Apple iPhone - Everything you need to know about the Australian iPhone

ACCC warns 'iPhoners' on bill shock

Australia's competition watchdog has warned consumers to carefully consider their data allowances when using 3G mobile devices to avoid exorbitant excessive data charges, known in the industry as "bill shock".

The rise in popularity of 3G devices in Australia, and particularly with the release of Apple's iPhone 3G earlier this month, is expected to lead to a dramatic increase in the amount of data accessed through smartphones.

The Australian Competition and Consumer Commission (ACCC) today warned that while data allowances might have increased, consumers might not be fully aware of the consequences of over-spending.

"The ACCC is particularly concerned that consumers may be misled if they are not made sufficiently aware that their data allocations can be exceeded — at significant cost" says ACCC chairman Graeme Samuel.

"In the case of smartphones, consumers can download greater amounts of information from the internet than ever before. With this, comes the potential for them to exceed their phone plan value and incur considerable additional charges."

An example of this additional usage charge is found in Telstra's iPhone 3G information pamphlet. Telstra iPhone pricing suggests customers sign up to an AU$29 browsing pack which includes 80MB of included downloads. Every megabyte of data used each month in excess of this allocation will cost an additional AU$1.

The watchdog encouraged consumers who are new to accessing the internet via their mobile phones to make use of data usage meters provided by some of the carriers, or by accessing similar information on the handset itself. The iPhone 3G is an example of a recent release smartphone that tallies the owner's recent data usage.

Like this article? Click below to send it to your mobile for free!

Advertisement

Talkback 20 comments

  1. What do you expect Anonymous -- 22/07/08

    savvy show off consumers who only care about image instead of functionality will buy this device. If they are also dumb enough to choose the wrong plan and download dozens of songs each month regardless of carrier then I hope they cop a $10,000 bill.

  2. T Anonymous -- 22/07/08

    It's especially bad with telstra... "cough" 5meg plan "cough" +$1 per meg

  3. 1c/Kb Craig Ringer -- 22/07/08

    Telstra charge 1c/Kb on business phone contracts (and probably others) unless the user signs up for a Data Pack. That's $10/Mb or, at advertised HSDPA download rates of 7.2Mbit/s, around $32,000/hour. I can provide Telstra brochures that back this up (and show how deceptive their advertising is) by email if required.

    Phones are shipped to users with data unbarred even if the user selects no data pack. I had an exciting surprise with my N95, which I thought was being charged at the already insanely expensive $2/Mb, but was actually being charged at $10/Mb. Lucky I used it only a little.

    They force users to buy a Data Pack with iPhone plans (and possibly retail plans for other phones like the N95) but on business phone contracts seem to make no effort to warn the business or user of the costs. So: Watch out if you use an iPhone with a business plan SIM.

    1. Is this for real? Anonymous -- 22/07/08

      If I sign to a plan that has a 1Gb cap, then $0.12/Mb I will be looking at a bill of $3110.40/hr or $51.84/minute after my first 142 minutes or 1Gb is used.
      This can not be right!

    2. Where did you get 1c/Kb? a -- 22/07/08

      1c per kilobit = 8c per kilobyte = $80 per megabyte

      No company charges $80 per megabyte for wireless data usage

    3. Where did you get 1c/Kb? Anonymous -- 25/07/08

      Check teh fine print it can be even more expensive than this. i have seen up to 2.5C per kb on optus, I worked it out at $22,000 per gig. I even contacted the ACCC about their practices and lack of information and they said there was nothing they could do.

  4. IT'S THEFT Keith Styles -- 22/07/08

    Calling it bill shock is just a fancy way of labelling it... "THEFT" & one company is very good at it. I don't think I need to name the company!

    If you want high speed data, don't use the phone at all. Use the PC and a broadband plan which lets you have high download, using a company which doesn't rip you off with upload as well.

    . In other words, use the phone for what it's designed to do best, communicate,.. person to person, not substitute for a PC.

    If enough people do this, the telco's who overcharge will soon get the message.

