Vodafone backs away from 2G advice

By Suzanne Tindal, ZDNet.com.au
08 September 2009 01:23 PM
Tags: vodafone, drop outs, 2g, 3g, upgrade, mills

Vodafone has said that advice given by one of its employees to IT labour hire firm 3W joint CEO Bruce Mills that that he should switch his BlackBerry fleet to slower 2G services to avoid drop-outs was inaccurate.


(Credit: Blackberry Bold, by edans, CC2.0)

Mills said yesterday on Twitter that he had just been told to switch the fleet over to the 2G networks to stop call drop-outs across the country. "Not a great solution," he tweeted.

Mike Casey, director of graduate recruitment company GradConnection, replied. "I have the same problem. Tempted to move."

When asked for further detail on the issue, Mills told ZDNet.com.au that his employees were constantly getting drop-outs on different models of Blackberry handset — Storm, Curve and Bold — in North Sydney, Redcliffe (Queensland) and also at the Microsoft Partner Conference on the Gold Coast last week. He maintained that many delegates he spoke to there were having the same problem.

"[The phones] do everything, email, Twitter, Facebook. Problem is they lack one feature, the ability to make reliable phone calls," he said.

He said he rang Vodafone Corporate Support to find out what was going on. "[I] got told they are upgrading the network over the last month and the upgrades are continuing. They suggested I switch all the phones to 2G," he said, adding that the Vodafone employee had told him they did the same for reliability.

A spokesperson for Vodafone said that the upgrade was definitely finished on 31 August, and that there were no planned disruptions to 2G or 3G services, so the advice wouldn't have been accurate.

"It's certainly not a message that we are communicating to customers," the spokesperson said. "VHA has carefully planned the Vodafone network upgrade to ensure a smooth transition to 3G services, with minimal disruption to customers."

The Vodafone spokesperson highlighted that to access Vodafone's 3G services in regional and metropolitan areas, customers needed a 3G 900MHz mobile.

Mills' BlackBerry devices are 2100Mhz compatible but not 900Mhz compatible, according to the Vodafone website. However, North Sydney, Redcliffe and the area of the Gold Coast where Microsoft's Conference was held are all covered by 2100MHz, according to Vodafone's coverage maps.

Last week, VHA also had an outage last week in Perth due to a 3G network fault which dogged the higher speed services but left those running on 2G unscathed.

Advertisement

Talkback 6 comments

    blackberry vs iphone Anonymous -- 08/09/09

    you think blackberries drop out... my iphone drops out constantly!!

    happy storm customer Anonymous -- 08/09/09

    My BlackBerry storm with Vodafone works a treat from Geelong to Brisbane on one charge.

    Vodafone dropouts Anonymous -- 09/09/09

    Here in Coffs harbour we have not had any Vodafone coverage at all for two days! The coverage in ourarea has always been poor and has been declining rapidly in the last three months. 3G was turned on 31/8 with marginal improvements in coverage but now we have nothing at all! so much for minimal disruption. Regional customers are being treated like second class citizens.

    Bold on Optus netowork does the same thing Anonymous -- 09/09/09

    I switched my bold to 2G (unless i'm surfing internet) many months ago to avoid this issue. I spend most of my time in Nth Syd too.

    Bold Dropouts in Melbourne Anonymous -- 18/10/09

    Got the same thing happening. About to change carrier to the dreaded T because I cannot have my phone dropping out on every other call. Blackberry Bold on Vodafone in Port Melbourne. Not amused.

    bold on 3 Anonymous -- 25/11/09

    have no issues with calls on bberry bold on the 3 network unless I happen to be on a call when leaving 3 coverage and entering telstra roaming coverage (obviously it's difficult to transfer a call from one physical network to another). I have no issues when on a call on phone switches from 3G Roaming (Next G) to 2G Roaming. Perhaps Vodafones 2G network can't support the same packet structure as it's 3G network... thereby requiring the phone to drop the call and redial... sad if that's the case!

Add your opinion

Latest Videos

Sponsored content

Power Centre - Content from our premier sponsors

Blogs

  • David Braue All I want for Xmas is Telstra pricing
    Five consecutive days without broadband has led me to what seemed at the time to be an act of desperation: contemplating signing up for Telstra's 100Mbps cable modem service.
  • Array Sick of broken tender sites
    Some of the state governments desperately need to invest in more user-friendly tender sites so that looking for information on government tenders doesn't have to be a game of blind man's bluff.
  • Array Cyberwar: What is it good for?
    In this week's episode, Cyberwar. What is Australia's place in the world of digital warfare? What are the implications for the NBN?
  • More blogs »

Tags

Back to top

Featured