Apple slams door on Windows themes

There are some big differences between Mac OS X and Windows XP, and apparently Apple Computer doesn't want any blurring of the lines between the two.

The Mac maker has asked Web site ThemeXP to stop offering for download two "desktop themes" that let computer owners customise the look of Windows XP so that it resembles the Mac OS X. Desktop themes are small programs that allow people to personalise their wallpaper, icons, windows and so on to reflect their particular passion--be it a certain pop star, the entire Milky Way or an operating system.

"We just felt it was a violation of our copyrights and intellectual property and we requested that they remove" the themes, an Apple representative said Friday.

ThemeXP said on Wednesday that it pulled "EclipseOSX v4.40" and "MacOSX Aqua 3.2" after Apple claimed they were in violation of copyrights.

"As much as we enjoy long and expensive lawsuits against mega-corporations, we decided to comply with their notice of infringement and take down both of the themes we previously hosted," ThemeXP said in a note posted to its Web site.

Windows XP and Mac OS X both made their debuts last year, leading to plenty of comparisons.

Apple has made similar moves in the past when programs have attempted to mimic the look of Apple products. Linux users were upset by a similar move two years ago.

Interestingly, another Mac OS X-inspired theme on ThemeXP, dubbed "RottenApple," appears to remain on the site.

Advertisement

Talkback 5 comments

    Good on them! Microsoft has co ...Jill H Gates III -- 18/02/02

    Good on them!

    Microsoft has copied quite enough from Apple (and others) in the past.

    It’s about time someone put a stop to that, and we learned to give credit where credit’s due.

    Jill Gates, ThemeXP is not run ...Jack Gates -- 18/02/02

    Jill Gates, ThemeXP is not run by Microsoft, therefore it is not Microsoft doing the copying.

    gawd what is this world coming ...Anonymous -- 19/02/02

    gawd what is this world coming to...

    hmmmm....first time I've ever heard a theme getting pulled because it looked too much like an operating system. next thing you know an icon that has an apple in it will be copyrightable by Apple themselves. how ridiculous...

    isn't imitation the sincerest form of flattery?

    just for Apple, I will load a copy of this theme onto my system, use it, make fun of it, and then dump it without having to spend the $3000 to get to FEEL the Apple experience. Feel this Apple...

    time is better spent making Apples affordable, not scapegoating around.

    Childish ranting and raving. G ...Stephen M. Kuhn -- 21/02/02

    Childish ranting and raving.
    Get over it. It's a THEME. What about those people that are forced to work on a Windows machine that own a Mac? OR vice-versa? It seems the only intellectual property in this particular arena is silliness. "Mine!""Mine!". Like children. It should be taken as a compliment. It should be a reflect to Apple of their work. Unfortunately, it is turning into a reflection of Apple's consistent "It's mine and no one else can have it" attitude. Just like the Mac clones. Great idea. Made heaps of sales, but forced out of the market. Is that truly competitive business mentality, or anal-retentive rantings?

    Hmmm... it might be an over-th ...Anonymous -- 04/03/02

    Hmmm... it might be an over-the-top reaction by Apple, but the fact still remains that it might look like OS X but it will still run like Windoze. It reminds me of all those wannabe kit cars that were out a few years ago that looked like exotic sports cars but were just fibreglass shells on a VW chassis.

Add your opinion

Latest Videos

Sponsored content

Power Centre - Content from our premier sponsors

Blogs

  • Phil Dobbie A guide to the future of the internet
    Last week we looked at the history of the internet in Australia. It's been around for 20 years and changed our lives in so many ways. Imagine what it could do given another 20 years.
  • Array Carelessness busts Linux security
    No operating system can ever properly protect a computer from trojans as long as users continue to do silly things. Just because Linux is immune to your standard drive-by viruses it does not mean that it can escape trojan horses.
  • Array Sun shining on Ajnaware
    Graham Dawson talks about the future of iPhone app development and augmented reality.
  • More blogs »

Tags

Back to top

Featured