Telstra 'surprised' by broadband activists

With planned protests, proposed full-page advertisements in the metropolitan press and a proliferation of Web sites all protesting against Telstra's broadband caps, the telco giant admits it hadn't anticipated users would display their anger in this way.

Following Telstra's recently announced restrictions on broadband data downloads to three gigabytes a month, customer anger "has manifested itself differently than we expected," a Telstra representative told ZDNet.

Telstra claims that it imposed downloading limits due to the five percent of customers deemed "excessive" users who affect the service for other users.

Only 10 percent of respondents to a ZDNet Survey believe Telstra needs to clamp down on excessive usage, with 90 percent -- or 1386 readers -- claiming Telstra has shot itself in the foot over its decision to restrict broadband Internet use.

Telstra said at the time that it anticipated "excessive users would be angry".

However, "we thought there'd be a few emails," Telstra's spokesperson acknowledged in an interview this week.

Instead, Web sites devoted to the broadband culture are rallying support and boast a range of ways in which disgruntled Telstra broadband users can respond to the change of policy.

One group is organising street protests in Melbourne and Sydney and another site -- www.sitehappens.com.au -- aims to raise money for a full-page colour press advertisement, objecting to Telstra's move.

www.ozquake.com is encouraging customers to hit the telco where it hurts and pull their business out of Telstra.

The site provides users with a cut and paste email to Telstra CEO Ziggy Switkowski, giving him the dollar figure that their withdrawal of business will mean.

"At a time that Ziggy's saying he's concerned about market share and profits it seems a bit of a backward move to limit a medium that's growing," the site's webmaster Blair Ryan told ZDNet.

"It's an economic message we're trying to send."

Telstra maintains that whilst there are those voicing anger, a lot of customers are "looking forward to having a better service".

"Whilst there's this angry response, the percentage of people who've repeatedly made comments are probably around what we expected," Telstra's representative said.

Advertisement

Talkback 17 comments

    If Telstra were a company with ...Anonymous -- 22/06/01

    If Telstra were a company with a clue, let alone any idea of service, then they would see the uncapped broadband users as a market that they can sell a needed service to, instead of the Fawlty Towers approach that people who actually USE broadband are causing problems.

    There's a need, and people to pay for it: supply the service and make some money.

    The better service that the Te ...Anonymous -- 22/06/01

    The better service that the Telstra rep refers to cannot possibly come by cutting back on service. Obviously, like so many other Telstra employees he is quoting from FAQ sheet put together by some lame brain within the network and has no idea or is not allowed to voice his ideas on what the cutbacks mean to loyal customers. Oh there's a word that Telstra would not have in **** Sheets, LOYAL.

    An engineering cockup. The 256 ...Keith Styles -- 23/06/01

    An engineering cockup. The 256/64 or 512/128 thruput cap tells them exactly how much bandwidth is needed to provide users with a decent broadbacnd service. Blaming 5% of users for their own design deficiency is an excuse.

    We need more people to go to t ...Anonymous -- 23/06/01

    We need more people to go to the following site and pledge some money. These anti Telstra ads in the paper can't be done for free. So try and make a difference and pledge however much you can, even if its only $10-$20.

    http://www.sitehappens.com.au/mydotcom/

    After 11 days of "unlimit ...David Morgan -- 25/06/01

    After 11 days of "unlimited" access, my contract is changed without my knowledge or permission and they think I will just agree with that. NO WAY!
    As someone that had the superb Optus service until moving to a Unit, I can say that Bigpond's service and support is well below par, something closer to an internet startup company working out of someone's garage.
    Wake up Telstra, because Im not paying your bills any longer.

    Seriously 3gb a month on broad ...Anonymous -- 25/06/01

    Seriously 3gb a month on broadband is a joke i pay $89 a month to be entitled to 100mb a day that is just crazy.If telstra wants to be fair at least make it 6gb so it takes the pressure of its customers to not have to worry if they go over the 3gb limit wich in reality is done quite easily by just surfing the net and getting some streamong media.6gb would make it alot fairer and even 6gb is still a joke but atleast makes the internet more enjoyable.

    The 3 Gig limit is so so so pa ...Anonymous -- 25/06/01

    The 3 Gig limit is so so so pathetic.
    What else is there to say.
    Politicians, business people, anyone with clout please help us.

    3gb cap for a better service!? ...Anonymous -- 26/06/01

    3gb cap for a better service!? From what I can tell, my service has been slower than ever.

    And what's the point of broadband if you can't use it to it's full potential?

    It's like getting a Ferrari and then being told you can only go 40km/hr in it.

