Bankers wrestle with online security

The Australian Bankers Association is still grappling with two-factor authentication for Internet transactions and has almost hit a "brick wall" in its anti-fraud efforts.

Last week, major Australian banks gathered in Sydney with the Banking and Financial Services Ombudsman to discuss the security of online commerce in a closed-to-media event organised by the ABA.

The issue of two-factor authentication, which requires two forms of identification, was a major talking point throughout the conference, attendees told ZDNet Australia . National Australia Bank and Bendigo Bank currently offer such security to customers, utilising SMS and password tokens as additional protective measures.

The added layers are meant to combat a continued rise in phishing and cybercrime attempts on bank customers. Some Australian banks have fallen victim to copycat Web sites whereby phishers record the login details of unsuspecting clients.

Microsoft chief security adviser Peter Watson, who attended the conference, said there was concern at consumers' reluctance to conduct transactions online due to the perceived risks.

"They now recognise it's a credibility issue," he said of the banks. "It affects their ability to take more transactions to their customers. It's causing banks costs."

ABA members had realised they were increasingly dependent on the security levels of their customers, according to Watson.

"The banks are almost at a brick wall [stage] with security," he said.

"No matter what we do in terms of ramping up internal security, if consumers don't have the technology to allow [improvements] to occur, there's no point."

Whether two-factor authentication will be adopted industry-wide is unclear, however.

"There was discussion ... as to whether they should go down an individual or industry approach," Watson said.

While some banks have adopted such a system, there was some support for an industry approach, according to Watson.

The possibility of standards development for two-factor authentication was one reason.

The ABA was looking for a strategic, rather than tactical, solution, he said. "There's no point in the banking sector going and addressing two-factor without the support of ISPs and major retail sites."

The conference concluded without major agreement on the way forward. Watson said whether banks will implement their own defences or follow an industry approach remained unresolved.

Some bankers at the event recalled the advent of automatic teller machine systems, said Watson, as an example of the costs to industry such a system might cause.

Another conference presenter, Peter Cassidy, secretary general of the Anti-Phishing Working Group, said mandating two-factor authentication has to be approached with care.

"Saying two-factor is 'it' excludes a number of other approaches that may also be effective," Cassidy told ZDNet Australia .

He expressed confidence that an improved security system would eventually be commonplace across the financial industry.

"Some kind of multi-factor [system] will come forward," he said. "It's on the cards everywhere."

Like this article? Click below to send it to your mobile for free!

Talkback 6 comments

  1. A new innovative technique to help enterprises prevent their customers/employees from falling prey to phishing, pharming, and online fraud. (Green Armor recently introduced its patent-pending technology, Identity Cues). The solution leverag Anonymous -- 26/07/05

    A new innovative technique to help enterprises prevent their customers/employees from
    falling prey to phishing, pharming, and online fraud. (Green Armor recently introduced its patent-pending technology, Identity Cues).

    The solution leverages a unique blend of psychology and technology to
    make obvious to even non-technical and untrained users whether they are communicating with an organization's legitimate web site or with a phony site set up by a criminal. It directly targets the underlying human weakness
    at the root of the phishing problem -- the inability to distinguish between
    two items that look nearly identical -- and does not require deploying complex technologies. As a result, it offers significant advantages over
    earlier anti-phishing technologies -- for all parties involved (users, system administrators, and the organizations implementing the system).

    For example, it is much easier on users: they don't have to download/install
    any software, carry any security devices, register for any services, or
    memorize any extra secrets. There are no extra steps during the login process, and, even if people do not make a conscious effort to use the
    anti-phishing/anti-pharming system, Identity Cues can still be effective at
    protecting them.

    For more information you can visit www.greenarmor.com

  2. Green Armor Solutions looks like an interesting idea. I would try it out if Australian banks and business decided to give it a trial run. Any thing that can help to secure financial sites would be a good thing. If there is no need to install special so Anonymous -- 26/07/05

    Green Armor Solutions looks like an interesting idea. I would try it out if Australian banks and business decided to give it a trial run. Any thing that can help to secure financial sites would be a good thing. If there is no need to install special software or use an endless string of questions and answers to prove your ID and also to prove the site you are visiting is genuine, more power to it. Sounds like a good method as long as phishing sites are also unable to duplicate the Green Armor software.

  3. Reading between the lines of this report I have to wonder what the real agenda of the ABA members was in attending this conference. It certainly doesn't seem to have been to reach agreement regarding customer security. The Banks have had this problem for Anonymous -- 26/07/05

    Reading between the lines of this report I have to wonder what the real agenda of the ABA members was in attending this conference. It certainly doesn't seem to have been to reach agreement regarding customer security. The Banks have had this problem for long enough to have come up with a solution to the problem by now. Customers need to feel confident when doing banking on-line. It's anything but secure at present. I'm not convinced multi level security even with tokens is the answer. It's messy, long winded and expensive for the user.
    Instead, they all appear to have agreed to disagree !!

