GTA 3 -- Silenced and Censored?

A furore has erupted over the censoring of a Playstation 2 game by Australian officials. Grand Theft Auto 3 was initially given the Refused Classification tag by the Office of Film and Literature Classification (OFLC), meaning it is illegal to go on sale in this country.

It's alleged, however, that a local games publisher has packaged the game with an -MA15+" rating in order to capitalise on sales of a game that has taken the world by storm.

News came to light today of a popular Playstation 2 game being pulled from distribution due to certain aspects of its content constituting "sexual violence", according to the Office of Film & Literature Classification (OFLC). The game itself primarily involves a criminal career grounded in heinous and wanton acts of violence, involving drug trafficking, mass-murder, road rage and assassination of Police personnel.

Grand Theft Auto 3, published in Australia by Take 2 Interactive, has been selling at retail outlets for several weeks under the classification MA15+. However, the OFLC maintains it gave an entirely different rating for the title -- a classification of "RC", meaning Refused Classification, dated to the 28th of November 2001. According to the Guidelines For The Classification of Computer Games, published by the OFLC, "Material so classified may not be sold, hired, exhibited, displayed, demonstrated or advertised.". Hence, the game must be removed from public availability, and in fact should never have reached the marketplace.

Apparently the game allows for players to solicit the services of prostitutes by picking them up in a car, then afterwards players are able to kill the prostitute character and take money that was in that character's possession. According to Trish Flanagan of the OFLC, the classification was declared because "the depictions of sexual violence exceeded the guidelines for an MA15+ rating."

The game's alleged error in manufacturing -- leading to the erroneous MA15+ rating on the packaging - could lead to serious legal repercussions. Ms Flanagan elaborated: "there are quite severe enforcement implications," for deliberate defiance of the act. But she was quick to separate the OFLC from the pursuit of justice, explaining that: "The OFLC does not do any enforcement. We can only advise, take an educative role or make recommendations,".

When asked the OFLC's opinion on whether the game had been deliberately sold illegally with the incorrect MA15+ rating, she stated that this was "that was not the case, as far as we are aware,"

The publishers of the game, Take 2 Interactive, declined to comment due to their submission of a request for a second opinion from the Classification Review Board, a separate body to the OFLC. ZDNet and GameSpot Australia was told that this second review could take "a week or two", due to the Classification Review Board's status as a loose collection of freelance advisers who are not employed full-time in their special capacity.

Strangely enough it seems that the rest of the game's activities such as drug-running, murdering innocent civilians, killing police officers, running down pedestrians, drive-by gangland shootings and causing massively destructive automobile accidents are all quite acceptable within the guidelines of an MA15+ rating for computer games.


Like this article? Click below to send it to your mobile for free!

Talkback 20 comments

  1. Thats so f**king stupid. The game wasn't supposed to be sold to kids, but that doesn't mean adults shouldn't be able to have some fun... and take out a couple of annoying looking pigs. I bet the censorship board people are having so much fun playing GTAII Anonymous -- 09/12/01

    Thats so f**king stupid. The game wasn't supposed to be sold to kids, but that doesn't mean adults shouldn't be able to have some fun... and take out a couple of annoying looking pigs. I bet the censorship board people are having so much fun playing GTAIII right now...

  2. Ok Fine make it R+ Adults Only But don't try and stop it or you will inevitably open a black market for this game. anon -- 10/12/01

    Ok Fine make it R+ Adults Only
    But don't try and stop it or you will inevitably open a black market for this game.

  3. I hate it, I really wanted this game! I bought my PS2, about a week ago... I still dont have any games!!! Cause GT3 is sold out everywhere. and GTA3 is banner... Im not happy JAN! Geoff -- 10/12/01

    I hate it, I really wanted this game!

    I bought my PS2, about a week ago... I still dont have any games!!! Cause GT3 is sold out everywhere. and GTA3 is banner...

    Im not happy JAN!

  4. Any game that has elements that link sex and murder/violence, should not be stocked on the shelves of computer game stores/department stores. The game should remove any link between the two acts and then be remarketed with the MA15+ rating. David Williams -- 10/12/01

    Any game that has elements that link sex and murder/violence, should not be stocked on the shelves of computer game stores/department stores.

    The game should remove any link between the two acts and then be remarketed with the MA15+ rating.

  5. "Ok Fine make it R+ Adults Only But don't try and stop it or you will inevitably open a black market for this game." Sorry to tell you this, but Computer games are rated differently to movies and videos. There is no such thing as Anonymous -- 10/12/01

    "Ok Fine make it R+ Adults Only
    But don't try and stop it or you will inevitably open a black market for this game."

