Famous fraudster claims ID cards help criminals

By Tom Espiner, ZDNet UK
26 October 2007 11:36 AM
Tags: access, access card, frank, fraud, id, id card, rsa, security

Frank Abagnale, a one-time fraudster who now works with law-enforcement agencies, said national ID card schemes make it "100 times easier" to steal personal information.

Speaking at the RSA Conference Europe 2007, Abagnale said that one weak link in an organisation can compromise the whole system.

I'm not big on ID cards.

Frank Abagnale

"With the ID cards scheme, all it takes is one weak civil servant to be bought off, and one weak link can [compromise the system]," said Abagnale. "I'm not big on ID cards -- you're giving the government information that someone else can access. ID cards make it 100 times easier to steal that information, because it's concentrated in one place.

"Nothing is really secure; if the money is right, you can forge a passport to back fraudulent activities -- you can forge ID cards. You can replicate holograms, dyes in paper, and give terrorists access to Britain."

Frank Abagnale RSA Conference Europe 2007

ID cards make it 100 times easier to steal that information, because it's concentrated in one place.

Abagnale's views back up research published earlier this month by the Australian National Audit Office (ANAO), which found that the proposed Access Card is unlikely to significantly reduce Centrelink fraud.

In Abagnale's keynote, he told the audience of security professionals about his experiences of being on the wrong side of the law, depicted in the 2003 film Catch Me If You Can, directed by Steven Spielberg and starring Leonardo DiCaprio as Abagnale and Tom Hanks as FBI agent Carl Hanratty.

Silicon.com's Gemma Simpson and ZDNet Australia's Jo Best contributed to this article.

Talkback 5 comments

    No big surprise! Keith Styles -- 26/10/07

    It is self evident, but Politicians, NGO's and Government bureaucracies aren't interested in experts views on an ID card. It's not in their best interests.
    An ID card gives all these people (including the scum bags of the world), access to so much information, it adds to their their crummy clutching grab for power.
    They ALL thrive on power and control being control freaks.

    It's an obvious statement of fact that:

    "Absolute power corrupts, absolutely!"

    A situation so many Politicians love to exploit!

    ID Cards Anthony Muscio -- 26/10/07

    There is a way to make ID cards secure, and It would be useful for health records and massive society wide tracking of medical use, procedures and results however large organisations always try to save money and this always diminishes the security. There will also be a loss of privacy unless laws protect it. How do you make a secure ID card, I'm not telling.

    Laws wont protect you! Keith Styles -- 26/10/07

    As I said in my opening post above, the power hungry types (& scum bags) can't wait to see the ID card introduced so they can exploit them.

    Any nerd in an IT department who thinks he can protect the ID card user is only protecting his own self interest.

    Laws will NOT protect anyone because the types waiting for the ID cards to be imposed on EVERYONE, DO NOT obey any laws!
    The current laws used by Centrelink & other bureaucracies are an abject failure, simply because way to many types have access to the data & the laws don't protect anyone already on these data banks.

    Forget it pal!

    Laws not required Anonymous -- 02/06/08 (in reply to #320088689)

    All social systems depend on laws, however I am talking about an ID card that does not have a unique number, that monitors both use and access and who's storage is distributed. Laws would ensure that the slightest variation in use could be detected and punished. This is most applicable when the laws apply primarily to public servants and can be enforced through law, internal policy and by liability and dismissal.

    Its already easy Anonymous -- 23/06/08

    If you want a false identity it is easier to do it under current systems than a well implemented card system.

    Typicaly naysayers commenting here do not understand the benefits of well implemented technology.

    Of course a smart card system can be implmented poorly and of course no matter how secure the card is someone can get a card under fraudulent pretexts...but this is already the case..many more people can get a legitimate ID under false pretenses at very low costs.

    Overall there will be a net reduction of fraudlent ID's its only aproblem if you then increase the rights of people who have one of these cards to be greater that is given to someone at the moment with a fraudulent ID.

Add your opinion

Latest Videos

Sponsored content

Power Centre - Content from our premier sponsors

Blogs

Tags

Back to top

Featured