Microsoft poised for Australian XBox Live mod chip crackdown

By Andrew Colley
26 November 2002 09:20 AM
Tags: modchip, copyright, piracy, coding, xbox, accc, live, region-coding
Microsoft Australia's regional XBox office is issuing strong indications it plans to mimic its United States headquarters' policy of penalising XBox owners that use mod chips in their consoles by refusing them access to XBox Live.

XBox Australia's regional director, Alan Bowman, told ZDNet Australia   the local arm of XBox Live would model its service on the North American version closely and that Microsoft Australia would protect the XBox platform's intellectual property "as much as possible".

However, Bowman stopped short of confirming or denying whether the ban policy would be followed in Australia.

Bowman added that Australian XBox Live users would use the same Seattle-based server that currently detects mod chips in US consoles to gain access to XBox game servers that Microsoft planned to disperse internationally.

The modification chips that have motivated the ban in the US circumvent measures built-in to XBox consoles to prevent them accessing games and DVDs that have been illegally copied or carry foreign region coding or include customised software.

"The bigger issue for us -- the common thread through all of this -- is making sure that we not only protect our own intellectual property but the intellectual property of all software developers on the live platform," said Bowman.

The practice is creating waves among US-based XBox enthusiasts. Owners of "chipped" XBox consoles have flocked XBox hacking enthusiast sites to report that they are unable to access the XBox Live service.

Microsoft's global headquarters is yet to respond to questioning as to whether following the policy would run foul of the Australian Competition and Consumer Commission (ACCC). The ACCC has to date indicated a preparedness to go in to bat for consumers who have introduced the mod chips to products.

The ACCC intervened earlier this year in a Federal Court case to prevent Sony Computer Entertainment Australia (SCEA) have anti-circumvention provisions of the Copyright Act interpreted to include mod chips used to bypass copyright protection measures built in to PlayStation2 consoles. Judge Sackville came down on the side of the ACCC.

The ACCC told ZDNet Australia   it had some reservations about the importation of the Microsoft mod chip policy.

"As to whether Microsoft can refuse to deal with those consumers who have had their XBox consoles chipped depends on whether there are any indications given to the consumer prior to purchase that they will not be able to avail themselves of certain services if they use the equipment in a certain manner," said a spokesperson for the ACCC.

The ACCC has not made its position clear on whether the legal arguments it presented in the case of the PlayStation2 mod chips would be just as relevant to the XBox. However it does have some concerns about how Microsoft's attitude to mod chips might impact on its XBox warranty policy.

"We would be concerned if XBox were refusing to honor the statutory warranties simply because a consumer has had their console chipped," said the spokesperson

SCEA is currently appealing Judge Sackville's decision before a full bench of the Federal Court. Arguably, SCEA and Microsoft share a common interest in wanting the use of mod chips curbed but for now the latter is keeping its distance from the existing case.

"Sony is running its own case on this, Microsoft stands by its own protection of its own intellectual property," said Bowman.


News in context
Visit this page for ZDNet Australia's comprehensive coverage of Microsoft's XBox news.

Advertisement

Talkback 8 comments

    This is pure discrimination. T ...Anonymous -- 26/11/02

    This is pure discrimination. The ACCC and Federal courts have ruled that mod-chips allow the playing of O/S & imported games, and as the owner of the console are entitled to use it as we please. These Draconian tactics should not be tollerated. What about privacy concerns? Did M$ ask your permission to gather info about you thru their x-box?

    Microsoft have no right to do ...Anonymous -- 26/11/02

    Microsoft have no right to do this on previously sold XBox models, however I believe they have updated the EUA so that they are legally able to do it on new XBoxs.

    When the XBox was sold originaly the End User Agreement stated that you could not modify or reverse engineer any of the software in the XBox, however that has since been updated to cover hardware. This means that new XBoxs covered by the new agreement can not legally have their hardware modified.

    The question remains though, can Mircosoft legally add this to their EUA? If I buy a car, I've never read anything that says I can only use it as long as I don't add Alloy Wheels or a spoiler...

    This is good that Microsoft is ...Charles Tisse -- 27/11/02

    This is good that Microsoft is doing this so those good for nothing hackers can stay the hell out of Xbox Live.

    I think there is a modchip which you can switch on and off though, and that should be able to allow you to play on Xbox Live.

    good for nothing hackers? oh p ...A@ron -- 27/11/02

    good for nothing hackers? oh please. if i want to play a game or dvd from japan or anywhere else in the world I should be given that right. My PS2 is chipped for this exact reason, does that make me a "good for nothing hacker"? The courts said it was ok and that makes it law so i am perfectly within my legal rights thank you very much.

    This is tottaly against allo t ...Anonymous -- 28/11/02

    This is tottaly against allo that gaming stands for, placing this ban on modchips doesn't allow us the full range of gaming input so either we can't play other games or we casn't use the ethernet it's just not right i thinkn that Microsoft has just taken away one of the most important features of the console, we don't want small controllerws we don't want skateboards we want to be able to use every game and DVD we can.

    Exercise your rights as consum ...Anonymous -- 29/11/02

    Exercise your rights as consumers -
    DON'T SUPPORT M$ - DON'T BUY INTO IT!

    Product Activation, Media Centre, X-Box hacking, where will it end? Not until M$ is in every house, in every business, on every TV..
    George Orwell was about 20-25 years off...

    M$ is a virus, a plague..

    Did you even read all of what ...Charles Tisse -- 29/11/02

    Did you even read all of what I said?? If you want you can get a modchip that you can turn off whenever you want to connect to Xbox Live. If you still want to argue even though you are given this choice, then you are no better than those good for nothing hackers who would just ruin Xbox Live if given the chance.

    Microsoft is doing the right thing here. If you want hackers and cheaters galore and a subpar online gaming experience, then stick to playing games online on the PC or PS2.

    Why do you actually agree on x ...Ice2k3 -- 28/01/03

    Why do you actually agree on xbox having this modchip protection scanning?? its not right.. some people do actually use modchips for legal purposes actually alot of people do like parents that own an xbox but have little kids that scratch up the games they copy the games that they originally own and let the kids play them.

    Whats the big deal anyway is microsoft that money crazy? Hell, like i said they are just shutting out the people that actually do use the modchips for a good cause i definetly wouldnt want to have to go out and buy a new game the same game again because it is scratched up and wont play the damn things are to expensive too do that.

Add your opinion

Latest Videos

Sponsored content

Power Centre - Content from our premier sponsors

Blogs

  • Suzanne Tindal IT: Govt's cost-cutting bitch
    The government needs to stop looking at IT as a necessary evil or the place to remove costs when the Treasurer comes calling.
  • Array Can complaints on mobile content be cut?
    On 1 July this year the new Mobile Premium Services Code was introduced. It sounds like it's had a good impact, but is it enough?
  • Array NZ farmers: Bleating about broadband
    As we know, farmers are such bleaters. They bleat as much as the four-legged woolly things in their paddocks. If it's not the weather, it's the strength of the dollar! Nothing is ever right. Likewise with rural broadband.
  • More blogs »

Tags

Back to top

Featured