    Sorry to tell you this, but Computer games are rated differently to movies and videos. There is no such thing as a R rated computer game. It goes from M15+ to RC. If it can't get a M rating it can't be sold. This is a issue of concern to many Australians, and is also of concern due to the blending of technology with DVDs. It is possible for a DVD movie to have enough computer content to be classified as software, and then be no longer be able to be released because it can't fit under the reduced catagories.
    The inconsistancies between the two rating systems is ridiculous.

  6. This violence that debass the value of human life and morals does belong in our society. I imagine those producing this are solely doing so for profit. Perhaps next they'll bring out a "game" supporting the death of innocent people by terrorists Anonymous -- 10/12/01

    This violence that debass the value of human life and morals does belong in our society. I imagine those producing this are solely doing so for profit. Perhaps next they'll bring out a "game" supporting the death of innocent people by terrorists.

  7. Censorship is the real evil of society. It is a way for governments and religions to keep control of their ‘sheep’. I will not stand for people that won’t let me view the movies, play the games or listen to the music that I want to enjoy. I ag Anonymous -- 10/12/01

    Censorship is the real evil of society. It is a way for governments and religions to keep control of their ‘sheep’.
    I will not stand for people that won’t let me view the movies, play the games or listen to the music that I want to enjoy.
    I agree that it may not be appropriate for young children but that is up to the parents to decide.

  8. Why be surprised. The OFCL & our stupid Federal Government treat us ALL as children. If they were to treat the adults as adults, that would be the same as saying we have intelligence...NEVER.!!! The law's an **** when it attempts to regulate, ban Keith Styles -- 10/12/01

    Why be surprised. The OFCL & our stupid Federal Government treat us ALL as children. If they were to treat the adults as adults, that would be the same as saying we have intelligence...NEVER.!!!
    The law's an **** when it attempts to regulate, ban or censor individual behavour, which has no impact on other people. The people who should be protecting children are their PARENTS.
    In real life, as distinct from the unreal world of politicions children will circumvent all their efforts to censor material. Childrens' curiosity has no bounds.
    Playing games,using the Internet or watching films/DVD's/VCR's are all examples of unnecessary restriction by "know it all" dogooders, imposing their own moral standards on others.

  9. GTA3 Available on Morpheus. To all the die hard GTA fans, a full working version of GTA3 is available for download from Morpheus. Search for "GTA 3" and sownload the 190MB version. It works 100%. Anonymous -- 13/12/01

    GTA3 Available on Morpheus.
    To all the die hard GTA fans, a full working version of GTA3 is available for download from Morpheus. Search for "GTA 3" and sownload the 190MB version. It works 100%.

  10. to bad for MA15+ =R18Adults only, or i would so apparently uneducatedly assume. obviously the classification body is FAR more intelligent than I, and for this reason have decided to forgoe the sensible and perfectly legitimate concept of labell Anonymous -- 13/12/01

    to bad for MA15+ =R18Adults only, or i would so apparently uneducatedly assume.

    obviously the classification body is FAR more intelligent than I, and for this reason have decided to forgoe the sensible and perfectly legitimate concept of labelling a game with a R18+ rating,

    obviously, the classification body has already compenstaed for the blow out in transactions in the highly evident Computer game black market whcich operates so obviously in every metropolis. And furthermore,

    obvliously the regulation body has assumed that gamers around the country will have no problems with the RC rating, and we will understand their non-existent cause for not classifying a great game with R18+,

    Obviously I am being sarcastic

    Obviously, this decision is wrong

    Obviously, it is up to us to ensure that regulation bodies dont have the authority to RC rate games which obviously belong in the R18+ rage

    Obviously, we must be heard.

  11. it sucks so much that it had to be banned! my friend bought it before it was banned and now he's mocking me because i can't get it anymore. i wanted GTA3 so much but now my hopes of getting it are gone. Why? Anonymous -- 15/12/01

    it sucks so much that it had to be banned! my friend bought it before it was banned and now he's mocking me because i can't get it anymore. i wanted GTA3 so much but now my hopes of getting it are gone. Why?

  12. banning the game will start a large black market scandal between all of the gta fans. why not put an R18 restriction on it. Anonymous -- 15/12/01

    banning the game will start a large black market scandal between all of the gta fans. why not put an R18 restriction on it.

