Novell stupid business decisions school Anonymous -- 14/06/05

    best because its free, now there is asuggestion about vlaue, not becuase it is the most secure, best featured, most flexible, but it is free. Obviously you went to the Novell stupid business decisions school

  3. Who honestly cares? "Best Browser" means absolutely nothing. No browser is secure, and the "best" choice is the one that works for the most people. These two organizations should be working together instead of competing against each Anonymous -- 17/06/05

    Who honestly cares? "Best Browser" means absolutely nothing. No browser is secure, and the "best" choice is the one that works for the most people. These two organizations should be working together instead of competing against each other if they are serious about toppling Internet Explorer's lead.

    http://www.inaniloquent.com/PermaLink.aspx?guid=01c2f9f3-df0c-482d-a9ec-bc2ca831baf6

Add your opinion


Latest Videos

ZDNet's CIO Vision Series

Department of Defence | Greg Farr, CIO (part two)

In the second part of his interview, Defence CIO Greg Farr talks about outsourcing, the skills crisis and reveals his most urgent IT priority.

Sponsored content

Power Centre - Content from our premier sponsors

Blogs

  • Angus Kidman I'm a celebrity, don't back me up
    Celebrity comes with its perks — free alcohol, better-looking partners, lots of holiday time — and disadvantages — constant media intrusions, being forced to appear in films with Eddie Murphy for the long-term good of your career, and having to do mindless radio interviews with angry men who've been awake since 4am.
  • Array Lies, damned lies and telco stupidity
    Earlier this month, Telstra put out a press release trumpeting that it's come up with a new phone coaching service to help people who are "bamboozled" by their mobiles. Another excellent example of wrongheaded thinking from the mobile industry.
  • Array Dear carriers: More walking, less talking
    Sometimes, a well-placed and well-timed letter can make all the difference. Other times, it can make no difference at all — and even hurt your case. This week's missive by the Competitive Carriers' Coalition, I would suggest, falls into the latter category.
  • More blogs »

Tags

Back to top

Featured