Youth radio hammered over World Trade Centre digital photo

Digitally-enhanced photographs are becoming a popular feature of many consumer Web sites, with uses ranging from marketing and promotion to reader competitions. However, the use of a particularly sensitive image to promote a branding exercise for Australia's publicly-funded youth radio network has sparked outrage, fuelled by articles and polls run on some of the country's dominant news Web sites.

To promote a Beat the Drum competition -- a contest whereby listeners are encouraged to display the network's logo in prominent places -- Triple J posted on its Web site an image of the logo strung between the still-standing twin towers of the World Trade Centre.

The image was one of six digitally enhanced photographs of world icons, such as the Sydney Opera House and the Eiffel Tower in Paris, adorned with the drum logo.

However, use of the image has sparked outrage, with the News Ltd site news.com.au and the Publishing and Broadcasting's ecorp--Microsoft venture ninemsn.com.au running articles and polls on the radio network's move. Both polls ask whether the move is "insensitive". By early afternoon, on both polls, the yes responses outweigh the no replies by a small margin.

A source inside Triple J told ZDNet Australia   said the photos were not placed in the Web site to get more traffic or feedback from people or to be "provocative."

Instead, they were aiming to "encourage participants to think big for the competition."

The competition requires participants to take the drum logo and "expose it to as many people as possible as creatively as possible."

Triple J marketing manager Louis Rogers told ZDNet Australia  that as far as they knew there was only one person who complained about the image since it was posted on Friday. Rogers said they do not agree with the complainant's position and that they will not be taking the photo down.

"The purpose was to stimulate creativity in the minds of triple J's listeners, and to acknowledge the unlimited resourcefulness of our audience," Rogers said.

Rogers said the digitally altered photo was created internally and the station's management was aware that the twin towers were being used as a promotion.

The managing director of interface designing company Hiser Group, Susan Wolfe, said Triple J's use of the twin towers photo was "really poor taste and very tacky."

"It's very inappropriate. You would think their marketing folks would filter this sort of thing. I think it would be the right thing to do to take it down since all the other digitally altered photos already get the point across," Wolfe said.

Wolfe added that with people having the tools to play around with photos, it is very easy to alter images and use them in Web sites. However, she said, these images should also adhere to legal limits and, on this case, use images that are not emotionally charged.

The use of digital photographs is a popular tool among many leading Web sites. The football sub-site of leading United Kingdom news Web site Guardian Unlimited is one, frequently asking readers to send in digitally doctored photographs of major football personalities.

Advertisement

Talkback 13 comments

    Oh Please, even mentioning the ...Anonymous -- 10/08/04

    Oh Please, even mentioning the WTC is considered to be 'offensive' or 'bad taste' in the so PC US of A, and this bullocks is filtering into Australia.

    How about we think about the thousands of people killed by guns each year around the world. You don't see people getting upset becase the new driver game on the side of sydney public transport has a gun in.

    What a crock...Is it coming to ...Anonymous -- 10/08/04

    What a crock...Is it coming to the stage in the world that we aren't even allowed to be REMINDED of things that happened in the past for the fear that someone might shed a tear? People are reminded constantly day in and day out about traumatic and upsetting events in their lives, death of father, mother, family... Get over it, get on with your lives and let people USE their imaginations!

    i recon that the yanks should ...Anonymous -- 10/08/04

    i recon that the yanks should just pull their heads in. it has been a long time now since the wtc devistated the world..get on with life it is not going to bring the dead back..ans wat are we going to do..cut all the movies that were made before the event that have a picture of the trade centre in it...go JJJ

    Once again we have the yanks t ...Anonymous -- 10/08/04

    Once again we have the yanks trying to cram their ideas down our necks.
    Until the FTA totally destroys our way of life due to our inheriting US based laws we are still a soverign nation ruled from within - NOT RULE FROM WITHOUT.
    You dont like it Yankee Doodle then pull your head in and go home because this is our bit of space.

    So the Eiffel Tower, Opera Hou ...Anonymous -- 11/08/04

    So the Eiffel Tower, Opera House, Australian Parliament House and NASA Shuttle all pass without a mention while the Trade Center is objectionable?

    I guess that says everything.

    Well, I guess if you folks are ...Anonymous -- 11/08/04

    Well, I guess if you folks are going to assume all Americans feel this way (based on some of the comments here), it will also be OK if I assume you're all just like Steve Irwin and Paul Hogan?

    Cheers.

    I could give a dann ;-) It's o ...Anonymous -- 11/08/04

    I could give a dann ;-)

    It's only a pic, come'on!

    PS I'm from the US and I have a sister living in AU :-)

    On a space shuttle - how insen ...Anonymous -- 12/08/04

    On a space shuttle - how insensitive!!! Doesn't Triple J realise a couple of space shuttles blew up and people perished. Add that one to the list of unmentionables. I imagine some people have jumped from the Eiffel Tower, so scratch that one off as well.

    What a lot of rubbish about no ...Anonymous -- 13/08/04

    What a lot of rubbish about nothing. Why don't these complainants do something positive for humanity rather than waste everyone's time.

    So what? Maybe JJJ should have ...Anonymous -- 13/08/04

    So what? Maybe JJJ should have used images of U.S. caused 'collateral damage'. Nobody would be screaming bad taste if an image of a bombed was on CNN

    Hey it works though - JJJ got ...Anonymous -- 26/08/04

    Hey it works though - JJJ got the free publicily for their comp...

    I'm a listener of Triple J and ...Anonymous -- 22/09/04

    I'm a listener of Triple J and out of interest I typed 'Beat the Drum' into Google to see what people were doing. This was one of the options. I don't find the image of the Towers distaseful at all. Compared with the continuous images we've all seen of the collapsed towers as well as the horrific aftermath of it all, I can honestly say that I find this altered image easier to look at than pictures of the actual event. Who knows, if more people do as I did and come across this article, you may just win the competion for yourselves! Oh, the irony.

    Just how much more paranoid an ...Anonymous -- 30/09/04

    Just how much more paranoid and politically correct are we going to get in this country? I see images of the World Trade Centre in movies all of the time, should we stop showing those movies? It would be different if the enhanced photographed depicted the Twin Towers at the point of impact or collapse - THAT would be in poor taste. Prior to that moment, the WTC was just a landmark. Lighten up, grow up and stop trying to gag freedom of expression and speech.

Add your opinion

Latest Videos

Sponsored content

Power Centre - Content from our premier sponsors

Blogs

  • Phil Dobbie Is wholesale-only backhaul just a pipedream?
    The potential acquisition of Pipe Networks by SP Telemedia has raised the question about whether vertically integrated backhaul providers will mean higher wholesale prices for ISP customers.
  • Array Get extensions going in Firefox, redux
    Previously on Null Pointer we looked at getting extensions working in Firefox betas, and that was great until the fine folks at Firefox changed their minds.
  • Array How reliable is IP telephony?
    Have you ever heard a weird kind of hissing, crackling or popping noise when calling someone on an IP telephony line? How rare is the phenomenon these days?
  • More blogs »

Tags

Back to top

Featured