Simple security flaw poses threat to XP

By Patrick Gray
17 February 2003 02:50 PM
Tags: security, windows, xp, gray, adminstrator, patrick, attack, physical
A simple security flaw in the Windows XP operating system allows attackers with physical access to a Windows XP machine to obtain unrestricted administrator privileges by using the Windows 2000 Recovery Console utility.

The attacker simply puts the Windows 2000 CD into the drive and boots up the target system with it. When prompted, they select the recovery console option and immediately gain access to a command prompt without being queried for a password.

The attacker can then read and write data to and from the hard disk, including administrator data.

Although the flaw relies on physical access to be exploited, it is sure to cause headaches with network administrators enforcing a "user accounts only" policy in a corporate environment.

It has always been possible for attackers with physical access to a system, especially one with a bootable CD-ROM, to compromise it with relative ease by using other bootable CD's such as BiatchUX, the popular Linux based forensic recovery tool. However the ease of exploitation of this glitch is sure to cause concern among system administrators.

Security consultant Daniel Lewkovitz says administrators can minimize their exposure to these types of "physical access" vulnerabilities by taking a few simple measures.

"Any physical access to a machine gives a would-be attacker access to data such as passwords, and allows them to use bootable floppies or CDs," he said.

"All of these vulnerabilities can be reduced by strongly controlling physical access to the machine. Floppy drive locks and locking rack cabinets are a good start," he said.

He says that disabling the boot function on CD-ROMs and setting a BIOS password makes it much more difficult for attackers to exploit this vulnerability, but does stress that an attacker with physical access to a machine has many methods of attack available to them.

Windows 2000 is not affected by this issue.

Advertisement

Talkback 5 comments

    Talk about overkill by the med ...Paul Snedden -- 17/02/03

    Talk about overkill by the media. So what if a "hacker" can boot up a WinXP box with a Win2k recovery console. Isn't that the "hacker" got physical access to the machine in the first place FAR more important?

    While Paul Sneddon's comments ...Anonymous -- 18/02/03

    While Paul Sneddon's comments may have merit in some theoretical locations, they seem a little niave in the "real world".

    Many networks have (and must have) accessible PCs for the simple operation of the business of the location. To ensure adequate protection against being tampered with (such as the installation of password capture programs, etc.), they rely on the security of the login.

    What is startling in this case is not that it is possible to access the machine through a boot medium (hey - no surprise there) but that a Microsoft operating system rescue facility provides access without any request for password.

    Why do you need W2K recovery C ...Anonymous -- 18/02/03

    Why do you need W2K recovery CD? You can use one of the many Linux-based system-on-a-floppy or system-on-a-CD systems to do the same thing. (They all will mount pretty well any filesystem, including NTFS, FAT or Apple's HPFS). Or if you have a screw driver you can take the hard-disk and mount it as a 2nd drive on any other computer that you have nady. Short of encrypting the data, having unsecured physical access to the system or storage device always is going to leave your data vulnerable.

    Move along....there is no news here.

    While Paul Adams' comments may ...Anonymous -- 18/02/03

    While Paul Adams' comments may have some neglegible impact in his fantasy "real-world", the truth is that the only way to secure data on a computer system is use encrytion for sensitive data (either on a per-file or file system level), or by securing access to that machine. No matter what you do, physical access to a machine will always make the task of compromising that system so much easier. This security flaw is laughable to say the least.

    Schools have always had a prob ...Anonymous -- 18/02/03

    Schools have always had a problem with things like this. One of the best solutions I have seen is to use a "Zero" card in the PC. As soon as the PC is rebooted things go back to the way they were origionaly.

    You can use any boot CD you want, so far I have never seen anyone break it without physically altering the machine.

    We used to use PC lockout too which was really good when things were DOS based, but lacked strength and usability when things became Windows 95+ based.

Add your opinion

Latest Videos

Sponsored content

Power Centre - Content from our premier sponsors

Blogs

  • Chris Duckett Get extensions going in Firefox, redux
    Previously on Null Pointer we looked at getting extensions working in Firefox betas, and that was great until the fine folks at Firefox changed their minds.
  • Array How reliable is IP telephony?
    Have you ever heard a weird kind of hissing, crackling or popping noise when calling someone on an IP telephony line? How rare is the phenomenon these days?
  • Array Forget the NBN, 100Mbps is already here
    Telstra and TransACT will shortly begin offering 100Mbps broadband to many customers. By moving early, the companies have not only raised the bar for Australia's broadband services, but thrown down a challenge to a government that now faces increased pressure to deliver the NBN as promised.
  • More blogs »

Tags

Back to top

Featured