  13. What crap. If you don't want it, don't buy it. There are worse things to see on the Internet than this game can offer. Put an R18+ sticker on it and sell it. Oh, there is no such classification, well then the OFLC should get their finger out and Anonymous -- 17/12/01

    What crap. If you don't want it, don't buy it. There are worse things to see on the Internet than this game can offer.

    Put an R18+ sticker on it and sell it. Oh, there is no such classification, well then the OFLC should get their finger out and make one. We can't rely on outdated classifications anymore. Gamers around the world are growing up and the classifications should as well.

    I agree we should shelter children from this game hence the proposed R rating and I believe it is up to parents to see what their children are playing. With games costing around $90-$100, I bet parents should have some idea where their money is going.

    I think it boils down to the OFLC's procedures and classifications not being up to date to support the new era of adult gaming that is GTA 3.
    It is very unfortunate that this wonderful masterpiece has been caught up in this mess. The developers and all involved did a fantastic job creating the game.

  14. i know were you can order a full brand new pal copy of the game for rrp email me and i'll tell i don't want to post it here they might shutdown the site freedom is here boys we can all play the goverment can go get f**ke sahir -- 21/12/01

    i know were you can order a full brand new pal copy of the game

    for rrp

    email me and i'll tell i don't want to post it here they might shutdown the site

    freedom is here boys
    we can all play the goverment can go get f**ked

  15. thats terrible, i live in the UK, where the game is legal, and was the main reason i got a PS2, owning the other titles as well. its a great game, but thats what it is, a GAME! not real life. unless the board is saying that the australian audience are inc Red Oktober -- 13/01/02

    thats terrible, i live in the UK, where the game is legal, and was the main reason i got a PS2, owning the other titles as well. its a great game, but thats what it is, a GAME! not real life. unless the board is saying that the australian audience are incapable of distingusing the two. which i doubt. this will only drive the game underground, and increase piracy of the game. oh well, i've had my say.

    RED OKTOBER

  16. move to america Anonymous -- 03/01/03

    move to america

  17. I dont know why they would have to censor it as i own the amerecian verson and when u pick up a prostitute is that the car goes up and down like a yardie Lobo and if u look through the windows of the car nothing is happing. Anonymous -- 24/01/03

    I dont know why they would have to censor it as i own the amerecian verson and when u pick up a prostitute is that the car goes up and down like a yardie Lobo and if u look through the windows of the car nothing is happing.

  18. this is a reply to David williams. This game didn't actrully show any sex refferences it juust had a car go up and down but if u looked carefully nothing is happing in the car plus why were GTA 1&2 allowed it nealy the same only different in graffics. Anonymous -- 24/01/03

    this is a reply to David williams. This game didn't actrully show any sex refferences it juust had a car go up and down but if u looked carefully nothing is happing in the car plus why were GTA 1&2 allowed it nealy the same only different in graffics. Also even this game just came out and maybe banned The Getaway this has more violence and it actrully has nudity!

  19. This is for the anominious the one that wanted it and his friend got it before him by it from a market or import it from america and get your ps2 chiped. Thats what I did i have Gta 3 with prosts and vice city with prosts too. ? -- 24/01/03

    This is for the anominious the one that wanted it and his friend got it before him by it from a market or import it from america and get your ps2 chiped. Thats what I did i have Gta 3 with prosts and vice city with prosts too.

  20. Actually, I'm glad its censored... I'm sorry for everyone who wants an uncensored version, but the censored version seems a better idea to me. The only disadvantage is maybe a mission or two will be missing. And I'm 19 incase you think I'm some Anonymous -- 02/05/04

    Actually, I'm glad its censored...

    I'm sorry for everyone who wants an uncensored version, but the censored version seems a better idea to me. The only disadvantage is maybe a mission or two will be missing. And I'm 19 incase you think I'm some little kid who wants to buy this game.

Add your opinion


Latest Videos

Sponsored content

Power Centre - Content from our premier sponsors

Blogs

  • Renai LeMay Australian Govt funds IT start-ups
    This week Australia's Federal Government announced it had allocated $3.6 million in funding to 57 local research projects so that they could be commercialised, with many of them being web or IT-related start-ups.
  • Array Google should come clean on datacentres
    It's nice that Google says it has put an effort into making its datacentres more energy efficient, but the search giant's pledges won't mean much until it discloses just how many of the beasties it's actually running.
  • Array US shows what OPEL could have been
    Sprint's WiMAX roll-out in Baltimore will prove the Australian government's decision to worm its way out of the Opel WiMAX contract was a short-sighted, and ultimately damaging, political stunt that has benefited nobody.
  • More blogs »

Tags

Back to top

Featured