NetBank pilot glitches anger users

Glitches in the Commonwealth Bank's (CBA) pilot of an upgraded NetBank Internet banking service are infuriating users.

Several users -- none of whom were prepared to be named -- complained the CBA switched them to the new service several hours before receiving an e-mail notifying them of the upgrade. The delay made some suspect NetBank's security had been compromised.

Another user contacted ZDNet Australia   following publication of our initial article to complain the upgrade changed access rights to the service.

"We have two people in the office allowed to access our account," said a representative of the business. "The second account lost its right to transfer money out of the account. But they had set up all the transfers to pay our staff their wages. Those transfers were cancelled by the new system and we had to re-enter them all manually".

CBA help desk staff, however, could not provide assistance. "The help desk couldn't help at all," the representative -- who also declined to be named -- said. "Until I escalated it to our relationship manager they wouldn't do anything for me".

Other glitches are also marring the trial. The system occasionally produces an error message saying it is illegal to use a browser's forward or back buttons in NetBank. The error occurs even when users have not used the forward or back buttons, freezes the service and leaves even the Exit button inoperable. Links to the site's "Help Guide" have also proved disappointing: the page they refer to says "Sorry, the page that you are trying to access is temporarily unavailable or no longer exists".

A CBA spokesperson said on Tuesday afternoon problems like these were the reason the bank conducted pilots of upgraded services. However, by Wednesday afternoon, the CBA was yet to provide detailed information on the performance difficulties.

Advertisement

Talkback 7 comments

    Just another example of how th ...Anonymous -- 06/04/05

    Just another example of how the incompetent administrators in a large company force their illogical policies on the general public.

    These people (myself included) ...Anonymous -- 06/04/05

    These people (myself included) voluntarily requested to be part of the trial. If you've asked to be a tester, then you shouldnt be complaining if you find problems. Report them to the developer, find out if there is a work-around, and wait for a fix. Don't go crying foul to the media.

    As someone who had money taken ...Anonymous -- 06/04/05

    As someone who had money taken from their NetBank account, it worries me that the new system will not stop ID theft! How is two IDs going to stop kepstroke logging? How long will it be safe for, 3 yrs? Yeah right!

    In response to Anonymous quest ...Anonymous -- 06/04/05

    In response to Anonymous question "how will this stop keyloggers" - it won't. No steps can be taken by any server-side software to stop you from running an application on the client side. If you did, it would be called a backdoor, and would in itself be a security vulnerability. It is the client's responsibilty to ensure the security of their own machine. If they can't do that, perhaps they shouldn't use internet services which require a secure client? You can't blame Telstra for an illegal wire-tap on your home phone, and likewise, you can't blame your bank for an illegal keylogger on your home PC. The message here is secure your platform, or don't use services which expose your information.

    In response to a previous comm ...Anonymous -- 08/04/05

    In response to a previous comment that testers should be prepared for problems I must agree. HOWEVER, the testing environment should not and must not interfere with normal business activities and operations of the testers. Furthermore, the problems described do not sound as if the system was ready for beta (or pre-release) testing.

    This is clearly and example of extremely poor test planning and risk management on the part of the Bank's IT group and developers. Having built major systems for Enterprises, test planning and risk management were always a significant activity of the development team, as was the identification and cl****ification of test environments and scenarios. We always included our testers in pre-test planning to communicate the processes that were to be tested, any changes from extant practices and limitations that could be expected.

    During testing, testers would be isolated in a sandbox so that their SOPs would not be interrupted and special help desk personnel were ****igned and trained to respond to calls for ****istance from the test group(s).

    These are just plain common sense tactics, especially if you really care about your customers and users. Whoever was responsible for this rather public example of ineptitude should be looking for a job in another field of endeavour. And the Bank, as well as all enterprises, should now seriously review its attitude towards Web applications and take a more professional, realistic and considered approach.

    ZDNet Australia should get its ...Anonymous -- 08/04/05

    ZDNet Australia should get its act together!

    I just posted a response only to find that the system had rather incompetently performed some sort of amateurish (half-arsed) censorship of my submission by blanking out occurrences of the US reference to the human posterior or type of burro/mule.

    I wish to add to this report, ...Anonymous -- 12/04/05

    I wish to add to this report, that recently someone got in to my account and illegedly transferred $2,000 to their own account with the description "$2,000.00 Donation".

    I've been with Netbank ever since it started, and have never had any fraud against me, till now, soon after I started using the new Netbank Pilot service.

    What's going on these days??

Add your opinion

Latest Videos

Sponsored content

Power Centre - Content from our premier sponsors

Blogs

  • David Braue All I want for Xmas is Telstra pricing
    Five consecutive days without broadband has led me to what seemed at the time to be an act of desperation: contemplating signing up for Telstra's 100Mbps cable modem service.
  • Array Sick of broken tender sites
    Some of the state governments desperately need to invest in more user-friendly tender sites so that looking for information on government tenders doesn't have to be a game of blind man's bluff.
  • Array Cyberwar: What is it good for?
    In this week's episode, Cyberwar. What is Australia's place in the world of digital warfare? What are the implications for the NBN?
  • More blogs »

Tags

Back to top

Featured