  5. Selective facts Keith "lack of" Styles -- 22/07/08

    The first thing is that although the Telstra network is 7.2Mbps capable the average throughput is advertised as 550kbps to 1.3Mbps (69KBps - 162KBps). The Optus & Vodaphone network is half of this but they still advertise about the same throughput.

    Assuming there is 120KB/s they can download 432MB per hour. If someone is stupid enough to be on $1 per MB they pay $432 (1/74th of the amount all you intelligent people are claiming).

    If you go on a Telstra 3GB plan then excess usage is $108 per hour (1/296th of your preposterous claim)

    If you go on an Optus then excess usage is $151 per hour (1/212th of your laughable claim)

    1. IT'S STILL THEFT! Keith Styles -- 23/07/08

      It makes no difference what numbers you care to massage for excess usage, it's still theft! especially when they also charge for upload & more so when it's off peak!.
      Australian's pay through the nose for data usage, thanks to TEL$TRA, when they introduced their flawed & unreliable ADSL1 broadband a decade ago.
      We are the only users, with very few exceptions, who get ripped off for data usage, in the world, thanks to the monopoly control of one telco.

      and by the way, I at least use my name to comment, which is more than I can say for you.

    2. LMAO Keith "lack of" Styles -- 23/07/08

      Funny how Optus actually charges higher amounts for excess usage at the higher GB allowance plans meaning a user going 100MB over their 1GB allowance with Optus will end up paying more then if they had the same usage plan with Telstra.

      When you come up with anything that can't be discredited by my grandmother then you may get some agreeable replies instead of taking the mickey our of you.

      And why are you complaining about names? I am using your name to comment. :-p

    3. Flawed and unreliable ADSL Andrew Jones -- 23/07/08

      Isn't it funny how when Telstra is forced to release a product that wasn't ready because the government demanded that it get's released. A number of small companies complained that they wanted to sell this new technology and Telstra was not allowed to go through their normal testing process so the product was launched about 6 - 12 months earlier then they wanted. The problems everyone experienced would have been sorted out and a more reliable service would have been launched a little later. Instead problems in equipment, in processes and testing took a couple of years to fix because the problems were no longer in a test lab, they were in the real world. Yes the problems were a Telstra problem but they were caused because at the time the company had no courage to resist the undue pressure they got from external parties who did not care about anything outside of politics and destroying Telstra.

    4. Not that funny Darren -- 24/07/08

      "Funny how Optus actually charges higher amounts for excess usage at the higher GB allowance plans meaning a user going 100MB over their 1GB allowance with Optus will end up paying more then if they had the same usage plan with Telstra."

      I don't consider it very funny that on a like for like comparison between Optus and Telstra, Telstra's plans suck.

      Telstra - for $85 a month you get a free 8gig iphone, $70 calls and a whopping 5MB of data

      Optus - For $79 a month you get a free 8gig iphone ($2 more for 16 gig), $550 in calls and 700MB of data.

      So in other words with Optus you get 140 times more data. Oh but Telstra charges less per meg if you exceed the allowance you say? It doesn't matter how you try to spin it.. their plans are still sh*t. No wonder they've struggled to sell their stock.

    5. Lit's take a look Arthur -- 24/07/08

      Someone chooses to go on a 1GB plan with Telstra and the 700MB plan with Optus.

      Sure they get a capped call plan with Optus but the focus here is the data right.

      They use 1GB.

      With Telstra they pay $89 for the data plus $85 for the voice plan = $174.

      With Telstra they pay $79 for the voice and data plus $105 for the excess data = $184

      After this Telstra is 10c per MB cheaper.

      No matter how you try and spin the facts for some people Optus will be better for other Telstra will be better.

      No bias here, just plain not-for-profit facts

    6. Telstra will never be better Anonymous -- 24/07/08

      No because if you were with Optus and intended on downloading 1gig you'd either go on the 'yes' 99 plan (1gig) the 'yes' Timeless $129 plan which offers 2gig not to mention unlimited calls and text. Telstra is never better no matter which way you look at it

    7. The arguement at hand Arthur -- 24/07/08

      The whole point of the article is that many users will not be smart enough to choose the correct plan for their needs.