  4. Hmm, Interesting partial solution to the logon problem suggested by Green Armor. However IMHO it is only a partial solution to the problem and is not easily universally applicable. The banks using SMS, well that pretty weak as well IMHO Anonymous -- 27/07/05

    Hmm,
    Interesting partial solution to the logon problem suggested by Green Armor. However IMHO it is only a partial solution to the problem and is not easily universally applicable.

    The banks using SMS, well that pretty weak as well IMHO and depends on the user having a mobile phone and within range of a mobile service.

    In my experience I have seen a web site run a Java script before entering the banks web site, thereby giving all the visual clues are correct. The Java script would then record the keystrokes and posting them back via port 80. So the method suggested by Green Armor is not 100%. But this doesn't mean dismissing the approach totally, rather its only a partial solution IMHO.

    Fake websites andor web pages are difficult to disprove and will always be an issue.

    The real weakness IMHO is in how the username and password is entered into password field. This technology has remained by and large static over the last 30 odd years and IMHO is due for a major upgrade.

    The biggest issue I see with passwords is KEYLOGGING (Or seeing what the person is pressing when entering the password).

    The solution to KEYLOGGING is at least to
    1. use a "handshake PASSWORD offset algorithm".
    2. virtual random keypads.

    This method is very hard to defeat, because key logging is useless, and a fake website won't be able to crack the password even if they key logging every single keystroke of mouse press or if they mimic the web site exactly.

    The method also makes people looking over you and seeing what your pressing keying useless, because every time you log on your pressing a different set of keys.

    Key loggers that are also attached to the keyboard via hardware are also defeated.

    Like any protection scheme this can also be defeated by repeatedly monitoring of the keystrokes or inspecting the description algorithm, however if the algorithm is changed slightly with a mathematical offset, the complexity rises dramatically making the password almost impossible to decode using mathematical pattern recognition.

    I could go on about how strenghten password security and confuse the hell out of the poor crackers, but that would be telling secrets wouldn't it. :-)

  5. Australia-Bankers wrestle with online security Mr. AT Alishtari, POA and Founder of EDI Secure LLLP, sees the problems nations are having with two factor authentication with offline devices. Are the Australian banks new authentication expanda Anonymous -- 27/07/05

    Australia-Bankers wrestle with online security

    Mr. AT Alishtari, POA and Founder of EDI Secure LLLP, sees the problems nations are having with two factor authentication with offline devices. Are the Australian banks new authentication expandable for being integrated globally since a handshake electronically bank to bank could open up a bank or depositors to cyber mafia attacks all over again.

    None of the major IT companies negotiating licensing both Chinas, Amsterdam, Japan, Germany and other G8 central banks, have a license to use the U.S. Patent owned by EDI Secure LLLP that is building its platform in two factor authentication with an offline device for virtual ID given to it by the USPTO on July 22, 2003 through its single use credit card number ID patent that includes all electronic utilization of the single use with any financial entity inside the U.S.

    The US Chamber of Commerce National Institute of Standard & Technology, NIST, just listed for the Office of Management and Budget as well as for a privacy and security bill going to Congress for implementation in 14 months and for the Senate Cybercrime treaty also under consideration four levels of authentication. The top level four is multi factor authentication with an offline device or wand covered by our patent.

    Obviously, whatever platform is used must link and relate to the U.S. treaty and NIST rules as well as honor the Buy American laws implemented recently by the Homeland Security. EDI Secure LLLP can be contacted at edisecure@att.net.

  6. If you would like an online demonstration of Identity Cues you can go to http://www.greenarmor.com and click "Free Evaluation" BTW: There is technology within the system that would stop the attack described by Josep Anonymous -- 28/07/05

    If you would like an online demonstration of Identity Cues you can go to

    http://www.greenarmor.com

    and click "Free Evaluation"

    BTW: There is technology within the system that would stop the attack described by Joseph Wojciechowski of a site forwarding requests to the Identity Cues system on the real site.

Add your opinion


Latest Videos

Sponsored content

Power Centre - Content from our premier sponsors

Blogs

  • Renai LeMay Australian Govt funds IT start-ups
    This week Australia's Federal Government announced it had allocated $3.6 million in funding to 57 local research projects so that they could be commercialised, with many of them being web or IT-related start-ups.
  • Array Google should come clean on datacentres
    It's nice that Google says it has put an effort into making its datacentres more energy efficient, but the search giant's pledges won't mean much until it discloses just how many of the beasties it's actually running.
  • Array US shows what OPEL could have been
    Sprint's WiMAX roll-out in Baltimore will prove the Australian government's decision to worm its way out of the Opel WiMAX contract was a short-sighted, and ultimately damaging, political stunt that has benefited nobody.
  • More blogs »

Tags

Back to top

Featured