    Isn't this just classic `bait ...Anonymous -- 26/06/01

    Isn't this just classic `bait advertising'? I mean Exhibit One: "Unlimited subject to AUP"
    Exhibit Two: "Constant connection to internet"

    The constant outages, speed cap and now download cap indicate to me that Telstra sold a service which it had NO INTENTION of providing. Instead of providing a network as promised in the `baiting' stages, they failed to upgrade an outdated network and blamed customers for its performance and outages.

    The ACCC MUST act in what is a clear cut example of bait advertising, misleading and deceptive conduct, unconscionable conducts, abuse of market power (read the Trade Practices Act 1974).

    If they get away with this, then basically the ACCC is just a bag of wind.

    Well I've just cancelled my Bi ...Anonymous -- 26/06/01

    Well I've just cancelled my Bigpond Cable and have also pursuaded my work and family to move over to Optus for local calls. Telstra are not getting anymore of my money, this is the last straw!

    Interesting. People are saying ...Anonymous -- 26/06/01

    Interesting. People are saying to Telstra, that they're looking forward to better service after the cap. I say what I have always said, for me, Telstra broadband has always operated at it's maximum rate. I get constant 53k downloads, from everywhere. How is my service going to improve?

    And another thing that everyone in the media seems to have missed is this. Telstra's 3GB cap is per household, so us poor souls that pay for legitimate extra users (taking our ADSL account from 89 to 111 a month) do not have any compensation for these extra users. That's right, We get 1GB per computer per month. 3GB would be "just" bearable for us in this house if it was per computer, but since it's per household, we have no choice but to move to Optus. Great business sense Telstra, offend your customers and throw them away.

    Telstra like to plug their cab ...Anonymous -- 26/06/01

    Telstra like to plug their cable/adsl services as up to 100 times faster than a modem connection. So why not give us 100 times the bandwidth. I wouldn't complain at around 30 gig a month.

    I have been using Cable for ov ...Anonymous -- 27/06/01

    I have been using Cable for over 18 months and I have constantly had my service interrupted for up to 2 months after rain one week. It took 2 hours to fix although it took them 1 and half months to acknowledge the problem was external hardware and not my computer.

    I have received compensation for this but this was due to my kicking and screaming, no offers from Telstra, that is too customer friendly and they may lose unwanted money :-)

    Unfortunately I am unable to receive Optus cable although I will at my first opportunity move house to an area where Optus has been setup and immediately disconnect from Telstra's service.

    I can't believe 10% of users are causing problems yet approximately 90% of users are complaining, tell me where the logic is? The way I see it, they are only getting $72.55 out of us, and no matter what we do per month, that is all they can get. By implementing a cap, they can milk us for more money.

    Sorry Telstra, but my time has come to say "so long, farewell, aufweidersein goodbye" :-)

    How dare they change the rules ...Michael Liapakis -- 30/06/01

    How dare they change the rules of the game after they already have me by the balls. You have my money Telstra and a signature on a binding contract that covers your arse and I am powerless to pull out without having to throw more good money at you. You have punished the early adopters of broadband and now their loyalty is gone forever!!

    dont worry i have seeked egal ...seth snipper -- 02/07/01

    dont worry i have seeked egal advice and i have been told that i should be able to change my contract to 3 month instead of 18 month because of some clause that telstra used to change there's well we can use that same clause to change our contract.
    my opinion is that you should all do as i have done and change your contract terms

    Who's pissing in who's pocket. ...Keith Styles -- 09/07/01

    Who's pissing in who's pocket. The ACCC, the Ombudsman, the Minister for Communications have all treated "US" the customer, the tax payer, the voter with total & absolute distain. Enough is enough. If the business community who are affected by the arrogant behavour of the people who are supposed to be protecting us, cannot muster enough energy to fight this nonsense, then they deserve to suffer the consequences of poor service and ever increasing costs

    Something most users are not a ...Anonymous -- 29/07/01

    Something most users are not aware of is if you ahve more than one account you are still limited to 3 gigs download. Eventhough i pay for the 2 extra accounts i still have a 3 gig limit as you have guessed i have cancelled my 2 extra accounts

Add your opinion

Latest Videos

Sponsored content

Power Centre - Content from our premier sponsors

Blogs

  • Renai LeMay How reliable is IP telephony?
    Have you ever heard a weird kind of hissing, crackling or popping noise when calling someone on an IP telephony line? How rare is the phenomenon these days?
  • Array Forget the NBN, 100Mbps is already here
    Telstra and TransACT will shortly begin offering 100Mbps broadband to many customers. By moving early, the companies have not only raised the bar for Australia's broadband services, but thrown down a challenge to a government that now faces increased pressure to deliver the NBN as promised.
  • Array IT: Govt's cost-cutting bitch
    The government needs to stop looking at IT as a necessary evil or the place to remove costs when the Treasurer comes calling.
  • More blogs »

Tags

Back to top

Featured