      Yes you are correct but only if someone is on the correct plan and never goes above their allowance.

      But if that was the case for all users this ACCC warning would only be a publicity stunt and a waste of time.

      Look at the real world and look at all posibilities.

    8. Selective facts Anonymous -- 25/07/08

      What people are saying is that Telstra dosn't give all teh information. Some people WILL buy an iPhone with a 5MB plan from Telstra and not realise that they are goign to be charged such a high cost for data. Excess is $10 a mb, if someone sends you an email with a 1 meg attachment thats 10 bucks you get charged. And how much does Telstra's 3GB plan cost?. And gee they only pay 432 bucks an hour. Wow thats good value. sign me up.
      All of teh costs that were mentioned in teh post you were refering to were correct. You have also presented selective facts.

    9. Anyone wanting an iPhone is stupid and deserves it give a nokia any day -- 25/07/08

      If you want to show how savvy you are and you have no idea about how you will use it then you deserve all you get.

    10. Challenge Keith "lack of" Styles -- 25/07/08

      Your argument is that the person buying the iPhone is stupid and would have no idea of how they will use it.

      I could spam you on you phone and even with a 3GB plan you could get charged excess usage so stop making up stupid hypothetical examples.

      Put together a spreadsheet and put each companies plans on it then work out how much you would pay based on each plan and different amounts of usage. I have seen this done for usage from 100MB to 5GB and eliminating obvious stupidity such as 1GB on a $5 plan you would be amazed at how easy those cheap Optus headline rates get beaten.

      The facts compare both companies and show the same facts on both so I can not see how this is selective.

      OH THAT'S RIGHT ANONYMOUS IS NEVER WRONG.

  6. Who in their right mind? Anonymous -- 22/07/08

    People talk about $32,000, $151 or $108. These people buy a device to last them 2 years or more and they only have 8GB / 16GB of storage. What do they plan on doing fill up the memory every day or every month and then delete it only to start again! Like most IT geeks with no knowledge of the real world you are all focusing on a simple number and not the way people will use these devices. Anyone can spin b.s. to make it sound as good or as bad as they want, when you look through all that brown stuff you will find that 99.99% of people will use the device and possibly download a few hundred MB or even a couple of GB but that's about it.

    Also the pricing plans are based on BYTES and not bits. If you want to pretend that you know what you are talking about then at least don't embarrass yourselves by using incorrect facts and figures.

    The only correct comment so far has been from Keith "lack of" Styles.

  7. Why the difference? Terry -- 22/07/08

    Why is there such a big difference between wireless internet (3G) plans and wireless data via a phone?

    For example, a 200MB Telstra wireless internet plan is $54.95 a month and $0.15 per MB thereafter.

    A $59 "browsing pack" for the IPhone gets you the same 200MB of data, but costs $0.25 per MB thereafter.

    Why does data over the same network cost so much more just because it goes through a phone instead of a wireless network card?

    This is what the ACCC really needs to investigate.

Add your opinion


Latest Videos

ZDNet's CIO Vision Series

Video | Optus CIO Lawrie Turner

In this exclusive video interview, Optus chief information officer Lawrie Turner speaks to ZDNet.com.au about being the IT head for Australia's number two telco.

Sponsored content

Power Centre - Content from our premier sponsors

Blogs

  • David Braue Telstra's BT coat doesn't fit
    The vision of the future BT portrayed this week at an Australian conference was so far removed from how Telstra's David Quilty has described the British telco that I wonder if they were talking about the same UK.
  • Array Australian security: the lucky country
    Does anyone seriously believe that Australian businesses and government agencies manage security any better than the US or UK?
  • Array Storage infrastructure on the tender track
    For a large-scale storage project, it's not uncommon to go out to tender for the best deal — but when was the last time you had to put together a tender for a document management room?
  • More blogs »

Tags

Back to top

Featured