Nation of hoarders: 30 million PCs rot in Australia

However, programs like this only address part of the problem, according to MRI's Le Messurier, who believes a tougher regulatory approach is required.

"Unfortunately the government hasn't regulated in this country to ensure there is a compulsory diversion from landfill, so we're still getting low recycling rates because the Australian consumer doesn't like the concept of paying for their recycling fees at the end of the product's lifecycle -- they want to pay it up front."

According to IT body the Australian Information Industry Association (AIIA)'s Byteback representative Josh Millen, greater regulation is exactly what's needed. Achieving a system which ensures PCs do not end up in landfill will require the involvement of Australian Customs, in conjunction with state and local governments. In effect, a national approach to the problem of e-waste.

Millen told ZDNet Australia that Byteback -- which is planned to end this year -- would like to see a national registry established, with hardware imports recorded by Customs so that PC manufacturers exporting goods to Australia can be tracked, in turn supporting the efforts of programs such as Byteback.

"Our main goal is developing appropriate safety net legislations and looking at a model for Customs to establish a national register and how Byteback would work under that," said Millen.

Salvaging the wreck
PCs lose value in storage because the most valuable item to take-back schemes is a working PC. After this come parts, such as CRT or LCD monitors, and salvageable materials such as steel or gold.

Cracking the CRT

MRI staff slice open CRT screens to salvage parts.
Credit: Liam Tung, ZDNet Australia

Today MRI receives AU$10 for every CRT screen it exports, representing a windfall of AU$200,000 per year but soon this window will close on the company, said Le Messurier.

The increasing availability of better quality consumer technology in MRI's export markets, such as Vietnam, the Philippines, China and some African countries, have caused consumers to turn away from these inferior goods.

"That gate will close over the next few months because our Asian neighbours are getting more discerning in their use of technology," he said.

After assessing the reusability of PCs, components containing metals are sorted and sent to South Korea. A low value circuit board, which contains steel and "a bit of gold", according to Le Messurier, attracts a price of AU$1,000 per tonne.

Staff use the board to separate low and high value items

Staff use the board to separate low and high value items.
Credit: Liam Tung, ZDNet Australia

"If you clean it up you could get more, but labour costs more than it's worth so we'd rather send it to a circuit board recycler in Korea," he said.

Australia also lacks the facilities to recycle certain toxic materials. Under Byteback, lead from CRTs is sent to the Netherlands, heavy metals from batteries are sent to France, printed circuit boards are sent to Canada, and LCD screens are sent to the US.

Although sending materials offshore for processing has been criticised due to the harmful effect that transport can have on benefits from recycling, Byteback claims that none of its non-recyclable materials are sent to developing countries with less stringent environmental regulations than Australia.

But to its credit, Byteback does divulge what materials need to be processed offshore, which company does the work and why -- an action that Dell, which claims the title "the greenest IT company in the world", is yet to take. And if UTS's Garlin is correct -- in saying that people will become more receptive to recycling PCs when they understand the impact of their decisions -- perhaps this type of transparency, along with government intervention, consumers will see the sense in waking up from the hoarding slumber to subscribe to the new mantra: reuse, recycle and reduce.

Advertisement

Talkback 7 comments

    Old PC's Anonymous -- 18/01/08

    I have lots - and they all work - and are doing things in my network - from an ancient 2650 system, through a Z80, 8080 (v20 version) 286, 386, DX4/100 - all just pottering away doing their tasks - reliably - in dos and linux.

    I dont need to follow the endless upgrade path - these do what I want, when I want.

    Sure - one day they will fail - but some have been running flawlessly now for 25 years - so I suspect they will out see my life.

    When that happens - I will be happy to will them to the recyclers.

    Several reasons Steve Roper -- 18/01/08

    I still have my old computers from the 80s and 90s - a Sinclair ZX81, VIC20, Commodore 64, Amiga 500 and Amiga 1200. All are still operational, and each is used for retrieving data from old storage media which modern drives cannot read. These computers also have nostalgia value, and my friends and I sometimes have "memory lane" evenings where we trot out our old computers and play the games of yesteryear.

    Old PCs I either cannibalise for parts or rebuild to give to friends and others who can't afford them, or who want an extra PC around the house for the kids. Even an old 486 is capable of running simple early-learning type games and chat/email under Windows 95. More recent models make good "backup" machines for our LAN evenings if somebody's computer is on the blink and they need a spare machine to join in.

    Re; Several reasons Adam -- 19/07/08 (in reply to #320093805)

    I will take them off your hands if you like, I am in Melbourne. Contact me at e_wate@y7mail.com if you are interetsed.

    Regards,

    No reason to upgrade. Matthew H Mckenzie -- 18/01/08

    There is really no particular reason to upgrade to any new hardware if your needs are currently filled. My parents purchased a business that was still keeping books using an Osborne Suitcase Computer running CP/M, and I concede that it had outlived its usefulness.

    Recently the purchase of school PC's was called into question when it was revealed that the platform was not up to the month, seriously, if it can't be done on Windows95 and Office2000, what on earth are they doing ?

    My kids run dual (at least) boot P!!!'s (1GHZ) and that will be adequate for at least another year. I have toddlers so I need to keep my Windows95 machine for the 640x480x256 games and software that would otherwise go to waste. Wipe the box and use a good TFT monitor and it is as good as new.

    We should only ever be milling the unserviceable machines, and recycling the rest. This does not mean your whole home or office needs to be a time capsule but there is no reason why you should not get 10 years out of a PC. If not you then someone else.

    Ebay, the dustheap of the world, is going a long way to help. You wouldn't shred a car after 3 years, why shred a computer ? I am not however about to defend anyone who hoards old hardware on the offchance it will ever again be used.... it should live and live in anger!

    ComputerBank Anonymous -- 18/01/08

    There are organisations, for example ComputerBank, that accept computers and computer parts. ComputerBank is a volunteer-based organisation. They use donated parts to build computers which are then donated to families in need as well as volunteer and community groups etc.

    Heart of a Geek Anonymous -- 19/01/08

    They just don't understand the heart of a geek. ^_^ It's like modellers that use every part of the sprue, or the indians that use every part of the Buffalo. If a machine is old, it can still be retasked as a file server, media machine, print server, an extra processing machine (for distributed processing) or similar. If people are still writing emulators for old machines such as the C64 and Apple IIc then it should hardly come as a surprise that we're keeping our old machines. Besides, as has already been said, if it does what you need it to, why throw it away?

    re old desktops Maureen New -- 14/03/08

    why is it not possible to give to the children of lesser advantages i am sure there are a lot of people that would love to have one of their own

Add your opinion

Latest Videos

Sponsored content

Power Centre - Content from our premier sponsors

Blogs

  • Suzanne Tindal Sick of broken tender sites
    Some of the state governments desperately need to invest in more user-friendly tender sites so that looking for information on government tenders doesn't have to be a game of blind man's bluff.
  • Array Cyberwar: What is it good for?
    In this week's episode, Cyberwar. What is Australia's place in the world of digital warfare? What are the implications for the NBN?
  • Array Is wholesale-only backhaul just a pipedream?
    The potential acquisition of Pipe Networks by SP Telemedia has raised the question about whether vertically integrated backhaul providers will mean higher wholesale prices for ISP customers.
  • More blogs »

Tags

Back to top

Featured